Genuine curiosity - stolen car back up for sale online
Genuine curiosity - stolen car back up for sale online
Author
Discussion

aceofspades1

Original Poster:

356 posts

45 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
As titled this is more of a pure curiosity question rather than a legal question, as the car has already been paid out by insurance and is nothing to do with us.

My dad's car was stolen back in July. Insurers gave a very fair offer which we took straightaway.

I did do some checking a couple of days after and as expected, it came up with a stolen marker when I checked the reg online.

I was browsing online earlier today and to my absolute shock, my car was listed for sale online at a dealer, with no mention of any theft, just a totally normal car advert. I've done a HPI check on it and there's no CAT N stolen recovered marker, you would never know it had been stolen. Except...... there are 24,000 more miles on the clock. It was on 49k when it left us, it's now on 73k and this is reflected in a photo of the mileage on the ad and the fresh MOT that has been done.

How on earth is this possible? I've done the math and the thieves would have had to do 200+ miles a day in it. It still has the dealer tailgate sticker, so I don't think the car is cloned unless they've stuck just the tailgate on....

I've been racking my brain for hours and I'm still baffled.

tomsugden

2,425 posts

252 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
I'm guessing the car you're looking at is a stolen car cloned with the identity of your old car.

aceofspades1

Original Poster:

356 posts

45 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all

Bill

57,434 posts

279 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
aceofspades1 said:
How on earth is this possible? I've done the math and the thieves would have had to do 200+ miles a day in it. It still has the dealer tailgate sticker, so I don't think the car is cloned unless they've stuck just the tailgate on....
How sure are you that you're not misremembering your old registration???

That's seems the most likely explanation given the lack of insurance marker and significant increase in miles.

macron

12,807 posts

190 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
Link to the ad........

Auto810graphy

1,611 posts

116 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
That no looks like a V-Check rather than an HPI. V-Check is not totally reliable so it may be on a real HPI report as stolen recovered.

Audimercorbm

142 posts

74 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
I was looking at a car the other day which the dealer said had a stolen recovered marker on it. But was not a cat n
On the v check it comes up with the salvage history which says it was stolen recovered
No idea why it wasn't a cat car though

Defcon5

6,460 posts

215 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
Could someone have had to change the instrument cluster if it was recovered without the keys? Replacing it with a set showing a higher mileage?

zedx19

3,022 posts

164 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
Link to advert?

aceofspades1

Original Poster:

356 posts

45 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
I'm happy to DM anyone a link to the advert, I think as per the rules you can't post links to adverts.



It's 100% the same car, you can see the sudden jump in the MOT history.

I'm now thinking it was hotwired and they've had to replace the instrument cluster... seems the only logical answer!

Hugo Stiglitz v2

444 posts

18 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
You're not advertising the car though??!!

Otherwise the high mileage topic wouldn't exist.

Stop teasing.

aceofspades1

Original Poster:

356 posts

45 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
Hugo Stiglitz v2 said:
You're not advertising the car though??!!

Otherwise the high mileage topic wouldn't exist.

Stop teasing.
I'm the original poster who started the thread. It COULD be seen as trying to boost an advertisement and that wasn't the intention, just curiosity.

If you want to DM me, I'm more than happy to share the link to the advert.

Plus - I don't really want 100+ people seeing the exact advert and one of them potentially tipping off the dealer. Remember, my dad's name and address is probably within the service history!

Edited by aceofspades1 on Thursday 24th October 08:17

Danm1les

980 posts

164 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
aceofspades1 said:
Remember, my dad's name and address is probably within the service history!
It shouldn't be, as per GDPR. I've seen stacks and stacks of service history destroyed due to GDPR.

ABMA

176 posts

44 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
Mark McCann posted a video on YouTube earlier this week (apparently deleted now) where he interviewed one of those professional car theft gangs.
So that’s exactly what happens: a stolen car is given a clean title and goes back to sale with legitimate papers.
Very very sad.

zedx19

3,022 posts

164 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
ABMA said:
Mark McCann posted a video on YouTube earlier this week (apparently deleted now) where he interviewed one of those professional car theft gangs.
So that’s exactly what happens: a stolen car is given a clean title and goes back to sale with legitimate papers.
Very very sad.
How though?

Truckosaurus

12,940 posts

308 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
Does the 'stolen' check only show for unrecovered vehicles?

If the OP's car was tracked down and then sold into the trade there would be no need to mark it as stolen any more.

It's in the insurance industry's interest to not permanently mark recovered cars as they will get more money when they sell the cars into the trade.

ABMA

176 posts

44 months

Thursday 24th October 2024
quotequote all
zedx19 said:
ABMA said:
Mark McCann posted a video on YouTube earlier this week (apparently deleted now) where he interviewed one of those professional car theft gangs.
So that’s exactly what happens: a stolen car is given a clean title and goes back to sale with legitimate papers.
Very very sad.
How though?
I wish if I could find the link to post.

Simply they find an identical car with clean title (likely unregistered loss/ damage/ irreparable and use its details (VIN).
They even engrave the ViN into the stolen car, input the VIN into the ECU. There are other details but this is more or less what they do.