Is this too much for an F56 JCW?
Is this too much for an F56 JCW?
Author
Discussion

Chris-1e43g

Original Poster:

49 posts

56 months

Yesterday (15:26)
quotequote all
I’m looking at a 2015 manual JCW 3 door hatch for sale privately with around 60k miles on. The asking price is £13k but looking at the value sites and other cars for sale that looks a bit steep?

It is a really nice and quite rare spec, manual and fully loaded with extras so assume that might knock the price up a bit but I’m still thinking that should be going more for around £11k for a private sale?

It’s also due a service next month, last service was nov 2023 but it’s only done 2k miles since then, and to keep the service schedule happy it should have another one within 2 years.

What are your thoughts?

ZX10R NIN

29,578 posts

143 months

Yesterday (15:39)
quotequote all
Go & view it if you still feel its worth the money then buy it, or find one for 11k that meets your requirements.

macron

12,205 posts

184 months

Yesterday (22:12)
quotequote all
I have a feeling a seller like that will want to try and negotiate over the service alone.

IME most "fully loaded" actually aren't, a few packs gets a lot, but sometimes it's silly things like a heated rear window blanked on the panel, which was something like £160. Weird to not tick that but to have the HUD, pan roof and HK etc. Arguably not having an auto box (obvs a cost option) means it isn't as loaded as it could be.

Post the spec, we'll soon find out!

macron

12,205 posts

184 months

Yesterday (22:21)
quotequote all
AF56JCW? Apparently a plate worth £2k? Err no it really isn't.

Heathwood

2,891 posts

220 months

Yesterday (22:38)
quotequote all
It does sound a tad punchy, but if the specs as good as you suggest and it’s in excellent condition, then it might be (almost) justified.

For reference I paid £14.7k for an 18 plate LCI JCW with a good spec on 49k miles a couple of weeks ago from a very good dealer.

Jamescrs

5,585 posts

83 months

My view is if I was selling a car at 13k and you offered me 11 I’d just ask you to leave again.
If as you say there are other cars at 11k then I’d be suggesting you go and look at those instead.

ChrisH72

2,636 posts

70 months

Spec varies so much on these that valuation is difficult.

Looking on AT I can't see much at 11k so I think you'd be knocked back on that offer. Offers over 12k would seem reasonable if you really like the car.

Chris-1e43g

Original Poster:

49 posts

56 months

Thanks for the replies, gives me more to think about. I was just comparing cars for the same price that have a bit less mileage but are dealer cars therefore get at least some warranty but maybe I shouldn’t be assuming that private should be cheaper?

As for spec it has pretty much every option ticked. Heated windscreen, even adaptive cruise which very few have. The addition of it being a manual too i think is pretty rare.

I think the rarity is the reason for the asking price.

SFTWend

1,233 posts

93 months

Chris-1e43g said:
Thanks for the replies, gives me more to think about. I was just comparing cars for the same price that have a bit less mileage but are dealer cars therefore get at least some warranty but maybe I shouldn t be assuming that private should be cheaper?

As for spec it has pretty much every option ticked. Heated windscreen, even adaptive cruise which very few have. The addition of it being a manual too i think is pretty rare.

I think the rarity is the reason for the asking price.
I didn't think you could have adaptive cruise with a manual gearbox.

AT and other sites provide guide valuations. I'd expect to save at least a grand buying privately with no warranty etc. At 10 years old I'd prioritise condition, mileage and maintenance history over spec. Everything else being equal, maybe a grand difference between a very low spec and very high spec.

Check the JCW spec for that year as sellers like to list items, intimating they were options, when they were part of the standard spec.