New small car for a 78 year old
New small car for a 78 year old
Author
Discussion

Gone a bit AMG

Original Poster:

7,317 posts

220 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Hello folks,

The old dear wants a new car, her Citroen C3 was brand new when we bought it 8 years ago but she’s worried about a major failure and would like a new car, possibly her last but hopefully not.

Essentials:
Hybrid, petrol possibly full electric but not keen on full electric.
Ideally no more than a few cm wider than the C3
Automatic
High seating position-really important.

I’m taking her out on Friday to have a look at a few. Hence suggestions needed. We will either HP or PCP this and the budget in that case 300ish ideally less per month but we have around 3k deposit.

Hyundai Inster, I like but Mum’s not seen one yet, she’s gone Toyota Aygo. This isn’t my area of expertise so I’d appreciate any advice.


ThingsBehindTheSun

3,150 posts

54 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Higher seating position suggest an SUV? If so, how about an MG ZS Hybrid. If that is too big and an SUV isn't required how about an MG3 Hybrid. The Trophy is the model to go for and isn't much more per month.

Have to say an 8 year old car is basically new to me, I am sure it will last for years.

Danm1les

979 posts

163 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Kia Soul? We have one and of the various older passengers that have been in it, they have always said the seating position is great and the visability.

Oberheim

571 posts

14 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
A Toyota Yaris Cross or Toyota Aygo X might fit the bill.

CMTMB

976 posts

18 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
My parents (late 70s) drive a Kia Niro and really like it. Small enough without being tiny, higher seating position without being an SUV. Hybrid auto is a piece of cake to drive and very economical, long warranty etc

paul_c123

1,872 posts

16 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
It has to be a Honda Jazz or Nissan Micra.

PistonBroker

2,694 posts

249 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
My Mum's 73 and is on her 4th or 5th Jazz. Loves them.

It occurs to me she didn't fit the profile in the early noughties when she got her first one, but clearly does now!

ZX10R NIN

30,026 posts

148 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Kia Soul

blue_haddock

4,853 posts

90 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Oberheim said:
A Toyota Yaris Cross or Toyota Aygo X might fit the bill.
Yep my first thought was a Toyota as well

andy43

12,574 posts

277 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
blue_haddock said:
Oberheim said:
A Toyota Yaris Cross or Toyota Aygo X might fit the bill.
Yep my first thought was a Toyota as well
+1. Yaris Cross is easy to get into, indestructible and has a 10 year warranty if it's serviced annually. Or Jazz but I think you sit a bit lower in those.

robsa

2,444 posts

207 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
As well as the Aygo X or Honda Jazz Cross thingy, what about the Suzuki Ignis? It's tall, very well priced, they have loads of kit for the cash and Suzuki have an excellent reliability record.

Pica-Pica

16,073 posts

107 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
paul_c123 said:
It has to be a Honda Jazz or Nissan Micra.
Jazz is the one. I am a similar age and tried one - a very good vehicle. But I could not part from my 335d. (My wife still hankers after an Alfa)

andburg

8,562 posts

192 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Would a Dacia spring be any use? Small, upright, cheap and 100 real world miles might suffice

mike13

767 posts

205 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
ThingsBehindTheSun said:
Higher seating position suggest an SUV? If so, how about an MG ZS Hybrid. If that is too big and an SUV isn't required how about an MG3 Hybrid. The Trophy is the model to go for and isn't much more per month.

Have to say an 8 year old car is basically new to me, I am sure it will last for years.
Mg3 drivers seat sheared in safety tests, wouldn’t have one for free!

Mr_Megalomaniac

1,164 posts

89 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
78 years old....
This perhaps?



Jokes aside, Hyundai i20 and i10 are good small cars albeit non-hybrid. i30 has the hybrid drive train.
Audi A3, BMW 1 series, Ford Puma, Suzuki Swift are probably some of the more interesting and well rounded offerings in my opinion.

rlg43p

1,558 posts

272 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
A lot of the reason people think a higher driving position is desirable is because of visibility.

In a Jazz the bonnet drops away sharply and the windscreen is BIG, hence forward visibility is extraordinary.

So she should test drive one. I bet she would love it.

cliffords

3,627 posts

46 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
rlg43p said:
A lot of the reason people think a higher driving position is desirable is because of visibility.

In a Jazz the bonnet drops away sharply and the windscreen is BIG, hence forward visibility is extraordinary.

So she should test drive one. I bet she would love it.
The higher seat position is because as you get older it's much more difficult to get in and out of conventional height salon cars . Visibility is a bonus but not why the elderly like a higher car . I like a higher car .

tgr

1,216 posts

194 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Fiat Panda

macron

12,772 posts

189 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
Jazz..... Cross Star.

Aygo X.


Pica-Pica

16,073 posts

107 months

Wednesday 28th January
quotequote all
cliffords said:
The higher seat position is because as you get older it's much more difficult to get in and out of conventional height salon cars . Visibility is a bonus but not why the elderly like a higher car . I like a higher car .
The H-point (hip joint position) on a Jazz is probably about where it was in most 1950s cars, that is, at a comfortable position. Only in the late 1950s, early 1960s, did the H-point become lower. Fashion and styling, I assume