Recommend me a new family car
Recommend me a new family car
Author
Discussion

RTaylor2208

Original Poster:

197 posts

186 months

Friday 20th March
quotequote all
I'm in a fairly fortunate position at the moment that we have 3 cars in the house hold.

1. 2015 BMW 520d Gran Turismo Msport 65K miles
2. 2008 Porsche Cayman 145K miles
3. 2026 Renault Meganne Etech < 1k miles

So far I'm covered on the diesel, petrol and leccy propelled vehicles.

The BMW does the family duties of longer journeys or when we need the space of a big car, the Porsche the majority of the time is a driveway ornament but its nice to have something a bit more fun to drive when I feel like it and don't need to ferry anything but me +1 around.

The Renault is the Mrs daily on a sal-sac scheme, but I find myself using it for local running around when she's not using it. Its fine but nothing to get excited about driving.

The BMW genuinely has been and is a great car for what we needed it to do, cheap to run, reliable, a nice place to sit and loads of room when we need it. But I'm getting the itch to change it after owning it the last 6 years.

Budget is £20k + whatever I might get for the BMW based on what's for sale and in what condition, I reckon its worth somewhere in the region of 10K.

What I am struggling with is what to replace it with, ideally something that is newer but not too dissimilar, I quite like the look of the 6 GT as its pretty much a newer version of the same car or the Tesla Model S but what else am I missing? Any gems out there in the big car field that I am not thinking of without going for a SUV thing or that comes with eye watering servicing costs.

I'm not keen on VW group stuff, some bigger Audi's (A6, A7) I like but the rest I couldn't live with the interiors.

Pickle_Rick

751 posts

85 months

Friday 20th March
quotequote all
Lexus LS or Genesis g80?

Potential 10 year warranty on the lexus

RTaylor2208

Original Poster:

197 posts

186 months

Friday 20th March
quotequote all
Thanks for the suggestions, the Lexus looks promising.

I know the GT isn't thought as as a good looking car, and car taste is subjective but I couldn't part with my own money to a Genesis G80.


fflump

3,185 posts

63 months

Saturday 21st March
quotequote all
As your budget is around £30k I’d look at the E53 estate or late E43.

MR2 Steve

376 posts

132 months

Saturday 21st March
quotequote all
S4 Avant
RS4 Avant
C43/C63 estate
X3 M40i
F Pace 3.0S or SVR
330i estate
M340i estate
540i estate

RTaylor2208

Original Poster:

197 posts

186 months

Monday 23rd March
quotequote all
I appreciate the responses, some of the engine choices a bit questionable with my requirement of reasonable service and maintenance costs though.

I'm not looking for something fast as such, 0-60 <8s is fine but I don't really need anything with more than 200-250HP.

Rob 131 Sport

4,528 posts

77 months

Tuesday 24th March
quotequote all
A G30 5 Series or an Audi A6 50TDI. I’ve owned the former in 3.0 form (and the 2.0 is also great). I’ve also driven extensively the Audi in 3.0 form and could really recommend them. I wasn’t as keen on the 2.0 A6.

RTaylor2208

Original Poster:

197 posts

186 months

Tuesday 24th March
quotequote all
Rob 131 Sport said:
A G30 5 Series or an Audi A6 50TDI. I ve owned the former in 3.0 form (and the 2.0 is also great). I ve also driven extensively the Audi in 3.0 form and could really recommend them. I wasn t as keen on the 2.0 A6.
I had a 520d G30 as a rental a while back when away for work and to be honest I wasn't that impressed. I think the GT I have rode better but that could be down to the rear air suspension.