Stick with what I've got or start afresh?

[Thatchman]

I've recently become a dad, boy that still sounds strange in my head and I'm in need of some car buying/selling advice. I've currently got a mk7 GTi pp auto which my other half really likes, mainly because of the gearbox, she's the complete opposite of a petrol head and hates driving. But I've never really gelled with it, I mean it's a great car but it's far from peak driving pleasure.

I've been thinking of selling the golf and getting a 130i e87 manual as nothing more than a evening/weekend/rare track/road trip with mates toy. I've also inherited an 06 polo auto which would become the ol'ball and chain 'shopping' car as she only drives locally, that's if I get round to fixing it. The problem I would then have is two small cars and all the detritus that comes with a new born, I'm already finding the golf too small and I don't think the 1series would be any bigger/better

The golf needs a fair of tlc before it goes anywhere but should I replace it, it's kinda does everything? Ideally I'd get rid of both VWs and get a 5series or van as a family car but the misses wouldn't drive either.

I've also got an mx5 which Is reserved for drift/track stuff but I fell like I've outgrown it as a road car that and it's real beat now, but the 1series feels like a more adult version, with back seats and stuff.

Should I stay or should I go? If anyone has had either id appreciate your input or if you've got any fun dad car suggestions.

[Rob 131 Sport]

I’d keep the Golf. Most of the ‘must have’ paraphernalia associated with babies is unnecessary. I’ve got 3 children (now grown up) so should know.

[Monkeylegend]

Rob 131 Sport said:

I d keep the Golf. Most of the must have paraphernalia associated with babies is unnecessary. I ve got 3 children (now grown up) so should know.

It is a well known fact that the more space you have available the more rubbish you will fill it with.

[Davie]

Only you'll know the answer. So many factors to consider... like are you even going to have time / interest in something fast road / weekend orientated so will it just sit unused, frustrating you? Also, the amount of stuff you need is directly proportional to the life you live - if you barely venture beyond the local corner shop, you'll be fine but if you're away on trips / travelling to family etc, different set of needs.

I'd probably get one, decent all rounder... Golf R estate / 340i / S4 sort of thing, but I say that but I soon got tired of trying to run something 'nice' so ended up with an old Volvo estate and then a van. I still hanker over something 'fun' but just now, time for such things is in short supply.

Your choice.

[Rob 131 Sport]

Monkeylegend said:

Rob 131 Sport said:

I d keep the Golf. Most of the must have paraphernalia associated with babies is unnecessary. I ve got 3 children (now grown up) so should know.

It is a well known fact that the more space you have available the more rubbish you will fill it with.

And don’t get me started on unnecessary roof boxes and badly packed boots.

[Blue_star]

I recommend a suv for family duties. A lot easier to get the baby in and out while keeping your back health. Sounds like you have a fun car already anyway.

Size wise golf is adequate if your pram fits.

[Belle427]

A roof box on the golf will solve space issues on trips.
Not everyone's cup of tea though but something we use now on a smaller hatchback car for holidays since giving up a larger vehicle.
I loved an estate car as a family though, just made things a lot easier but as others have said you cope with what you have if you try.