Wildly different online valuations
Wildly different online valuations
Author
Discussion

AudiMan9000

Original Poster:

822 posts

79 months

Yesterday (14:45)
quotequote all
I’m 2.5 years into a 4 year PCP on a Mazda CX-5.

I’m looking to get out of it and into an EV.

Settlement figure is £22k.

Confused value it at £20k.

WBAC value at £13k.

Why such a huge difference?

The 3 year warranty expires in April 2027. That’s when the 4th and final year of the PCP begins.

When is it worth going to dealerships to see about part-ex and starting a new PCP, without being told I’m “upside down”?

shtu

4,610 posts

177 months

Yesterday (14:48)
quotequote all
AudiMan9000 said:
Confused value it at £20k.

WBAC value at £13k.

Why such a huge difference?
One is an insurance valuation, one is a famously low-ball car buying service.

Mr_Megalomaniac

1,296 posts

97 months

Yesterday (16:14)
quotequote all
shtu said:
One is an insurance valuation, one is a famously low-ball car buying service.
This.
How do you think WBAC makes its money?
As it is I sold an Honda through them once (pre-COVID); was brutally honest in the condition and quality, and they gave me the same amount when I turned up (actually like £50 more).

But I wouldn't consider them for selling anything valued higher than a few grand.

AudiMan9000

Original Poster:

822 posts

79 months

Yesterday (16:19)
quotequote all
I have no intention of selling to WBAC.

I need to know when I can realistically go to dealerships and not be told I’m upside down on my PCP.

Confused isn’t just for insurance. Their valuation was for the purpose of buying and selling. And according to them I’m only £2k upside down. Once I’m about £1k upside down, I can just clear that off out of my monthly wage as a deposit of sorts.

Cre4tive

50 posts

Yesterday (16:33)
quotequote all
AudiMan9000 said:
I have no intention of selling to WBAC.

I need to know when I can realistically go to dealerships and not be told I m upside down on my PCP.

Confused isn t just for insurance. Their valuation was for the purpose of buying and selling. And according to them I m only £2k upside down. Once I m about £1k upside down, I can just clear that off out of my monthly wage as a deposit of sorts.
Plug your details in here. This will be a CAP valuation and will give you trade, private sale, and retail.

https://hpivaluations.com/

Note that the actual initial quote, IIRC, assumes mileage, but you can then adjust that top right to get a more accurate quote.

AudiMan9000

Original Poster:

822 posts

79 months

Yesterday (16:42)
quotequote all
Cre4tive said:
AudiMan9000 said:
I have no intention of selling to WBAC.

I need to know when I can realistically go to dealerships and not be told I m upside down on my PCP.

Confused isn t just for insurance. Their valuation was for the purpose of buying and selling. And according to them I m only £2k upside down. Once I m about £1k upside down, I can just clear that off out of my monthly wage as a deposit of sorts.
Plug your details in here. This will be a CAP valuation and will give you trade, private sale, and retail.

https://hpivaluations.com/

Note that the actual initial quote, IIRC, assumes mileage, but you can then adjust that top right to get a more accurate quote.
That’s really help thanks! Glad I posted. That suggests a value of £18,560 max. So just under £4k negative equity. Hopefully I’ll have broken even by April and can get rid.

Cre4tive

50 posts

Yesterday (18:00)
quotequote all
AudiMan9000 said:
That s really help thanks! Glad I posted. That suggests a value of £18,560 max. So just under £4k negative equity. Hopefully I ll have broken even by April and can get rid.
No problem smile

Gives you a ballpark as to where you are, at least.

NAAHD

253 posts

56 months

Yesterday (20:36)
quotequote all
Mr_Megalomaniac said:
This.
How do you think WBAC makes its money?
As it is I sold an Honda through them once (pre-COVID); was brutally honest in the condition and quality, and they gave me the same amount when I turned up (actually like £50 more).

But I wouldn't consider them for selling anything valued higher than a few grand.
I saw a McLaren at one a few months back and couldn’t help think there must be a better way. Didn’t have a camera out so I don’t think filming a YouTube video or anything. Unless they have a special deal for newish supercars of course?

AddyT.

605 posts

124 months

Yesterday (21:14)
quotequote all
Usually you can terminate a PCP once you have paid 50% of the agreement which typically arrives at the 3 year mark, so you might find you can voluntarily terminate it at that point. I’ve done it at that point before and had no issues despite the fact the car was in negative equity at the time.

_Rodders_

5,200 posts

50 months

Yesterday (21:16)
quotequote all
AudiMan9000 said:
I m 2.5 years into a 4 year PCP on a Mazda CX-5.

I m looking to get out of it and into an EV.

Settlement figure is £22k.

Confused value it at £20k.

WBAC value at £13k.

Why such a huge difference?

The 3 year warranty expires in April 2027. That s when the 4th and final year of the PCP begins.

When is it worth going to dealerships to see about part-ex and starting a new PCP, without being told I m upside down ?
It's really not difficult.

One of them will actually give you some money.

Cre4tive

50 posts

Yesterday (21:32)
quotequote all
AddyT. said:
Usually you can terminate a PCP once you have paid 50% of the agreement which typically arrives at the 3 year mark, so you might find you can voluntarily terminate it at that point. I ve done it at that point before and had no issues despite the fact the car was in negative equity at the time.
Thats a very good point, given the timeline the O/P is on.

Also you dont have to have paid 50%, they can only ask you to pay 50% of the total transaction amount, so even if hes paid 45% it might be cheaper to pay the 5% than say £4K of equity.


Mr_Megalomaniac

1,296 posts

97 months

Yesterday (22:12)
quotequote all
NAAHD said:
I saw a McLaren at one a few months back and couldn t help think there must be a better way. Didn t have a camera out so I don t think filming a YouTube video or anything. Unless they have a special deal for newish supercars of course?
Could have been one of the owner's cars perhaps?

AudiMan9000

Original Poster:

822 posts

79 months

Yesterday (22:44)
quotequote all
Cre4tive said:
AddyT. said:
Usually you can terminate a PCP once you have paid 50% of the agreement which typically arrives at the 3 year mark, so you might find you can voluntarily terminate it at that point. I ve done it at that point before and had no issues despite the fact the car was in negative equity at the time.
Thats a very good point, given the timeline the O/P is on.

Also you dont have to have paid 50%, they can only ask you to pay 50% of the total transaction amount, so even if hes paid 45% it might be cheaper to pay the 5% than say £4K of equity.
Turns out I’ll hit the VT point in April/May 27.