elise to noble logical progression ?
elise to noble logical progression ?
Author
Discussion

poptosis

Original Poster:

850 posts

275 months

Wednesday 21st February 2007
quotequote all
Afternoon gents,

So clearly you are all bloody quick but my knowledge of these cars doent extend much further than that really at the moment. The alure is strong though. My question is should I be looking at a Noble more closely and what are the prinicple differences I might expect from ownership? Is it possible to use the car on a daily basis?

My current steed does most jobs pretty well. It is fine over distance, very reliable and cheap to run. Is all that going to go out the window if I leave lotus?

Your thoughts and experience would be gratefully appreciated. There are so few cars out ther its tricky to do first hand research at this stage and I am loathed to waste some private sellers time to muse over his pride and joy that they are trying to part with.

Im hoping for a daily commute that I can spank on the track a few times a year.

Regards,

pop

gadgeroonie

5,362 posts

265 months

Wednesday 21st February 2007
quotequote all
lots on here including me have gone from a Lotus to a Noble M12

think of it as an elise with all the power you could dream of and sweeter handling

it has a few creature comforts also like air con !!

mine is not a daily driver(neither was my elise) - lots of people on here do use them every day

my suggestion would be to buy a nice cheap diesel turbo as a work horse and enjoy your Noble

mgbond

6,749 posts

261 months

Wednesday 21st February 2007
quotequote all
In my 1.5yrs ownership I have found it to be a lot more expensve than my old Elise.

However I did buy a 2.5 with std diff which failed 3 months later (a Known problem) and a couple of other things.

Just look on here for the advice but try to get at least a GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy

F.C.

3,901 posts

237 months

Wednesday 21st February 2007
quotequote all
Elise / Exige on steroids.
Heavier on Fuel, Tyres, Insurance, Servicing, Licence and most of all FUN!!

ajg31

1,455 posts

236 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
mgbond said:
In my 1.5yrs ownership I have found it to be a lot more expensve than my old Elise.

However I did buy a 2.5 with std diff which failed 3 months later (a Known problem) and a couple of other things.

Just look on here for the advice but try to get at least a GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


Do you not think a decent 2.5 with LSD is not a viable option then? Are they so different, and does the extra 8k buy you so much more?

gizard

2,272 posts

312 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
mgbond said:


GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


rather rare !



Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 07:23

lotus160sport

527 posts

245 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
I moved from lotus to noble ownership and it was well worth the move, as everyone is saying they are not de-similiar to each other in terms of there handling charicteristics but the noble simply would blow the elise away with its performance, I also think that the noble is a much more comfortable drive and feels alot more solid i.e no sqeeks or rattles. Buy a noble you will not be dissapointed.

snuffy

13,216 posts

313 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
gizard said:
mgbond said:


GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


rather rare !



Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 07:23


That's what I've got !

gizard

2,272 posts

312 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
snuffy said:
gizard said:
mgbond said:


GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


rather rare !



Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 07:23


That's what I've got !


Me too - doesn't make them any more desirable though!

Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 10:17

snuffy

13,216 posts

313 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
gizard said:
snuffy said:
gizard said:
mgbond said:


GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


rather rare !



Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 07:23


That's what I've got !


Me too - doesn't make them any more desirable though!

Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 10:17


Maybe not that rare then ?

poptosis

Original Poster:

850 posts

275 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
It only costs about £1000 a year to service, tyre, and maintain my 135r. I appreciate a Noble is going to be more, but how much on average ?

doksie

498 posts

250 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
gizard said:
snuffy said:
gizard said:
mgbond said:


GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


rather rare !



Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 07:23


That's what I've got !


Me too - doesn't make them any more desirable though!

Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 10:17



me three!! high five's all round and dont tell people that...it makes them much more desirable

BrianJ

256 posts

271 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
Been from Elise to Noble and back to Exige - and never been happier as a result.

I would skip the Noble and save £££ and hassle.

epsomjames

790 posts

275 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
poptosis said:
It only costs about £1000 a year to service, tyre, and maintain my 135r. I appreciate a Noble is going to be more, but how much on average ?


I spent £2.5K on maintenance, tyres and servicing in (almost) a year and 7000 miles on my 3R, and that included two trackdays. Which is pretty good really.

Edited to say: I also went from Elise to Noble and never regretted it.


Edited by epsomjames on Thursday 22 February 14:11

ajg31

1,455 posts

236 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
2.5k for what would have been 2 services and about 600 quids worth of rubber is not bad.

poptosis

Original Poster:

850 posts

275 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
You can see how its a tricky choice with the exige S on the scene.

Clearly its test drive o'clock...

doksie

498 posts

250 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
i almost bought an Exige s2....but then i drove the Noble,i found the decision easy after that. i really liked the Exige but it didn't give me the same buzz.who knows,it may well be the other way around 4 you....think the only way u will know is after test driving the two cars yourself. if u dont like attention then dont buy the Noble as it gets lots.

epsomjames

790 posts

275 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
ajg31 said:
2.5k for what would have been 2 services and about 600 quids worth of rubber is not bad.


Only rear tyres, but that price included re-welding manifolds and replacing silencer too.

mgbond

6,749 posts

261 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
ajg31 said:
mgbond said:
In my 1.5yrs ownership I have found it to be a lot more expensve than my old Elise.

However I did buy a 2.5 with std diff which failed 3 months later (a Known problem) and a couple of other things.

Just look on here for the advice but try to get at least a GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


Do you not think a decent 2.5 with LSD is not a viable option then? Are they so different, and does the extra 8k buy you so much more?


No it's still a good buy if you make sure it has all the upgrades (I only know of one that has a 6spd, but the 5spd is upto the task). If I had done more research I wouldn't of paid out so much on the car to date (although I did get it 4k less than any other 2.5s at that time).

Also for a coule of k or less you can get it upto the perfomance of a 3/3R

Trust me, drive one and you'll love it. I have driven the Exige and I find it to loud (with stage 1 exhaust) when it hits the 6krpm mark (gave me a headache). I have not driven the S version so can't comment.

Bondy

gadgeroonie

5,362 posts

265 months

Thursday 22nd February 2007
quotequote all
doksie said:
gizard said:
snuffy said:
gizard said:
mgbond said:


GTO3 with LSD and 6 Spd.

Bondy


rather rare !



Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 07:23


That's what I've got !


Me too - doesn't make them any more desirable though!

Edited by gizard on Thursday 22 February 10:17



me three!! high five's all round and dont tell people that...it makes them much more desirable


me too - its the one best out there i reckon

good gbox and diff
3.0 power
wheels that don't buckle and snap at will
and no misted up light clusters ! (has anyone wiht a 3r/400 not had misty lights ?)