Tesla Model 3 2024 - column stalks
Tesla Model 3 2024 - column stalks
Author
Discussion

ajprice

Original Poster:

31,242 posts

214 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Enhance, who make the S3XY Buttons and S3XY Knob programmable controllers, have come up with column stalks for the 2024 Model 3 'Highland'. Like the buttons and knob they're programmable to do lots of things other than indicator controls. Looks interesting.



https://enhauto.com/stalks

Muddle238

4,237 posts

131 months

Friday 6th December 2024
quotequote all
It's a pretty naff reality when you have to pay extra to an aftermarket bunch just to get your car with a normal indicator stalk.

otolith

63,010 posts

222 months

Friday 6th December 2024
quotequote all
Muddle238 said:
It's a pretty naff reality when you have to pay extra to an aftermarket bunch just to get your car with a normal indicator stalk.
This dumb idea appears to have legs.






V8_EV

23 posts

49 months

Friday 6th December 2024
quotequote all
Looks like there are indicator stalk options on AliExpress. Good old Chinese filling gaps in the market!

FarmyardPants

4,261 posts

236 months

Friday 6th December 2024
quotequote all
My Cerbera has the horn button on the steering wheel arms. This is a spectacularly stupid idea. You have no chance of finding it if someone cuts you up on a roundabout, for example.

If I bought a Tesla so-equipped I would factor the cost of this in.

ajprice

Original Poster:

31,242 posts

214 months

Wednesday 20th August
quotequote all
The Model 3 indicator stalk is coming back, but only in China (for now?)
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/tesla/model-3/367596...

Mad Maximus

707 posts

21 months

Thursday 21st August
quotequote all
FarmyardPants said:
My Cerbera has the horn button on the steering wheel arms. This is a spectacularly stupid idea. You have no chance of finding it if someone cuts you up on a roundabout, for example.

If I bought a Tesla so-equipped I would factor the cost of this in.
Bring back the stalk mounted horn button. Bliss.

Tophatron

472 posts

239 months

Thursday 21st August
quotequote all
ajprice said:
The Model 3 indicator stalk is coming back, but only in China (for now?)
https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/tesla/model-3/367596...
I'm sure that will eventually return for UK cars too.

The system works better on the Ferrari as it has one button on each side - the Tesla system is much more confusing, especially if you're going round a corner and then want to use an indicator.

Dave Hedgehog

15,363 posts

222 months

Thursday 21st August
quotequote all
Muddle238 said:
It's a pretty naff reality when you have to pay extra to an aftermarket bunch just to get your car with a normal indicator stalk.
so much this

oldmanbm

450 posts

223 months

Saturday 23rd August
quotequote all
Just read that stalks are coming back and can be fitted to Highland Model 3s. Cost is estaimated at around £/$ 350 fitted. I agree it's crazy to pay extra for stalks but for some (including me) it might be difference between buying a new Model 3 or not.

AmitG

3,444 posts

178 months

Monday 15th September
quotequote all
oldmanbm said:
Just read that stalks are coming back and can be fitted to Highland Model 3s. Cost is estaimated at around £/$ 350 fitted. I agree it's crazy to pay extra for stalks but for some (including me) it might be difference between buying a new Model 3 or not.
Is this a standard Tesla option, or aftermarket? It's one of the issues preventing me from getting a Model 3.

jonwm

2,627 posts

132 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
I picked one up Friday, I'm used to it now, Friday I kept going for the stalks but it's not a problem after a few days.
Gear selector is great on the screen too, 9 times out of 10 it just know what gear you need.

Venom

1,864 posts

277 months

Tuesday 16th September
quotequote all
Tesla have just approved the return of the stalks for cars in all markets, according to a source. Sounds like they'll likely be rolled out in Q4 this year - or in other words, any new cars built now will have them. Less likely that cars already on boats being shipped will have them, but time will tell soon enough.

Will be interesting to see what price point Tesla offer these as a retro-fit for existing 24/25 cars. The chinese are paying the equivalent of £350 for a new steering wheel as well as the stalks. Personally, I'd probably accept leaving the wheel 'as-is' if it made the cost noticeably cheaper.

Odd idea poorly implemented, either way.

Gone fishing

7,867 posts

142 months

Sunday 21st September
quotequote all
The configurator is still showing steering wheel buttons in the UK and there is no stalk in the tesla shop, and noboidy seems to have reported it as available via the service menu.

So whilst it may be coming, its not here yet.

And itnernet rumours are always just that, a mixture of wishful thinking and spam for clicks from some of the well known Tesla sites who often get at least the timing, if not the substance, wrong.

AmitG

3,444 posts

178 months

Sunday 21st September
quotequote all
I do recall seeing an interview with the head of interior design for Tesla, which given how minimalist the interiors are, must be an easy job hehe

He said that in hindsight taking out the stalks was a bad idea. And he said something like - if you don't have to add something back, then you weren't taking out enough in the first place.

So it seems that they do intend to do it, but if or when it comes to the UK market we don't know.


Zcd1

577 posts

73 months

Sunday 21st September
quotequote all
I just bought a set of aftermarket stalks for my Plaid. While the on-screen gear selector works well and became second nature in short order, the button indicator setup still makes me look down almost every time, even after 8 months of ownership.

I haven t installed the stalks yet, but will report back once they’re functional.

AmitG

3,444 posts

178 months

Saturday 27th September
quotequote all
Apparently the indicator stalks are coming to Europe, and there is also going to be a front-mounted camera.

https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tesla-prepares-...

That would fix 2 of my deal breakers with the Model 3, and make it much more attractive. I assume that the UK would get these as well. (i.e. Europe in this context means the continent of Europe, not "mainland Europe" or "EU").

MM

385 posts

282 months

Saturday 27th September
quotequote all
Having put 5k miles on a highland, the steering wheel buttons are a bit of a revelation.

AmitG

3,444 posts

178 months

Sunday 28th September
quotequote all
I am sure that one can get used to the indicator buttons. I think that historically, people who bought Teslas were heavily into tech and were willing to experiment with new interfaces. But they now have much more widespread adoption; for example, loads of Ubers in my area are Tesla. And the drivers are definitely not tech bros. That part of the market doesn't want to experiment with the basics of a car user interface. They are more conservative. They have always had stalks and so, rightly or wrongly, they expect stalks.


Gone fishing

7,867 posts

142 months

Saturday 4th October
quotequote all
The Tesla website has been updated and new Model 3 orders now get stalks, there will be a transition as existing inventory gets used up so it you’re bothered one way or the other check existing inventory carefully.

Just goes to show if a design isn’t broken, don’t try and fix it.