......it continues
......it continues
Author
Discussion

dodaman

Original Poster:

45 posts

265 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
I see that we have two show on the same weekend September 13-14 next year we have Donington run by Peter Filby and Stafford run by Den Tanner.

Just when things seemed quieter.





Black5

579 posts

247 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
I could understand this if they were at opposite ends on the country, but the venues can only be 100 miles apart.

Will certainly split the manufacturers too, especially as very very few will have 2 show cars and staff to man 2 stands.

Oh well, Sat at one, Sun at the other!

Paul Drawmer

5,121 posts

291 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
dodaman said:
I see that we have two show on the same weekend September 13-14 next year we have Donington run by Peter Filby and Stafford run by Den Tanner.
Bonkers.
I'm waiting to see what the exhibitors make of it.
Won't be suprised if both shows get poor support from their own industry.



Davi

17,153 posts

244 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Paul Drawmer said:
Won't be suprised if both shows get poor support from their own industry.
my first thought too - a good reason not to go to either frown

Black5

579 posts

247 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
I received an email from Den earlier:

kitcarman said:
As to Donington: all the reports, on all the forums and from all the manufacturers, were to the effect that it was terrible and certainly not profitable for anybody – in short: that Donington was dead. On that basis I took my opportunity to book my show (from which I cannot be barred) on the only weekend in September that the Stafford Bingley Hall was available. If Donington thinks it isn’t dead, and if it decides to go-head on that same weekend, bearing in mind that its date regularly changes to accommodate the racing calendar, then it’s the proprietor’s prerogative.

We’ll have to wait and see what actually happens ‘in the event’. I dare say that I’ll stand accused of causing trouble again but, as ever, all I’m striving for is a level playing field.

Den Tanner B.Sc.
MD of Kitcars Intl. Ltd. Publishers of Kit Car and Cobra Magazines.
Yep, Den is still barred from the Donington show.

Can't really comment on any of the rest of his email. I do think that even if the 2 shows were a few weeks apart manufacturers would be torn between which one they would attend.

Roll on Exeter - can rely on that being a good, well turned out show.

grahambell

2,720 posts

299 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Oh great, more crap the industry could do without.

Considering that Stafford is traditionally March while Donington is long established in September this does look sadly like a deliberate move by Den Tanner.


Edited to say, just noticed Black5's post after I posted mine. Yes, Donington got slated this year, but I think most of the problems stemmed from a double booking that wasn't Filby's fault.

Did anyone out there really think the show was 'dead'? Or did you expect the organisers to ensure it improved (i.e. no double booking, infield kit car parking and track access) for 2008?


Edited by grahambell on Monday 29th October 15:24

Ferg

15,242 posts

281 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
grahambell said:
Considering that Stafford is traditionally March while Donington is long established in September this does look sadly like a deliberate move by Den Tanner.
Er...
Wasn't it October 16th last year (or was that the year before)??
I know which I'll go to. Donington has got steadily worse year after year, but this year due to outside influences I went for the day not the weekend and it was actually quite a good day with enough to see for just the one day. Besides...Stafford is considerably further than Donington.

Sam_68

9,939 posts

269 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
grahambell said:
Oh great, more crap the industry could do without.

Considering that Stafford is traditionally March while Donington is long established in September this does look sadly like a deliberate move by Den Tanner.
I agree. This nonsense is doing the industry no good at all. frown

jgmadkit

553 posts

273 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Think there is also a show planned for August next year (Peterborough I think).

Getting to be too many now, manufacturers are stretched too thin trying to support all these shows, its not a big or affluent industry after all. Two big shows a year should be enough.

John

eliot

11,988 posts

278 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Donnington was pants this year. Wanted to grab my usual back of mixed stainless nuts&bolts - and there was only one seller there(Wrights) who didn't have what i wanted. And yes, it has been getting steadily worse.
Never been to stafford and I'm not likely to try it unless i hear good feedback.

grahambell

2,720 posts

299 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Ferg said:
grahambell said:
Considering that Stafford is traditionally March while Donington is long established in September this does look sadly like a deliberate move by Den Tanner.
Er...
Wasn't it October 16th last year (or was that the year before)??
Wasn't there so don't know. Do know Stafford always used to be the first show of the season, though maybe that changed recently.

However, having shows so close together - both date wise and geographically - isn't likely to result in optimum attendance for either.

Westyman

100 posts

267 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Can only see this ending in tears for Den. Stafford show has always being very badly attended. If Limelight get track use next year then I can't see any major manufacturers going to Stafford instead. The industry needs two major shows which in all likelihood will continue to be Donnington & Stoneleigh. Smaller shows such as Stafford have a part to play but pitching it against donnington is fooolhardy in my oppinion.

Black5

579 posts

247 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
I have to say, after attending Donington and Exeter in the last few years, the only draw for Donington is the track.

IMHO Exeter is a better 'show'.

Meeja

8,290 posts

272 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
grahambell said:
However, having shows so close together - both date wise and geographically - isn't likely to result in optimum attendance for either.
yes

Went to the Stafford show two years ago - and was disappointed. Have been going to Donington religiously until this year (work pressures meant I couldn't make it) and it has been going downhill.

Having two shows arranged like they now are is just going to put more nails in the coffins of both of them.

Wacky Racer

40,716 posts

271 months

Thursday 29th November 2007
quotequote all
I have been to most of the Stafford shows over the last ten years or so, the last couple have been disappointing, but a lot depends on the weather...

I do think the actual venue and halls are excellent though....

Only been to Donington once about six years ago, which was excellent and really busy....

Bloke with fireblade engined Westfield blew his engine up on the track....yikes

V8 GRF

7,298 posts

234 months

Thursday 29th November 2007
quotequote all
Meeja said:
Having two shows arranged like they now are is just going to put more nails in the coffins of both of them.
Ridiculous, this happened in the games industry a couple of years ago. A long established show losing some shine in Earls Court with a bright new shiney competitor in that isolated aircraft hanger in the docklands called Excel.

Earls Court was a ghost town the other was well attended but still 'lacking' both suffered and now the UK, a major developer of games, no longer has a show and all down to the bloody-mindedness of the 'rival' organisers.

Surely a joint show would be the way forward? Or at least talk to each other and agree different dates.

Edited by V8 GRF on Thursday 29th November 11:09

Graham-P

1,548 posts

270 months

Thursday 29th November 2007
quotequote all
Well have to say that Donnington has been getting worse over the years and this year was the end for me, poor everything, parking, manufacturers attendance etc, will not be attending next year. Never been to Stafford but haven't heard any good reports either, so can't comment.
I think my attendance for next year will be, the Kent Show, always seems a good turn out but is a bit dependent on the weather as it's early in the year, then the big one at Stoneleigh, plus all the little car shows and runs out that go on with the PH crowd in the summer.

Meeja

8,290 posts

272 months

Thursday 29th November 2007
quotequote all
V8 GRF said:
Surely a joint show would be the way forward? Or at least talk to each other and agree different dates.
With the individuals involved, that is unlikely to happen.

Edited by Meeja on Thursday 29th November 11:44

Jubal

930 posts

253 months

Thursday 29th November 2007
quotequote all
Meeja said:
V8 GRF said:
Surely a joint show would be the way forward? Or at least talk to each other and agree different dates.
With the individuals involved, that is unlikely to happen.
It's pathetic. I can understand healthy competition but the history behind this spat bores me. No-one but the individuals really remembers exactly why they are fighting and to dilute show attendance in a small industry like this by scheduling as they have shows a complete lack of integrity.

choogh

196 posts

246 months

Thursday 29th November 2007
quotequote all
Tanner and Filby's little spats will destroy this industry, just a matter of time..People don't need their (his for the most part)squabbles, & dummy spitting.