Will Prodrive be in F1 2008?
Will Prodrive be in F1 2008?
Author
Discussion

skeggysteve

Original Poster:

5,724 posts

246 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Interesting article here on Grandprix.com.

Especially the last paragraph.

stevieb

5,253 posts

296 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
With respect to the last paragraph they will get around this the same way redbull got around this, by the parent company int he redbull case Redbull technology limited or what ever it is called supplying both teams. Mclaren and Prodrive will do the same, the chassis will be designed and made by Mclaren Technologies or Composites and sold to both Mclaren Racing and Prodrive.

But irrespectively do the rules state that customer cars are legal in 2008

patmahe

5,919 posts

233 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Special dispensation to race I'd say, due to the amount of investment put in by a new team

PJS917

1,194 posts

277 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
I hope they are able to race, but the FIA are so inept/crooked/useless/biased/ (delete as appropriate, or use all of them) I would not put it past them making a total hash of it and declaring anything to do with Mclaren illegal. Of course if Ferrarsi want to have a junior team then the matter would have be cleared up long ago.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

256 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Customer cars were mooted by Max a few years ago and Prodrive have never disguised the fact that this is the way they wanted to enter F1. Seems a bit late to be arguing about it now. Late, but typical of F1, sadly.

M3MTH

1,955 posts

243 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
If prodrive will share alot of mclaren's chassis, data, parts etc, what about loaning out Alonso to them?! that way he's not in the same team as such but still under a mclaren contract if they are part of the same group wink

skeggysteve

Original Poster:

5,724 posts

246 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
stevieb said:
With respect to the last paragraph they will get around this the same way redbull got around this, by the parent company int he redbull case Redbull technology limited or what ever it is called supplying both teams. Mclaren and Prodrive will do the same, the chassis will be designed and made by Mclaren Technologies or Composites and sold to both Mclaren Racing and Prodrive.
Good point I hadn't thought of that.

stevieb said:
But irrespectively do the rules state that customer cars are legal in 2008
Not sure about the 'rules' as such but I think the Concorde Agreement pretty much states what can and cannot happen in F1.

patmahe - Especially if Bernie is in favor.

toomuchbeer

877 posts

237 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
As I understand it, the sticky point is how the prize monies are spead out between the teams.

Ie, do 'constructors' get more money from Bernie than 'Customers'.


toomuchbeer

877 posts

237 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
stevieb said:
With respect to the last paragraph they will get around this the same way redbull got around this, by the parent company int he redbull case Redbull technology limited or what ever it is called supplying both teams. Mclaren and Prodrive will do the same, the chassis will be designed and made by Mclaren Technologies or Composites and sold to both Mclaren Racing and Prodrive.
If that is the case, then technically, both McLaren & Prodrive will be customers......?

castrolcraig

18,073 posts

235 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
M3MTH said:
If prodrive will share alot of mclaren's chassis, data, parts etc, what about loaning out Alonso to them?! that way he's not in the same team as such but still under a mclaren contract if they are part of the same group wink
this has been discussed on here several times...................

id say him and sutil in the prodrive cars and button and hamilton in the "sister" full works mcmerc

skeggysteve

Original Poster:

5,724 posts

246 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
PJS917 said:
I hope they are able to race, but the FIA are so inept/crooked/useless/biased/ (delete as appropriate, or use all of them) I would not put it past them making a total hash of it and declaring anything to do with Mclaren illegal. Of course if Ferrarsi want to have a junior team then the matter would have be cleared up long ago.
Sadly I have to agree with you.

andyps

7,819 posts

311 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Difficult to know what might happen here - the Prodrive entry was awarded to them after submissions by many parties to "win" the 12th team slot and as far as I remember was to go along with the new Concorde Agreement which would start in 2008. This being the same Concorde Agreement that teams signed up for once the GPMA folded. The way I see it, Prodrive have an entry for 2008 based on an agreement which would allow customer chassis at that stage, but as they were not previously part of the CA they have no influence on the final wording, but have been working towards being ready for the first race of 2008 based on what they were told. Presumably, if they have been in discussion with McLaren about buying a chassis/engine packaged from them McLaren also understood it to be the case that customer chassis would be allowed. Who might be seeking compensation from whom if Prodrive are not able to join in next year? Prodrive for loss of the investment they have made, or the FIA claiming a fine from Prodrive for not turning up when they should be on the grid?

I agree with PJS917 too - not difficult to think that objections are coming from Italy as they don't want to end up behind two teams using McLaren chassis next year, that would never do and therefore Jean Toadt etc. are no doubt throwing spanners into works. Had David Richards got an agreement with them, however.....

ELAN+2

2,232 posts

261 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
PJS917 said:
I hope they are able to race, but the FIA are so inept/crooked/useless/biased/ (delete as appropriate, or use all of them) I would not put it past them making a total hash of it and declaring anything to do with Mclaren illegal. Of course if Ferrari want to have a "Red Bull "team then the matter would have be cleared up long ago.
edited to stir it up a bit..... the original RB1 was the previous years Ferrari, that Red Bull purchased the manufacturing rights to, hence they owned the design and were there fore the manufacturers or some such nonsense. Interestingly other teams weren't allowed to pull this sort of stroke......

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

256 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
ELAN+2 said:
PJS917 said:
I hope they are able to race, but the FIA are so inept/crooked/useless/biased/ (delete as appropriate, or use all of them) I would not put it past them making a total hash of it and declaring anything to do with Mclaren illegal. Of course if Ferrari want to have a "Red Bull "team then the matter would have be cleared up long ago.
edited to stir it up a bit..... the original RB1 was the previous years Ferrari, that Red Bull purchased the manufacturing rights to, hence they owned the design and were there fore the manufacturers or some such nonsense. Interestingly other teams weren't allowed to pull this sort of stroke......
Wasn't that Sauber a few years ago? The RB1 was a Jaguar design and ran a Cosworth engine.

ELAN+2

2,232 posts

261 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
ELAN+2 said:
PJS917 said:
I hope they are able to race, but the FIA are so inept/crooked/useless/biased/ (delete as appropriate, or use all of them) I would not put it past them making a total hash of it and declaring anything to do with Mclaren illegal. Of course if Ferrari want to have a "Red Bull "team then the matter would have be cleared up long ago.
edited to stir it up a bit..... the original RB1 was the previous years Ferrari, that Red Bull purchased the manufacturing rights to, hence they owned the design and were there fore the manufacturers or some such nonsense. Interestingly other teams weren't allowed to pull this sort of stroke......
Wasn't that Sauber a few years ago? The RB1 was a Jaguar design and ran a Cosworth engine.
errrrr where's the paper bag smiley? I stand corrected, still the point stands, that the rules can be adjusted to screw certain teams/advantage others.I must remember to double check the facts, age does this sort of thing to your memory hehe


belleair302

7,008 posts

236 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Simple answer is no. Prodrive will sell their spot or take a refund from the FIA due to contract differences.

johnph

1,097 posts

258 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
ELAN+2 said:
PJS917 said:
I hope they are able to race, but the FIA are so inept/crooked/useless/biased/ (delete as appropriate, or use all of them) I would not put it past them making a total hash of it and declaring anything to do with Mclaren illegal. Of course if Ferrari want to have a "Red Bull "team then the matter would have be cleared up long ago.
edited to stir it up a bit..... the original RB1 was the previous years Ferrari, that Red Bull purchased the manufacturing rights to, hence they owned the design and were there fore the manufacturers or some such nonsense. Interestingly other teams weren't allowed to pull this sort of stroke......
Wasn't that Sauber a few years ago? The RB1 was a Jaguar design and ran a Cosworth engine.
afaik the RB1 was an upgraded version of the 2004 Jaguar. This same design was given in rev limited form to Toro Rosso for 2006.

flemke

23,481 posts

266 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
belleair302 said:
Simple answer is no. Prodrive will sell their spot or take a refund from the FIA due to contract differences.
Contract differences between...?

NightDriver

1,082 posts

255 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
Prodrive will be there, I'd happily put a very large sum of money on it smile

Dunit

645 posts

234 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2007
quotequote all
I think Prodrive will be there , The deal would help out Macs on the money side and would have Pits along side one another. Also it will be another team Money contribution to !The keeping the Ferrari Tradition alive on the Grid Fund!.
How long much longer do all the other teams have keep paying out to have them on the grid.
If Macs had have been banned i wonder where the Vodaphone money would have gone?