FIA and Ferrari - How many people believe:
FIA and Ferrari - How many people believe:

Poll: FIA and Ferrari - How many people believe:

Total Members Polled: 463

FIA are completely un-biased: 9%
FIA are biased towards Ferarri: 91%
Author
Discussion

Scuffers

Original Poster:

20,887 posts

303 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
ignoring the obvious refference to today's fiasco, just interested to get a snap-shot of what the majority here think.

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

280 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
today was another perfect example of 'one rule for them, another rule for everybody else'.

Hamilton cuts a chicane in France because he loses control when fighting hard and he goes 'over the limit' and gets a stop go, Ferrari release Massa into somebodies path in a clearly tight pitlane almost causing an accident and they get off scott free.....again.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

238 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
he got a 10,000 Euro fine rolleyes


hilly10

7,540 posts

257 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
I bet if that was a Maclaren today it would have been a stop go penalty no doubt about it. That little weasel Berni is so far up Ferrari arse hes covered in st

tomTVR

6,909 posts

270 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
Boohoo rolleyes

cj_eds

1,567 posts

250 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
I'm sure this opinion won't be popular around these parts, but the result and punishment seems fair I reckon.

Massa should have lifted off, but the mistake was the team's and not his - the drivers have to rely 100% on the lights/lolly pop to leave their pit box. The team screwed up and its the team that have got the 10k fine. Him trying to lay the blame on Sutil is wrong though. For that he should have all his world championship points stripped off him and given to Hamilton hehe
More worrying is the stweards bottled it when making a crucial decision that could have turned the race on its head.

Back to the original pole question though, and yip, they're hideously biased.


kambites

71,460 posts

250 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
rofl An 8000 pound fine... that'll learn 'em.

CivicMan

2,211 posts

230 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
he got a 10,000 Euro fine
Which, as he is earning $10 million a year, will not make him sweat unduly......

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

256 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
It makes no difference if it is the team or driver at fault, the driver is part of the team. In the GP2 race drivers were penalised, it has been done in F1 before.

Whether the FIA are biased or not is irrelevent - the perception is that they may be. And that is the most damning fact. One wonders if there is another Mosley scandal out there that Ferrari are holding back...

anonymous-user

83 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
Stop trying to find logic from the decisions being laid down, it will do your head in.
I just find it sadly amusing now, it's just a pantomime.

woof

8,456 posts

306 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all

I think in this case - the fine was probably right
Looking at the history of these things - a collision will 100% guarantee a penalty eg Lewis and Rosberg in Montreal. But a near miss generally doesn't. Though if that had been a Mclaren on a Ferrari - then it would be a stop and go during the race. No doubt

The FIA are totally bias to Ferrari or should that actually be FOM and the FIA are 100% bias

I've said it many times on this forum - that there would be no F1 without Ferrari - it's that simple. So of course, FOM will be more flexible when it comes to making sure the most important part of the circus is kept happy. Fiat are never that far from pulling the plug on their support. You're either in with the in crowd, Bernie, Max, Ferrari and of Flav or you're not.

You're always going to help those who help you - it's a business. Full stop

You only have to look at this weekend's race to see it, in full effect. A totally soulless circuit. Zero overtaking, poor facilities and a poor crowd, with a huge racist factor going on (quite disgusting behaviour by the crowd when Lewis received his trophy)

anyway ... Flav managed to swing an extra race in Spain - a very poor market for F1. But did you know that Flav owns the TV rights for F1 in spain. So when Alonso didn't qualify in the top10 on Saturday, the look of disappointment on his face, wasn't just that his driver qualified 12th - that he knew that the very fickle spanish public wouldn't be tuning in for the race.






Derek Smith

49,740 posts

277 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
I can't see the logic of the fine. Either he did do something dangerous or he didn't. So Massa was very lucky. The last time they fined someone who didn't do anything wrong they had to pay $100,000,000.

But the collision aside, Kimi's take off was most certainly dangerous and to prove it there is an injured mechanic. His offence was a classic case of driving off too early. He should have been fined.

marcia1

5,099 posts

219 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
Spelling police shout i think you mean believe scuffers boxedin

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

238 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
If Ferrari walked there would still be F1.

It's bigger than that.

Maybe Kimi should also be fined for leaving his pit box dangerously.

BUT

A fine IS NOT an option open to the FIA according to thier own rules.

They cannot impose a fine!

pies

13,116 posts

285 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
Precedents now been set so nobodies going to do a stop go penalty for pulling out infront of another car

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

238 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
pies said:
Precedents now been set so nobodies going to do a stop go penalty for pulling out infront of another car
yes

Seems like 10K euros would be a cheap price to keep your podium position if you needed to use that option!

Nebby

268 posts

245 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
Massa drove an absolutely perfect weekend in my view, but the way Rob Smedley seem to make it sound as a team error not driver is completely wrong.

Massa is part of the team and they all work together to get the car to the finish, I am a Lewis supporter and not Ferrari but they always seem to get their own way being as two other GP2 teams were penalised for the same offence in the same weekend.

coetzeeh

2,890 posts

265 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
If Ferrari walked there would still be F1.

It's bigger than that.
Yeah, but at a third of the size though.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

238 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
coetzeeh said:
odyssey2200 said:
If Ferrari walked there would still be F1.

It's bigger than that.
Yeah, but at a third of the size though.
If they are not seen to be impartial and to have intergrety it may cost them more than that!

SimonY

348 posts

237 months

Sunday 24th August 2008
quotequote all
I don't even see where the problem is, I've seen cars running side by side down the pitlane many times before in F1 with no fines or penalties?

Allen and Brundle were like a (particularly annoying) dog with a bone over it as well. Quite clear that they wanted Lewis to take the points, a shame when Massa had driven a faultless race. Not really the way you would want to win if you were Lewis imo.