BBC F1 Broadcast in HD?
BBC F1 Broadcast in HD?
Author
Discussion

mollytherocker

Original Poster:

14,464 posts

238 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
Im thinking of getting a Sky HD box as they are now only £49.

If the F1 is in HD, the deal is clinched!

MTR

Holst

2,468 posts

250 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
mollytherocker said:
Im thinking of getting a Sky HD box as they are now only £49.

If the F1 is in HD, the deal is clinched!

MTR
I read somewhere that it wouldnt be HD as bernie wanted more money for the HD rights.

However this info might be out of date.

Gun

13,432 posts

247 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
Isn't all the camerawork carried out by the country that is hosting the race so the BBC would only be responsible for the British GP??

Scuffers

20,887 posts

303 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
don't think that's the case....

Certainly HD was avaliable last year (and was used to show it in the cinima's)

only bit that was not HD was the on-board stuff (last year)

IforB

9,840 posts

258 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
No HD available next year I'm afraid.

[i]Roger Mosey of BBC Sport said “F1 won’t yet be available in HD though we’d very much like it to be. I’ll keep you posted.”

He went on in a later comment to explain that it wasn’t down to the BBC. He said: “the BBC very much wants F1 to be in HD. The problem is the world feed is currently in standard definition, and it depends on the demand from broadcasters other than the BBC before it will be upgraded. We’ll keep lobbying…”[/i]



Edited by IforB on Monday 2nd February 17:46

skeggysteve

5,724 posts

246 months

Monday 2nd February 2009
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
don't think that's the case....

Certainly HD was avaliable last year (and was used to show it in the cinima's)

only bit that was not HD was the on-board stuff (last year)
A lot more info here

Warning it's a long thread and it's the 2009 version of a thread that started years ago.

But it does have some inside info.

BTW the cinema feed was not HD but upscaled feed.

mollytherocker

Original Poster:

14,464 posts

238 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
So not in HD then. Bugger! F1 would look fantastic in high def! Mind you, I have also been reading that the Sky HD boxes are not very reliable.

I guess I will wait then, because it will happen eventually, surely!

MTR

motormania

1,143 posts

282 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
mollytherocker said:
So not in HD then. Bugger! F1 would look fantastic in high def! Mind you, I have also been reading that the Sky HD boxes are not very reliable.

I guess I will wait then, because it will happen eventually, surely!

MTR
Your right about the SKY HD box... If BBC do show F1 in HD, my advice will be to stay clear of SKY HD. Don't get me wrong, as a Sky+ subscriber their Sky+ service is the best piece of techno ever. If you have a young family you'll know what I mean.

The problem though is that the SKY HD box is flawed. SKY know this but are not prepared to fix it just yet due to price issues. The power supply feeding the box's internals is not up to the job and the box will break far too often. I know several people who've had mutliple failures with their SKY HD box. One friend had his box break 7 times last year!!!

The best option is to go with the new breed of Freesat Recorder boxes now on the market, slightly more expensive at approx £300 but there is no subscription, but you get loads of channels in HD and they are more stable than the SKY HD one.

So until SKY publically announce that they will be upgrading the internals to the SKY HD, do not subscribe to it.

I plan to keep my Sky+ and install the FreeSat box on top if it. Just run a couple more cables from the dish outside and plug-n-play - simple really.

Maybe SKY are very aware now about the bad press that the boxes are getting, that's why they've dropped the price from £200 - £99 and now £49!! The good news might be that this causes the new FreeSat boxes to come down in price. I guess the hardest part is knowing when to buy at the moment...


hornetrider

63,161 posts

234 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
motormania said:
mollytherocker said:
So not in HD then. Bugger! F1 would look fantastic in high def! Mind you, I have also been reading that the Sky HD boxes are not very reliable.

I guess I will wait then, because it will happen eventually, surely!

MTR
Your right about the SKY HD box... If BBC do show F1 in HD, my advice will be to stay clear of SKY HD. Don't get me wrong, as a Sky+ subscriber their Sky+ service is the best piece of techno ever. If you have a young family you'll know what I mean.

The problem though is that the SKY HD box is flawed. SKY know this but are not prepared to fix it just yet due to price issues. The power supply feeding the box's internals is not up to the job and the box will break far too often. I know several people who've had mutliple failures with their SKY HD box. One friend had his box break 7 times last year!!!

The best option is to go with the new breed of Freesat Recorder boxes now on the market, slightly more expensive at approx £300 but there is no subscription, but you get loads of channels in HD and they are more stable than the SKY HD one.

So until SKY publically announce that they will be upgrading the internals to the SKY HD, do not subscribe to it.

I plan to keep my Sky+ and install the FreeSat box on top if it. Just run a couple more cables from the dish outside and plug-n-play - simple really.

Maybe SKY are very aware now about the bad press that the boxes are getting, that's why they've dropped the price from £200 - £99 and now £49!! The good news might be that this causes the new FreeSat boxes to come down in price. I guess the hardest part is knowing when to buy at the moment...
No probs with my Sky HD box, 14 months and counting.

Rich-UK

1,431 posts

285 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
motormania said:
... but you get loads of channels in HD ...
BBC HD part time and ITV HD even more part time are not loads of HD channels!

On the plus side, the Humax Freesat HD box upscales SD pics to make them look a bit better.

furtive

4,503 posts

308 months

Tuesday 3rd February 2009
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
No probs with my Sky HD box, 14 months and counting.
Same here