How bad is rush hour congestion in your local town/city?
How bad is rush hour congestion in your local town/city?
Author
Discussion

12gauge

Original Poster:

1,274 posts

195 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
Only ever had to commute into Cambridge, so my experience of rush hour congestion is somewhat limited.

Typically going into town queues start at least a mile on most roads outside of the M11 and A14. Speeds are then not much above walking speed within that area.

Is Milton Keynes congestion free with its grid system?
Is coventry congestion free with its inner ring road?

GetCarter

30,565 posts

300 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
er... about one car every 20 minutes.

Well you DID ask. wink

snowy slopes

41,307 posts

208 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
Hmm lets see
any road nera racecourse roundabout= gridlock
The road out of town towards conisborough=gridlock
Bawtry road on the way in to town am=gridlock, on the way out of town pm=gridlock
trafford way anytime between 7.30 am-9.45 am and 4pm till 6.30 pm= gridlock


Doncaster can be a really nasty place to get round by car, its safer to take the bus, or cycle

aizvara

2,067 posts

188 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
On the few occasions I've been bothered/forced to commute into the centre of Cambridge from the north (down the A10 from Ely) the heavy traffic has started way outside, probably more than five miles away, with stop start around every junction and roundabout, but never down to walking speed for too long until you are actually in Cambridge. Even then, it isn't too bad, really, especially if you time it right, but I prefer to just take the train and cycle the rest. I think my total journey is 15 miles, and it takes 50-60 mins by car. 45 mins by bicycle and train.

They've talked about having a congestion charge in Cambridge. Hopefully there'd be more trains and buses to compensate.

djt100

1,739 posts

206 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
I used to work 4 miles from home and have to pass a school any way i went, Approx 45-55 min journey, I now work 38 miles from home, and it takes about an hour most days, not schools.

Local traffic is a nihgtmare.

Puggit

49,338 posts

269 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
Rush hour traffic in Reading is a nightmare.

It starts with a disadvantage: There are only 2 bridges across the Thames and there are only 3 tunnels under the railway.

Next add 20+ years of Labour council deliberate mis-management and you have the recipe for disaster. For instance, it was a great idea to build the A33 relief road - and now it has 5 sets of traffic lights on it, with no attempt at creating flow (quite the opposite).

banghead

ewenm

28,506 posts

266 months

Thursday 14th October 2010
quotequote all
Bath is terrible, so I avoid rush hours. The downside of having a small city surrounded by hills, with narrow streets and limited river crossings.

The fatboy

277 posts

183 months

Friday 15th October 2010
quotequote all
morning: slow crawling inbound towards the city centre.

afternoon: slow crawling outbound towards the motorway.

every direct roads to the motorway junctions.

12gauge

Original Poster:

1,274 posts

195 months

Saturday 16th October 2010
quotequote all
aizvara said:
On the few occasions I've been bothered/forced to commute into the centre of Cambridge from the north (down the A10 from Ely) the heavy traffic has started way outside, probably more than five miles away, with stop start around every junction and roundabout, but never down to walking speed for too long until you are actually in Cambridge. Even then, it isn't too bad, really, especially if you time it right, but I prefer to just take the train and cycle the rest. I think my total journey is 15 miles, and it takes 50-60 mins by car. 45 mins by bicycle and train.

They've talked about having a congestion charge in Cambridge. Hopefully there'd be more trains and buses to compensate.
Yes, ive tried the A10 before and seen on-off queues as far away from Cambridge as Stretham.

Why oh why did they build so many houses in Ely and Littleport instead of actually in and around Cambridge?

MATTP77

697 posts

216 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
Puggit said:
Rush hour traffic in Reading is a nightmare.

It starts with a disadvantage: There are only 2 bridges across the Thames and there are only 3 tunnels under the railway.

Next add 20+ years of Labour council deliberate mis-management and you have the recipe for disaster. For instance, it was a great idea to build the A33 relief road - and now it has 5 sets of traffic lights on it, with no attempt at creating flow (quite the opposite).

banghead
unfortunately for you i used to work on the J11 improvement project, thankfully now, i am on a different project.

The traffic is a nightmare at reading for sure, and the A33 "relief" road is only a relief if it is actually flowing.

Try getting around on a match day! I feel sorry for the poor souls trying to get north on the A33 from basingstoke areas. The road works saw to it that those people couldnt make it north of the project office!

Puggit

49,338 posts

269 months

Monday 1st November 2010
quotequote all
MATTP77 said:
I feel sorry for the poor souls trying to get north on the A33 from basingstoke areas. The road works saw to it that those people couldnt make it north of the project office!
I come up from the Grazeley direction, so that was me!

It is now a joy, however!

I suspect the junction will be a victim of its own success. It can now deliver so much traffic to the Relief Road, that the RR can't cope, so traffic is now backing up around jc11.

Stupidity in action!

MATTP77

697 posts

216 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Puggit said:
MATTP77 said:
I feel sorry for the poor souls trying to get north on the A33 from basingstoke areas. The road works saw to it that those people couldnt make it north of the project office!
I come up from the Grazeley direction, so that was me!

It is now a joy, however!

I suspect the junction will be a victim of its own success. It can now deliver so much traffic to the Relief Road, that the RR can't cope, so traffic is now backing up around jc11.

Stupidity in action!
During the two years i was there, that was on my mind... The HA are unlikely to care as it means that the traffic is no longer queuing on the m4 off slips.. i am not too sure whether the RRR/A33 are under HA jurisdiction, or whether they are maintained by the local council (more than likely).

It is the same for any road improvement though - at best unless you are building a bypass - you are only ever going to be pushing the bottleneck further down the road!

I have not driven the south of the junction yet

magpies

5,186 posts

203 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
we only have a rush 10mins - aroung school time!!!!!!

anonymous-user

75 months

Tuesday 2nd November 2010
quotequote all
Cardiff = grumpy The council planners responsible for digging up the same strech of road (a crucial road, reduced from 4 lanes to 2) TWICE in six months deserve nothing less than death.

I live in the city centre though and work out of town, so I'm heading against the main flow. Mornings are fine, a 15 mile commute normally takes around 20 mins. In the evening it's horrendous though, the entire centre gridlocks and it can easily take an hour. If I go the long way around via a bypass I can do it in 20 mins, despite it being over double the distance.