Broken Cayman!
Author
Discussion

Adt

Original Poster:

30 posts

247 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Hi, I need a bit of advice...

I bought a 2006 Cayman S at the end of Feb with 30k on the clock. Dealer gave me a 6 month '5 star' AA warranty, which I paid £300 to upgrade to 'Gold' (which covers practically everything).

Noticed a slight rattle not long after so when I took it to an indie for a minor service on 20th May I asked them to investigate. They gave it back and said they'd need to strip the engine but there was also a small oil leak and a track rod needed replacing.

It went back to them on 1st June and it's been there since!!!

Short story is as follows:
*Garage finds that rear main seal needs replacing (est £1,300 inc track rod)
*Day later garage says all of the tappets down one side need replacing (est now totals £2,300)
*Warranty company send engineer to have a look. They then approve £2,100 towards cost.
*Garage does work but there's still a noise. Engine stripped back and they find piston slap has caused
damage, meaning pistons need replacing.
*Warranty company send engineer to have a look. They then approve max claim of £5,000 towards total cost.
*TOTAL BILL NOW ESTIMATED AT £11,100.
*After various discussions, dealer who I bought the car from says if I pay £1,500 he'll pay the rest of
shortfall (c.£4,500).

Questions for all you knowledgable people....

1) Will getting all this work done a) increase the value of the car?
b) decrease the value of the car?
c) no change in value but more saleable?
b) no change in value but less saleable?
2) Would you pay the £1,500?

I'd be very grateful for your thoughts as I'm a bit stuck!

Cheers
Ad

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
sorry to hear all of this . . .

1a - NO
1b - NO
1c - maybe but probably no - better off not telling
1d - NO but as per 1c
2 - NO

basically should have immediately gone back to supplying dealer IMHO - I would press that dealer hard to get them to pay for the lot if you can + the warranty company too!

Good Luck!

khushy

acf69

407 posts

202 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Personal view is that it might pinch a bit, but paying £1,500 to get the £11k of work done is probably your best idea. You could have a bun fight with the vendor / cover company, but probably not worth the hassle. Pay, have the car you thought you had bought and then enjoy and forget the slight blip at the begining of ownership

acf69

407 posts

202 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
i'm obviously a much softer touch than kushy!

RudeDog

1,670 posts

205 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Sorry to hear of the problems you are having with your Cayman.

Why is the dealer offering to pay the balance of the bill if you pay £1,500? I ask because if they are duty bound to repair the car under warranty, how come you have to make a contribution and if they are not legally required to fix the car, why are they paying anything? Doesn't sound right to me.

Is your insurance warranty limited to £5,000?

Regarding your last questions, I do not think it will affect the value of the car very much either way but clearly it needs fixing before you can offload it!

Wacky Racer

41,427 posts

278 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
acf69 said:
Personal view is that it might pinch a bit, but paying £1,500 to get the £11k of work done is probably your best idea. You could have a bun fight with the vendor / cover company, but probably not worth the hassle. Pay, have the car you thought you had bought and then enjoy and forget the slight blip at the begining of ownership
This.




RedSpiseeBalls

441 posts

190 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Thats real bad news, sorry to hear this, but my opinion to your questions is:

1a - no
1b - no
1c - no
1d - possibly, you may loose some prospects that may wonder (with all the work done) what else is also wrong with the car

2 - I'd be gutted to pay that.. but I guess theres really no other option

Edited by RedSpiseeBalls on Wednesday 3rd August 16:56

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
It sounds at face value that the AA warranty (irrespective of cover level) covers up to £5k max and that the dealer you bought it from is prepared to make a sizeable contribution towards the full repair cost as a goodwill gesture to cover the shortfall. I'd bite their hand off to be honest, even if it feels a little galling to have to pay any money for it.

Others have answered the questions really. I guess on a positive note it would show the engine has had an inspection as a consequence of you getting this work done. Without it someone else could just as easily end up in the same situation as you on a different car.

Edited by Durzel on Wednesday 3rd August 17:03

Phooey

13,917 posts

200 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
How much is a new engine from Porsche out of interest (with warranty)?

I wouldn't want to be paying a bean without some kind of warranty on repairs. And only then, it would have to go to a very very respected indie. Hartech being one.

Be careful not to shoot yourself in the bks (yet) by naming and shaming etc. It *may* be a good offer.

Adt

Original Poster:

30 posts

247 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for all the prompt replies guys. Just noticed I gave two option Bs for the first question so cheers for ignoring that.

The max claim on the AA warranty is £5,000 and that's stated on their docs so no way of getting any more from them.

I think the dealer is liable for the whole cost under the Sale of Goods Act but...

  • I said I'd pay up to £500 towards the cost becuase I chose an indie where costs are high
  • It's already caused loads of inconvenience and I want/need my car back.
I'm gonna have a chat with a solicitor tomorrow.

Either way though I reckon I'll offer £1,000 towards it just to get it resolved. That'll still hurt though!

helmutlaang

522 posts

190 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Doesnt SOGA apply here as brought from trade?


R Soul

123 posts

196 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Bad news and sorry to hear it - my Cayman S engine is also in bits, and being rebuilt, at an OPC... so you're not alone.

If your rebuild is done 'properly' I agree it shouldn't reduce the value of your car and could make it more sellable. Let's face it - these 986/987/996/997 engines have been failing and, I for one, would rather buy one that I know has been rebuilt instead of just wondering if/when it's going to s**t itself...

I agree with others that it seems a bit rich to ask you to contribute to the costs - perhaps you should get some legal advice before proceeding? Either way - check the small print of your warranty contract.

As far as being quoted 11K for the rebuild... WHAT??? if you have a choice of who rebuilds it perhaps you should try a reputable OPC or Hartech (search for the latter's threads on here).

My understanding, which may be incorrect, is that a brand new engine, with all new ancillaries, costs about as much as is being charged to rebuild your engine with 'some' new components... Seems very expensive tbh...

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Does SOGA really apply? For how long? Wouldn't SOGA imply some sort of automatic warranty in all cases? I vaguely recall reading or being told that traders are obliged to provide a 3 month warranty as a bare minimum, but I would've presumed SOGA would apply to new cars rather than used cars bought caveat emptor.

Why are you taking it to an independant rather than an OPC by the way? If I was only paying a contribution towards it then I'd probably want Porsche to do it purely to show to any future prospective buyer that I didn't try and get it done on the cheap or whatever.

(Not a criticism of any indie but with a big restorative job I'd wonder why Porsche weren't doing it themselves *shrug*)

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
ok - garage first find IMS - repairs it gives it back to customer
noise still there - garage now discovers tappetts - repairs it and gives it back to customer
noise still there - garage finds piston-slap

hmmmmmmmmm sounds like the garage doesnt know their arse from their elbow - I would be a bit worried about that as well TBH!

davek_964

11,401 posts

206 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
I would probably pay the £1,500 since compared to the total bill it's fairly small - and even if the dealer should be paying the full amount it might take ages to resolve.

Having said that - I'd also want more info from the independent. What was the reason for replacing all the tappets on one side - i.e. what was wrong with them? It appears not to have been the main problem - so was it another problem or was it mis-diagnosis?

I don't know how much Cayman S engines are, but for your total bill I'm pretty sure 996 owners could have had an entirely new (exchange) engine. It seems pretty steep.

Adt

Original Poster:

30 posts

247 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Cheers R Soul

£11k includes the track rod (about £200), the RMS (£1000) and tappets (£1000). The garage have been really good about it all and lent me a car for the whole time (albeit a corsa, followed by a f***cking kia).

I would love to tell the dealer to get stuffed but the inconvience and eventually costs could easily end up being more than £1000.

Sh*t situation isn't it!

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
R Soul said:
If your rebuild is done 'properly' I agree it shouldn't reduce the value of your car and could make it more sellable.
hmm - IMHO an engine thats works fine and hasnt been fiddled with is more attractive than an engine that has had problems and has then been fiddled with/fixed/corrected as IMHO once you start fiddling - thats when the problems begin!!!

khushy

davek_964

11,401 posts

206 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Adt said:
Cheers R Soul

£11k includes the track rod (about £200), the RMS (£1000) and tappets (£1000). The garage have been really good about it all and lent me a car for the whole time (albeit a corsa, followed by a f***cking kia).

I would love to tell the dealer to get stuffed but the inconvience and eventually costs could easily end up being more than £1000.

Sh*t situation isn't it!
That still leaves £9k for the rest of the engine work. I think you're being a lot more positive about the independent than many of us would. It sounds extremely expensive - I bet you could have had an entire new engine for less.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
Sorry to hear.

Adt said:
1) Will getting all this work done a) increase the value of the car?
b) decrease the value of the car?
c) no change in value but more saleable?
b) no change in value but less saleable?
The above will be very dependent on who you are selling to.

Some people prefer the idea of an original car, and the thought of an engine removal/rebuild will scare them into thinking it is a 'faulty' car.

Others (generally the more eductated on these matters) will see it a plus point.

For example, if I were seaching for a 996 N/a or Boxster/Cayman, and I found one that had had an engine rebuilt by the likes of Hartech, that's be a huge plus for me, but not everyone would have the same view.

Adt

Original Poster:

30 posts

247 months

Wednesday 3rd August 2011
quotequote all
ALL - I would question the indie but the independant engineer from the warranty company agreed, which resulted in the track rod, RMS and tappets being replaced at their cost - I'm sure they were sure because they don't pay out lightly

Also, I haven't had the car back in all this time. They fixed the tappets, started it up, then heard the noise.

I therefore suspect both needed doing but they initially didn't strip it any further than needed to replace the tappets.

....and I wish it was with Porsche now I know the extent of the work but it's gone too far to take it there now.