Soldier looking for Advice on 911.
Discussion
Gents,
Im a serving soldier, 22yrs service and off to Afghanistan next yr for 6 months. After i come back and along with the sale of my Audi A3 3.2, ill have a budget of £19k for a Porsche.
Im after a 996 Carrera. I have had fairly decent cars in the past such as Honda CRX 1.6vtec, RS2000 (the 4x4Mk5 one), Ford Puma, Subaru Impreza (which i had from new) and now a Audi A3 3.2 V6. Admittedly not exactly exotic cars but good drivers cars. I understand the servicing costs hence the Impreza and Audi so the "looking after" of the Porsche doesnt worry me. In fact i was on the verge a few years ago of buying a 2nd hand Boxster Anniversary. Whenever i buy a car i tend to spend ages looking over ones before putting the money down so distance and time taking to get one doesnt worry me. Can any of you PH experts give me any advice as to what to look for?
Spec wise i would like a Carrera 4, if only because after the Audi and Subaru im used to the 4x4 confidence. Its really a year away from buying the car so prices will drop even more but id prefer to buy an older low mileage car than a newer high miler one, or does this not matter with Porsche's?
Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Im a serving soldier, 22yrs service and off to Afghanistan next yr for 6 months. After i come back and along with the sale of my Audi A3 3.2, ill have a budget of £19k for a Porsche.
Im after a 996 Carrera. I have had fairly decent cars in the past such as Honda CRX 1.6vtec, RS2000 (the 4x4Mk5 one), Ford Puma, Subaru Impreza (which i had from new) and now a Audi A3 3.2 V6. Admittedly not exactly exotic cars but good drivers cars. I understand the servicing costs hence the Impreza and Audi so the "looking after" of the Porsche doesnt worry me. In fact i was on the verge a few years ago of buying a 2nd hand Boxster Anniversary. Whenever i buy a car i tend to spend ages looking over ones before putting the money down so distance and time taking to get one doesnt worry me. Can any of you PH experts give me any advice as to what to look for?
Spec wise i would like a Carrera 4, if only because after the Audi and Subaru im used to the 4x4 confidence. Its really a year away from buying the car so prices will drop even more but id prefer to buy an older low mileage car than a newer high miler one, or does this not matter with Porsche's?
Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
I would not go the 996 route if I was working on a £19,000 budget. 996's at that price are going to be `leggy` and could cost you a fortune to run. This wouldn't endear you to the brand and if you know what they say about polishing a turd? You might be very lucky and find a gem but it is unlikely. The Cayman/Boxster S route makes more sense and once you've driven one you'll be impressed. I have owned 964/993/996 and 997 along with Boxster S 986 and 987. The 987 Boxster S is a fantastic car and although I haven't driven a Cayman they do get high praise from owners with regard to the driving experience.
I have also owned an Audi A4 and A6 with 4wd. These are also superb as every day vehicles but they don't involve the driver they way that a Porsche does. I only ever had one 4wd Porsche and that was a 993C4S. A beautiful car but Porsches with 2wd have so much mechanical grip and traction that my advice would be to go 2wd rather than 4wd.
I have also owned an Audi A4 and A6 with 4wd. These are also superb as every day vehicles but they don't involve the driver they way that a Porsche does. I only ever had one 4wd Porsche and that was a 993C4S. A beautiful car but Porsches with 2wd have so much mechanical grip and traction that my advice would be to go 2wd rather than 4wd.

Hello chap. Hope you have a good tour. A friend of mine did the same, but he bought an M6 when he came back from tour.
There are quite a few threads about this already so have a search (I'll try and post a few links).
The main *worry* with a 996 is the apparent engine woes; reported ad naseum on the internet, and there is a lot of bunkum mixed in with scremongering, however, if you were to be caught out by it, it could be pretty damaging to your bank balance. Instead, read up the facts on the issue so that you are clued up on the matter ( Hartech's website is a good place to start).
I share your preference for 4wd - you'll probably get a lot of 'experts' who will tell you that the C2 is the purer experience, and this is probably strictly true, however, having driven both, there isn't very much in it, it's not apprent 99% of the time on the p[ublic road and the 'purer' C2 will be slower as soon as the conditions are anything less than perfect. (about 2 secs a lap at Bedford in the case of the 997)
Just watch out for the budget creep whilst searching.....

GJB said:
I would not go the 996 route if I was working on a £19,000 budget. 996's at that price are going to be `leggy` and could cost you a fortune to run. This wouldn't endear you to the brand and if you know what they say about polishing a turd? You might be very lucky and find a gem but it is unlikely. The Cayman/Boxster S route makes more sense and once you've driven one you'll be impressed.
What rubbish. Why would you say that with no backing whatsoever?Two seconds of searching...
(OK, not C4's but C4's don't command a premium over C2 - if anything, they're less)
£500 under budget (or £2.5k under budget if you go 'bug' price)
http://www.911virgin.com/porscheforsale/346/996C2c...
http://www.specialistcarsltd.co.uk/item/607/catid/...
Cheers for all the quick replies.
I should of said on the original post im looking at Caymans as well. I have "road tested" a mates Cayman and thought it pretty good. But, and this may sound silly, i like the fact there is some sort of rear seats in the back, as in the 911. I dont consider taking anyone in the back but as i said silly as it sounds, i like the fact i can throw in the back a jacket or bag etc without filling up the front seat or having to use the boot all the time. And before you say, my Audi's rear seats are not full of junk! lol.
I know every car seems to come with a known fault such as RMS etc with the original Boxsters so ill accept that ill have to look carefully for that side of life and dont have a issue getting an expert to look over any prospective buy.
A next door neighbour has a 996 C4S and i have had ago in that and it got me but not sure i could get a good one for my budget, but as people said i will wait the year and see what the market is like when i get back.
I should of said on the original post im looking at Caymans as well. I have "road tested" a mates Cayman and thought it pretty good. But, and this may sound silly, i like the fact there is some sort of rear seats in the back, as in the 911. I dont consider taking anyone in the back but as i said silly as it sounds, i like the fact i can throw in the back a jacket or bag etc without filling up the front seat or having to use the boot all the time. And before you say, my Audi's rear seats are not full of junk! lol.
I know every car seems to come with a known fault such as RMS etc with the original Boxsters so ill accept that ill have to look carefully for that side of life and dont have a issue getting an expert to look over any prospective buy.
A next door neighbour has a 996 C4S and i have had ago in that and it got me but not sure i could get a good one for my budget, but as people said i will wait the year and see what the market is like when i get back.
my 2p . . .
most Porsche owners under an OPC warranty - service and maintain their cars as lovingly as possible without regard to cost (MOSTLY) - once an OPC warranty expires cost becomes more important and things get done by Indie's/delayed/skimped on/non OEM parts or not at all.
The older a Porsche is the less reliable its "solid" history can be and consequently the costs go up as does the RISK!!!!
Same with ANY supercar!
khushy
most Porsche owners under an OPC warranty - service and maintain their cars as lovingly as possible without regard to cost (MOSTLY) - once an OPC warranty expires cost becomes more important and things get done by Indie's/delayed/skimped on/non OEM parts or not at all.
The older a Porsche is the less reliable its "solid" history can be and consequently the costs go up as does the RISK!!!!
Same with ANY supercar!
khushy
petop said:
A next door neighbour has a 996 C4S and i have had ago in that and it got me but not sure i could get a good one for my budget, but as people said i will wait the year and see what the market is like when i get back.
Yes, a lot can change in a year.You can certainly now get a 'good' C4S for 20k, but it may be leggy and may be in a unpopular colour scheme (neither necesarrily a problem - high miles does not equal bad car, and you may like rainforest green with savannah interior).
100k mile C4S's were around the £19k mark 18 months ago, so who knows what level of C4S will be at the £19k mark another 12 months from now?
I do like the A3 3.2. Before it i had the Impreza which i loved but the older i got for one i dont think it suited me at my age. The thing about the 3.2 is the torque and its more relaxed way it drives. My only bug bear about it is it has a heavy front end so understeers a fair bit and of course the fuel economy but coming from an Impreza its nothing unusual.
I have seen some interesting colours in Porsche's, ox blood red one doesnt flick my switch but i would probably go for the black interior rather than anything too bright!
I have seen some interesting colours in Porsche's, ox blood red one doesnt flick my switch but i would probably go for the black interior rather than anything too bright!
monthefish said:
I share your preference for 4wd - you'll probably get a lot of 'experts' who will tell you that the C2 is the purer experience, and this is probably strictly true, however, having driven both, there isn't very much in it, it's not apprent 99% of the time on the p[ublic road and the 'purer' C2 will be slower as soon as the conditions are anything less than perfect.
What he means is that there *is* a difference to the way the 2 and 4wd versions drive (mainly the steering IME). This doesn't matter to MTF who lives in the perpetually rainy north, but not everyone agrees with him. You should try both and make your own mind up. Don't assume from your experience of 4wd versions of front wheel drive cars that the same lessons apply to 911s.
SS7
2001, C4, Manual 34k miles, £19,500

http://pistonheads.com/sales/2457039.htm
or for £13,995 from a dealer, 77k miles (which is nothing really if the car is decent)

http://pistonheads.com/sales/3072416.htm
Or how about a nice 2003 C4S with 53k miles for £19,900

http://pistonheads.com/sales/3068198.htm

http://pistonheads.com/sales/2457039.htm
or for £13,995 from a dealer, 77k miles (which is nothing really if the car is decent)

http://pistonheads.com/sales/3072416.htm
Or how about a nice 2003 C4S with 53k miles for £19,900

http://pistonheads.com/sales/3068198.htm
shoestring7 said:
..
You again?
shoestring7 said:
What he means is that there *is* a difference to the way the 2 and 4wd versions drive (mainly the steering IME).
Course there is. There has to be. It's just not a big a difference as some like to make out (again, most of whom have never experienced both)shoestring7 said:
This doesn't matter to MTF who lives in the perpetually rainy north,
To me, the benefits far outweigh the negatives (which, IME, are fairly insignificant). Each to their own. (I'd never want a 4wd track car if that helps you at all?)shoestring7 said:
You should try both and make your own mind up. Don't assume from your experience of 4wd versions of front wheel drive cars that the same lessons apply to 911s.
Fair point.GJB said:
I would not go the 996 route if I was working on a £19,000 budget. 996's at that price are going to be `leggy` and could cost you a fortune to run. This wouldn't endear you to the brand and if you know what they say about polishing a turd? You might be very lucky and find a gem but it is unlikely.
Seriously? Have you looked at 996 prices recently?Junior Bianno said:
GJB said:
I would not go the 996 route if I was working on a £19,000 budget. 996's at that price are going to be `leggy` and could cost you a fortune to run. This wouldn't endear you to the brand and if you know what they say about polishing a turd? You might be very lucky and find a gem but it is unlikely.
Seriously? Have you looked at 996 prices recently?You could do a lot worse than calling someone like Henry or Joel at RSJ and maybe arrannig to pop along to have a chat. Just do it on a weekday rather than the weekend when they'll be v rushed.
I don't know Joel, but I've dealt with Henry a few times and I think you could do a lot worse than spend an hour down there if you are anywhere near Uxbridge
Good luck and stay safe!
I don't know Joel, but I've dealt with Henry a few times and I think you could do a lot worse than spend an hour down there if you are anywhere near Uxbridge
Good luck and stay safe!
davek_964 said:
Junior Bianno said:
GJB said:
I would not go the 996 route if I was working on a £19,000 budget. 996's at that price are going to be `leggy` and could cost you a fortune to run. This wouldn't endear you to the brand and if you know what they say about polishing a turd? You might be very lucky and find a gem but it is unlikely.
Seriously? Have you looked at 996 prices recently?Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


