Porsche battery
Discussion
Porsche batteries really are substandard.
My last two cars , got rid of one after 10 years and the other about 8 years old, both still on the original battery ( Volvo and Toyota ).
Cayman battery chucked it after 2 years , friend's C2s battery chucked it inside 2 years.
They are cheap rubbish.
My last two cars , got rid of one after 10 years and the other about 8 years old, both still on the original battery ( Volvo and Toyota ).
Cayman battery chucked it after 2 years , friend's C2s battery chucked it inside 2 years.
They are cheap rubbish.
My experience is similar. The orginal Porsche MOLL battery lasted 7 or 8 years and the replacement (local equivalent) maybe 2 to 3. I think manufacturers are under pressure to reduce costs wherever they can.
On the other hand it may have something to do with the way more recent car are designed to reduce CO2 emssions. For example in my other car (a MY2009 BMW 335i) the iDrive controls the alternator such that:
- the alternator only operates and starts charging after some 20 (or so) minutes in order to reduce the engine load when cold and hence reduce emissions and
- the charging profile is tailored in accordance with battery charge and condition (the dealer is supposed to program the car when the battery has been replaced in order to select a profile suitable for the new battery!)
Hence, if you don't drive the regularly for more than 20 minutes your battery charge and overall condition quickly deteriorates. Fortunately,the dealer is going to do a software upload to start charging straight away and replace the battery under warranty so all's well !
On the other hand it may have something to do with the way more recent car are designed to reduce CO2 emssions. For example in my other car (a MY2009 BMW 335i) the iDrive controls the alternator such that:
- the alternator only operates and starts charging after some 20 (or so) minutes in order to reduce the engine load when cold and hence reduce emissions and
- the charging profile is tailored in accordance with battery charge and condition (the dealer is supposed to program the car when the battery has been replaced in order to select a profile suitable for the new battery!)
Hence, if you don't drive the regularly for more than 20 minutes your battery charge and overall condition quickly deteriorates. Fortunately,the dealer is going to do a software upload to start charging straight away and replace the battery under warranty so all's well !
R Soul said:
a mere £1295 if you spec it on a new Cayman R, Spyder, GT3 RS 4.0 ...And you get the standard battery included as well.
cooldude00 said:
how much is it to replace the official porsche battery btw?
my CTEK battery maintainer is showing up a solid green light alongside a flashing orange light, which is apparently indicative of sulphated battery and requires replacing....
I was quoted somewhere between £250 and £300 for my 987S. I bought a Bosch one for under £100 and fitted it myself.my CTEK battery maintainer is showing up a solid green light alongside a flashing orange light, which is apparently indicative of sulphated battery and requires replacing....

Better battery for much less money, but no Porsche warranty...
cooldude00 said:
mine is still under porsche warranty so don't think they'll let me fit non-branded batteries...
According to my OPC (when my battery died!), I could have fitted a non-Porsche supplied item without formally invalidating the warranty. However...if any future failure was linked to the non-standard item, a claim may no longer be valid!cooldude00 said:
this is really odd now... so my car's with the OPC and i've got a loaner.. new car... and the battery maintainer is showing exactly the same - solid green light with flashing orange... which makes me wonder if it's the connection.. but i've checked it and it's still the same?
Assuming you are using the optional plug for the cigarette lighter on your CTEK, then the socket on some cars is not quite deep enough for a perfect fit with this plug. As a result, if you don't push the plug in to the last millimetre (or twist it round a bit), you get the solid green and flashing orange and it won't charge. Not sure if Porsches have this issue though.If after pressing the plug in firmly, it's still giving you problems, it's probably a faulty charger.
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




