Old pork itch
Author
Discussion

mikees

Original Poster:

2,910 posts

203 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
I have had a number of boxsters, 911's and most recently a 997 S, but always hanker after an older 911. Torn between chopping the 997 in for a 964 or a 993. The attraction of a car that cost the same to maintain but without the opc warranty cost and won't depreciate is very attractive.

What are the views of others who have made the new to old transition?

Can't find much on search as on iPad on west coast of France on 3G.

This is a "what if" post after days on a surf board and sun lounger. Fancy a 964 but would a 993 be more sensible ?

Will always " buy on condition" but what are views on the cars?

Apologies for spelling. iPad keyboard crap and too much red wine :-)


Mikr

daveyb662

1,722 posts

196 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
Your spelling looked so good until it came to spelling your name! Haha

mikees

Original Poster:

2,910 posts

203 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
Git! hehe

carsarecool

4,456 posts

270 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
I've gone from Lotus > TVR T350 > Boxster S > 993.

The Boxster was fully loaded incl PCM and beautiful interior so it was a bit of a culture shock going 'backwards' so to speak.

But, once inside you really do appreciate the solidity of a 993 as well as the 'classic' feel of the car.

Be selective, wait for the right car and buy the best you can and it will reward you hugely.

I got slightly twitchy a few weeks back and started to look at gt3's when my car was in for some warranty work, but now the only car I would change to would be a 993 or 964 lightweight of some description.

There are some lovely 'recreations' for sale depending on your budget in the pre 89 ph classifieds. Warning though.....it could be an expensive browsing session biggrin

Have fun with your search and good luck!


ras62

1,115 posts

187 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
As a daily driver I would think its a lot to ask of a 15+ year old car, even though the build quality was excellent. Saying this you could still put money into maintaining an older car and find it cheaper than the depreciation on a newer 997, one reason I bought a 964 over newer metal. If it is a car to enjoy at weekends then absolutely, they are still fast, very entertaining, much more demanding and imo pretty in a way the later cars are just...not. £ wise it is a sensible move, but you can live without the 997 creature comforts?

mikees

Original Poster:

2,910 posts

203 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
I did 1500 miles in the last 12 months so this is NOT a daily driver. I have a Volvo xc90 for the commute.

911Thrasher

2,573 posts

230 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
Do it! I use to run both my 993 carrera and later 993 turbo until recently as a daily averaging 10 kmiles per year.
Even took them both to Courchevel in the snow with snowboards and to West coast France and Cornwall numerous tim with surfboards on the roof. Thule makes and still sells roofrack that will fit aircooled 911

Aircooled rocks and i really regret selling my 993turbo for the 360 modena, which didn't last - 10kmiles 4months - for the now 7.1RS...but nothing will replace the aircooled.

The only reason i ended up with the 7.1RS is because i couldnt find a perfect 993RS at the time and couldnt bear the time without a 911.

Actually thinking of selling the 7.1RS for a 964/993RS - problem is finding a low mileage one as i will be putting 8-10kmiles on it per year.
So if i buy one with 80kmiles 2 years down the line it'll have 100kmiles which at resale time will hurt. So buying a low mileage one does make alot of sense in my case.

The old 993 carrera in Cornwall


The old 993 turbo all packed up


with the old 360


and now with my current RS


Edited by 911Thrasher on Tuesday 16th August 23:18


Edited by 911Thrasher on Tuesday 16th August 23:19


Edited by 911Thrasher on Tuesday 16th August 23:25

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
I think it depends on how many miles you do and what kind of miles you do.

For example, if you spend most of the time on the motorway, an air cooled 911 is pretty crap. A diesel euro box is much better.

If however, you travel on a variety of roads that dont suffer too much congestion (i.e; you can explore a cars dynamics), then they are fabulous.

My solution for my type of driving is a Laguna Diesel and a 993 Carrera (Manual of course). I could have a 997 as a compromise but I prefer my two 'extremes'. They compliment each other perfectly.

OK, not as perfectly as say, a 964RS and a Jaaag Diesel maybe but you get my drift.

MTR


ras62

1,115 posts

187 months

Tuesday 16th August 2011
quotequote all
O/P then get one bought, you will love 'em. Just get the car inspected by someone who knows the older cars so to avoid crap, keep a grand back for addition jobs and enjoy.

johnycarrera

1,935 posts

261 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
If you do it and don't like it you shouldn't lose much if anything!
The 993 is easy to live with, and as you say you have something else for the commute! The older cars just look and sound fantastic and there's more of a sense of occasion smile

Junior Bianno

1,400 posts

224 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I've done just that. Sold the 997 after having had a few modern Porsches and got a mint, pretty much standard 964. Absolutely love it. It's in the process of a few (a lot) of modifications and I love that too. Feels much more of an event to drive and it's not slow. Not as quick as my last C2S but it feels it. I actually think I could use it as a daily driver, but I wouldn't want to. It's been pampered and I wouldn't want to put it through daily commutes, crappy winter weather and gritty roads etc. Its not a garage queen, but I'm happier being, er, selective about when it goes out.

Do it!

davek_964

11,401 posts

206 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
From a "cost to maintain" point of view, a 993 might be a better bet. Service costs on 964s tend to be higher, due to non-hydraulic valves.

I owned my 964 for 10 years - and for the last two of those years also had my 996 turbo. Initially, I thought the 964 would never go - it was such a different drive to the 996 and much more fun. However, the more I got used the 996 turbo the more fun it became - and although they were very different, my desire to use the 964 disappeared to almost nothing. It began to feel old.

If it had been my only "nice" car, then it would probably have been different. The air cooled certainly do have more character than the water cooled cars - but I think the water cooled cars a lot more versatile. Until about 5 years ago, my 964 was my daily driver - and I loved it. In fact - before I bought the turbo, I did consider making the 964 my daily again - but decided I was too old for that and wanted something a bit more relaxing for the trips to work (not that the 996 turbo is exactly boring!).

Dave

cuse92

87 posts

187 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
Since you are saying that it is not a daily driver, I would say go for it. I went from a 993 to a 996 to a 997, back to a 964-based Paul Stephens car. I enjoyed the water-cooled cars but always missed the 993 (except for the minor issue of the aesthetics of the front end, which I don't like).

I do about 5000 miles a year, mostly on overnight weekend trips and B-road blasts, and it is just so much more fun at sane speeds and in the air-cooled cars there is a sense of occasion that IMHO is a bit lacking in the modern cars. And the prices are stabilised if not increasing for the air cooled cars, while they are continuing to settle for the 996/7, so you could always fairly easily get back into a 997 without losing your shirt if in the end it wasn't for you...

pete

1,637 posts

315 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I can certainly sympathise with this. I changed from 11 years of TVR ownership to a 997.1 GT3, which I love to bits - best car I've ever owned by a long chalk. However I now find myself hankering after something a bit less polished.

I can definitely see myself swapping to a 930, 964 turbo or even a nice 993 at some point in the future.

Pete

nsm3

2,831 posts

227 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I always keep an eye on the older stuff, but there seems to be far fewer 993's available at the dealers than 18 months ago, especially JZM for instance.

GravyStain

162 posts

185 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I'm in a similar boat...

Sold my Turbo S a couple of months ago. Now i'm running an S2000 as a semi-snotter (actually that's being harsh, it's a fantastic bit of fun).

When I get back into pork in a year (after being a good boy and walloping some money off the mortgage), I know I will be severely tempted by a 930 or a 993 Turbo. Minimal depreciation, purist and a big sense of occasion.

Stepping out of pork has hurt, but in a years time I can step back into it as though it will be the first time, so my requirements may not be a Gen2 GT3 because a 993 Turbo will still feel miles more special than my current pocket rocket.

Absence really will make the heart grow fonder smile

all2ofme

855 posts

219 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
996 GT3?

Sometimes I wonder if I shouldn't have got the middle ground between my old 997.1 C2S and my current 996.1 GT3. Which'd be your car. Are we never happy? biggrin

pete said:
I can certainly sympathise with this. I changed from 11 years of TVR ownership to a 997.1 GT3, which I love to bits - best car I've ever owned by a long chalk. However I now find myself hankering after something a bit less polished.

I can definitely see myself swapping to a 930, 964 turbo or even a nice 993 at some point in the future.

Pete

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I've owned classic Porsches for years, including a 1977 Carrera 3.0, 1973 2.4S, 964RS and currently a mint 3.0SC. I wouldn't honestly use any of these as a daily driver, but they're hard to beat on a sunny weekend blast. Haven't had much experience of the 993, except for a quick test drive in a 993TT and found it quite dull compared to the 964RS I had at the time.

Fastfred

125 posts

220 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
I've worked my way back from a new Boxster S, via a nearly new 996 and am now in a 16 year old 993C4.

Fortunately its a second car used for high days and holidays, you need plenty of concentration all the time to make it work smoothly............but when it does, its worth it. If you get lazy, they bite!

Just don't expect 2010 style comfort and ease of use.

Pick wisely if you go for one, make sure its been looked after and serviced and expect a couple of hefty bills in the first couple of years (in my case RMS/cam covers and 2 years ago a suspension refresh with M033, I think lower sport option but not the fancy springs/dampers).

HTH

mikees

Original Poster:

2,910 posts

203 months

Wednesday 17th August 2011
quotequote all
So, any ideas on value of 05 54 997 c2s, 60k miles, 6 months OPC warranty, basic spec (no PCM, sat etc) silver, blue leather, 19" carreras, good condition? 24k private?