Porsche Warranty - not as good as it used to be.
Discussion
I'm currently looking at the purchase of a used Cayman S and phoned up my local dealer about putting a warranty on it. Can't believe the way the system now works where the car has to be inspected every time the warranty is renewed. What a great way for the Stealers to genereate extra revenue.
I have been doing a bit of research and am very suprised that some people have been refused warranty because the tyres have 'only 3mm' left on them and they are not prepared to pay out for brand new tyres. Additionall after market stereos and parking sensors have also resulted in warranty renewal refusals.
What was surprising is that the dealer even admitted the level of control on items being identified as requiring replacement varies massively between the dealerships.
I neve had this problem when I had the 911; ah the good old days....
I have been doing a bit of research and am very suprised that some people have been refused warranty because the tyres have 'only 3mm' left on them and they are not prepared to pay out for brand new tyres. Additionall after market stereos and parking sensors have also resulted in warranty renewal refusals.
What was surprising is that the dealer even admitted the level of control on items being identified as requiring replacement varies massively between the dealerships.
I neve had this problem when I had the 911; ah the good old days....
Edited by dasherdiablo1 on Wednesday 17th August 21:41
dasherdiablo1 said:
the car has to be inspected every time the warranty is renewed.
what? surely if it's in the dealer network for servicing etc then they "know" the car anyway? so why the need for an inspection?dasherdiablo1 said:
some people have been refused warranty because the tyres have 'only 3mm' left on them
that's ridiculous, well within the legal limit! As above.
Really don't see what the gripe is with the Porsche warranty to be honest. It's not forced on you, the terms are clearly laid out on their website, etc. If you don't agree to them, get a more flexible warranty from a third-party.
Also from the perspective of managing risk how can you expect them to provide an all-encompassing warranty on anything other than a known quantity? This means a standard car fitted with Porsche parts really, anything else is a bit of a gamble. As far as I'm aware beyond checking that everything fitted is OEM the inspection is merely making sure you're not trying to sneak something through on a warranty claim that was broken prior to taking out the policy, similar to taking out AA cover when you've already broken down.
I do agree that some of the restrictions seem quite onerous - particularly regarding aftermarket stereos, etc. But on the flip side I can sympathise with their point of view too - a badly installed stereo could do all sorts to the electrical system leading to an owner - maliciously or otherwise - rolling in wanting a malfunctioning car fixed FOC.
Fundamentally though it seems from anecdotal evidence that if you prepared to keep the car standard (or Porsche spec anyway) car it is by far the best warranty to have, if indeed you are keen to have a warranty.
Really don't see what the gripe is with the Porsche warranty to be honest. It's not forced on you, the terms are clearly laid out on their website, etc. If you don't agree to them, get a more flexible warranty from a third-party.
Also from the perspective of managing risk how can you expect them to provide an all-encompassing warranty on anything other than a known quantity? This means a standard car fitted with Porsche parts really, anything else is a bit of a gamble. As far as I'm aware beyond checking that everything fitted is OEM the inspection is merely making sure you're not trying to sneak something through on a warranty claim that was broken prior to taking out the policy, similar to taking out AA cover when you've already broken down.
I do agree that some of the restrictions seem quite onerous - particularly regarding aftermarket stereos, etc. But on the flip side I can sympathise with their point of view too - a badly installed stereo could do all sorts to the electrical system leading to an owner - maliciously or otherwise - rolling in wanting a malfunctioning car fixed FOC.
Fundamentally though it seems from anecdotal evidence that if you prepared to keep the car standard (or Porsche spec anyway) car it is by far the best warranty to have, if indeed you are keen to have a warranty.
Well, it is certainly not as good as when it was £725 for any model in the range, there were no issues renewing so long as you had a full history and anything that needed doing was done without cost or issue if they found something during a service. That was 2006. By 2007 it was much the same, but increased to £895. Then a couple of years later the price sharply increased again, all of the daft terms came in (strictly OEM - not even Bosch batteries or wiper blades and that silliness) and along with most people I knew at the time I dropped off of the scheme. More recently I understand that the price came back down a little and a degree of discretion returned on alterations to the car.
So the answer to the thread title must be : correct. Though in its current incarnation it still may be worth having to many out there.
So the answer to the thread title must be : correct. Though in its current incarnation it still may be worth having to many out there.
davek_964 said:
I thought you were due to buy a car a week or two back, but cancelled because the stock market crashed and we were all about to become unemployed. Have things recovered so quickly?
Don't be a prick.A good car at a very good price has come up so the opportunity presents itself.
dasherdiablo1 said:
Don't be a prick.
A good car at a very good price has come up so the opportunity presents itself.
After your "the world is going into financial meltdown" addition to an existing thread - particularly one that had absolutely nothing to do with that anyway - I think my question was fairly valid.A good car at a very good price has come up so the opportunity presents itself.
Still - thanks for the forum abuse. I'll be careful to ignore your posts in future.
davek_964 said:
dasherdiablo1 said:
Don't be a prick.
A good car at a very good price has come up so the opportunity presents itself.
After your "the world is going into financial meltdown" addition to an existing thread - particularly one that had absolutely nothing to do with that anyway - I think my question was fairly valid.A good car at a very good price has come up so the opportunity presents itself.
Still - thanks for the forum abuse. I'll be careful to ignore your posts in future.
Tydeides said:
My dealer is happy to not charge the inspection when the warranty is renewed simultaneously with the service. This seems a sensible approach to me.
I was told that as long as you take out the warranty, the inspection part of it is free - service or no service?If you choose not to warranty it, say because you don't want to shell out on new tyres as yours only have twice the legal limit on them (mini
), then you will get charged for the inspection.dasherdiablo1 said:
So your original comment wasn't posted to be rude or try to make me look stupid then?
If I wanted to be rude, I would be considerably more direct. You clearly stated in that other thread that - based on information you had, from friends who were "in the know" that you'd be very nervous about making any big purchases any time soon. Regardless of whether it's a good deal or not, a Cayman S is hardly loose change - and unless the car you were about to buy before was in a whole different league of expense, it's hard to see what changed. It was therefore a genuine question.
davek_964 said:
dasherdiablo1 said:
So your original comment wasn't posted to be rude or try to make me look stupid then?
If I wanted to be rude, I would be considerably more direct. You clearly stated in that other thread that - based on information you had, from friends who were "in the know" that you'd be very nervous about making any big purchases any time soon. Regardless of whether it's a good deal or not, a Cayman S is hardly loose change - and unless the car you were about to buy before was in a whole different league of expense, it's hard to see what changed. It was therefore a genuine question.
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


