997 C4S - new clutch required?
997 C4S - new clutch required?
Author
Discussion

sidicks

Original Poster:

25,218 posts

252 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
A few times recently, I've noticed that when changing gear the revs briefly rise as if the gear is not properly engaged, before the car accelerates normally.

The car is a 2006 C4S which is coming up to 40k miles, so I assume that the clutch needs replacing (or is there something else that could plausibly be causing these symptoms)?

As the car is under Porsche warranty, I don't really have any option as to where to take it to be fixed so I wondered what I should expect it to cost?

Also, as the problem has only just started to occur, how much leeway do I have before it is likely to become an urgent repair requirement rather than just a minor inconvenience, as currently? (The car is my daily driver).

Finally, if they are replacing the clutch, is there anything worth having done at the same time (The car is about 6 months from it's 6-year service)?

Thanks
smile
Sidicks

Flat6time

1,770 posts

241 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
sidicks said:
As the car is under Porsche warranty, I don't really have any option as to where to take it to be fixed
Not true,

The rules state that you can take it anywhere as long as genuine parts are used, and fitted to a Porsche standard.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
Can't really advise on the other stuff but what you've described sounds like a classic slipping clutch. It'll get worse and worse the more it slips until eventually it'll fail completely.

sidicks

Original Poster:

25,218 posts

252 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
Flat6time said:
Not true,

The rules state that you can take it anywhere as long as genuine parts are used, and fitted to a Porsche standard.
As far as I'm aware, this isn't true for the Porsche extended warranty.
smile
Sidicks

Gibbo205

3,572 posts

238 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
sidicks said:
As far as I'm aware, this isn't true for the Porsche extended warranty.
smile
Sidicks
Porsche said to myself anyone can work on my car even under extended warranty, as long as Porsche genuine parts are used and its done to Porsche standards.

cay

380 posts

187 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
The document for my OPC warranty ( taken out March this year ) says the car must be maintained to the manufacturer's specification and that all parts must be Porsche approved.

It doesn't say specifically that you have to use a Porsche centre.

STiG911

1,210 posts

198 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
What everyone else has said - you don't HAVE to go to the OPC for all repairs and maintenance in order to maintain your warranty.
Get on the blower and get some quotes for a new clutch. Remember that unlike an OPC, most specialist garages will charge a package price for the job, an OPC will bill by the hour, making the job way higher than neccessary.
also, taking the car to a specialist for the work would help on the 'other jobs that (might) need doing' For example, the IMS bearing, or RMS seal might nee attention, and the OPC might not readily point this out, or offer a price to fix.

sidicks

Original Poster:

25,218 posts

252 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
STiG911 said:
What everyone else has said - you don't HAVE to go to the OPC for all repairs and maintenance in order to maintain your warranty.
Get on the blower and get some quotes for a new clutch. Remember that unlike an OPC, most specialist garages will charge a package price for the job, an OPC will bill by the hour, making the job way higher than neccessary.
Thanks, I will bear this in mind!

STiG911 said:
also, taking the car to a specialist for the work would help on the 'other jobs that (might) need doing' For example, the IMS bearing, or RMS seal might nee attention, and the OPC might not readily point this out, or offer a price to fix.
Given that the RMS is a warranty issue then surely the OPC are likely to point this out, as they will recover the costs from Porsche?!
smile
Sidicks

IanHug

414 posts

268 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
sidicks said:
Given that the RMS is a warranty issue then surely the OPC are likely to point this out, as they will recover the costs from Porsche?!
smile
Sidicks
Might be worth your while seeing if it does need an RMS - the clutch done at the same time will be £1000 less than having it done separately.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Thursday 18th August 2011
quotequote all
IanHug said:
Might be worth your while seeing if it does need an RMS - the clutch done at the same time will be £1000 less than having it done separately.
I wonder how they diagnose the RMS - just dampness from that area I'd guess? So if for some reason whistle there was dampness in that area when they checked, they'd get onto the warranty people for an authority to replace the RMS, once approved they should offer you the chance to replace the clutch for just the part cost whilst they're in there.