Help to buy!
Author
Discussion

SimC

Original Poster:

154 posts

188 months

Friday 19th August 2011
quotequote all
Currently driving a 997 GTS but have managed to persuade SWSBO who has inherited some money that it would be a good investment for her to buy an older Porsche either 964 or 3.2 to sit alongside it as "her" car rather than leave it in the bank. It will only be for occasional use and be garaged for the winter. It will be a keeper for a few years. Looking for something to fulfil the following criteria as we all are:
1. Had the necessary things sorted with good history.
2. Will retain value and hopefully increase as years progress (understand it will need to be maintained) so exclude this cost
3. Manual - would consider targa and coupe only
4. Don't want to spend more than 12k, preferable nearer 10 but could push it for the right car

Have spent several weeks looking at all classified but would like some of your specialist advice. So the question is, if it was your money, what would you buy that is currently in the classifieds? Would like to strike whilst "iron is hot"!! If you are also currently selling, pm me details too. Thanks guys

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

254 months

Friday 19th August 2011
quotequote all
For that sort of outlay, don't bank on getting anything which will rise in value.
You'll need to spend money on getting it something like, so forget trust me i've owned a few.
Decent 3.2 will cost around 15k, minter £20k.
Nice low milers private will top out around 25k, same with the Supersport.

Get the best you can afford, otherwise it will be a rotten money pit.

SimC

Original Poster:

154 posts

188 months

Friday 19th August 2011
quotequote all
Really appreciate the honest reply. Is that the same for 964. Am I better to add a bit and get a well loved 993 as a better long term investment.

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Friday 19th August 2011
quotequote all
SimC said:
Really appreciate the honest reply. Is that the same for 964. Am I better to add a bit and get a well loved 993 as a better long term investment.
In terms of 'investment potential' (and really we are talking long term here, anything less than 10 years at best will be 'nil cost to own'), I would go for the best 3.2 you can find.

MTR

Edited by mollytherocker on Friday 19th August 23:54


Edited by mollytherocker on Friday 19th August 23:54

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

254 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
SimC said:
Really appreciate the honest reply. Is that the same for 964. Am I better to add a bit and get a well loved 993 as a better long term investment.
964's have arch liners so the B Post's don't tend to rot as much, for a classic feel i'd opt for a 3.2 and just get the best you can afford.
993's great cars yes, bit of an in between car for me, never really understood all the "last of the air cooled" stuff, and owned a 993 C4S, still didn't get it.
Personally i'd go with a nice 3.2 between £15-20k mate, don't get hung up on spec or colour just a nice honest clean solid example. Lovely.

SimC

Original Poster:

154 posts

188 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys. Will keep eyes open for someone who wants cash quickly on a well sorted car. As the summer comes to an end (not that there has been one) hope a few options come available. If spending slightly less than 15/20k and closer to the 12k in my initial post, if anyone spots something interesting, would be grateful for a heads up. Happy to spend a bit here and there tidying up over the next few years.

Redeem

382 posts

214 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
There is a red 3.2 targa for sale at Portiacraft for around 15k. I have not seen it but it looks good on paper.

rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
Buy what she will enjoy owning and driving. Trying to second guess values in 1 year, 5 years or 10 years is impossible (despite what people may say) and will spoil the experience. Good luck!

christer

2,804 posts

282 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
As others have alluded to it should probably be clearly stated that it is very unlikely that the cars you mention will be any kind of investment - I.e. An investment is something that will provide a positive return over a period of time. Sure, depreciation may be near zero - but that is completely different to an investment as I am sure you realise.

If the "investment" is in the pleasure of owning one of these cars then of course it is a very different matter smile

Herbs

5,132 posts

260 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
If you can find a bit more to invest then a NSX would be top of my list. I'm picking up my first 911 tomorrow but seriously considered the NSX as well but had to scratch the itch

It's only going to rise in price wink

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
SimC said:
Thanks for the input guys. Will keep eyes open for someone who wants cash quickly on a well sorted car.
Good luck with that!

Most owner's have a clear, if not inflated view of there cars.

Don't try and buy a classic cheap. Buy carefully.

Mtr

Edited by mollytherocker on Saturday 20th August 10:54

carcrazypop

579 posts

195 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
You did say 'her' car in the original post, so I assume she will be driving it on occasions ??

If so, let her drive the 3.2 before buying as they don't have power steering, and can therefore be quite heavy to park etc.

964's & 993's do have power steering.
Just a thought & good luck in your search.

SimC

Original Poster:

154 posts

188 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
Thanks again for input. The zero depreciation is the important part since she won't earn anything in the bank at the mo. Although it is "her"car she does have a modern family car so it will be a third when either if us feel like using it car. Note points re 3.2 and leaning towards a 964 targa. Slightly more modern/usable and quite a few around at a decent price. As far as the investment potential I know they are not going to grow much if at all but at least It will be fun. The search is on!

Shoestringracer

2,121 posts

230 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
There are £10k cars that are fun to drive and will probably rise in value but I don't think there are any £10k Porsches that will probably rise in value in any reasonable amount of time. I would look at desireable versions of 80's everyday cars and buy an absolute minter. e30 325i (esp convertible), Golf GTi and other hot hatches. Cars that are in excellent condition will possibly show a gain. In five years, people might be willing to pay a lot for one of the few 205 GTis that hasn't been crashed, modded or gone rusty and has only 50k miles. They don't cost a lot to service (compared to a semi worn out 911) and their rawness and bouncyness makes them fun for the odd blast.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
SimC said:
...leaning towards a 964 targa. Slightly more modern/usable and quite a few around at a decent price. As far as the investment potential I know they are not going to grow much if at all but at least It will be fun. The search is on!
That should be one of the best value cars you can buy (but do so with due diligence) so should be possible for your budget. Enjoyable to use too.

boxsey

3,579 posts

241 months

Saturday 20th August 2011
quotequote all
964 coupes have steadily risen in value over the last few years but that has a lot do with owners pumping a lot of money into them; engine rebuilds, suspension, bodywork renovation, etc. Those that have had that sort of work done tend to come on the market at about £20K and sell quite quickly.

However there are still some untouched/original cars that come up for sale for around your ideal budget of £12K. Particularly targas. While you're unlikely to lose any money on one over a few years, it will only go up in value if you put money into it. But be aware that you won't get back all of that money. I regard my own 964 as one of those cars that would sell for £20K if it went on the market now but I've put 50% more than that in to it to get it to the point where it is now. I don't begrudge it though because it's paid me back in smiles. smile