Should i swap a TVR for a Porsche 996 Targa?
Should i swap a TVR for a Porsche 996 Targa?
Author
Discussion

weasley

Original Poster:

13 posts

249 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
Sould i swap a TVR CHIMAERA for a Porsche 996 Targa?

Looking for a daily ride instead of having a smart car for getting to and from work and a tvr CHIMAERA for the weekends and summer days. budget would be 21k , I drive to work where i pick up a company car.My car can stay up to 3 weeks in Birmingham, without getting used so petrol and milage dont really matter as i only do 2-3k annual millage in my own car. thought about the Targa as i like the idea of topless driving without being a convertable{might get stolen in brum}

looking for 996 which is within my budget and would like to know are they any good and classed as a proper 911.should i look out for a certain age or are the 996 the same?.

Many thanks for you time

regards

Tim.

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Sunday 21st August 2011
quotequote all
wouldn't be a fair swap now would it? wink

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
Targas are less popular than either coupes or cabriolets, which is a good thing if you are buying, not so good when re-selling. But if the price is right and it's a Targa you really want then go for it. Should be a lot more practical than your TVR for daily use but will be less involving to drive too i.e. far more refined and user friendly

blueg33

47,025 posts

255 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
996 is not without its engine issues, so make sure it is warranted properly by an OPC.

Personally I think the 996 Targa is one of the nicest of the 996 range, but as others have said any 911 targa seems to have a lower value than its comparable coupe or convertible.

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
Targa only if you like the roof, car was based on cab so is heavier than regular coupe.

It was one of the least produced 996's though this is not reflected in used prices.

dibblecorse

7,668 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
996 is not without its engine issues, so make sure it is warranted properly by an OPC.

.
Honestly ? Really ? Does every 'what 911' thread require the scare mongering, I suspect there are now a greater number of 911's expecially 996 and earlier that are not on OPC warranty than are .....

yes its a risk, but not as huge a risk as everyone makes out from my research .....


blueg33

47,025 posts

255 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
dibblecorse said:
Honestly ? Really ? Does every 'what 911' thread require the scare mongering, I suspect there are now a greater number of 911's expecially 996 and earlier that are not on OPC warranty than are .....

yes its a risk, but not as huge a risk as everyone makes out from my research .....
I think people generally reckon a later Porsche like a 996/7 to be very reliable. Engine issues are however well documented, so why not get the car checked out? You would feel like a bit of a twit is you pay £20k for a car and find it needs £8k of engine work.

Of course its not all cars that are affected but its known risk that people may not have considered, so its reasonable to flag it

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
dibblecorse said:
blueg33 said:
996 is not without its engine issues, so make sure it is warranted properly by an OPC.

.
Honestly ? Really ? Does every 'what 911' thread require the scare mongering, I suspect there are now a greater number of 911's expecially 996 and earlier that are not on OPC warranty than are .....

yes its a risk, but not as huge a risk as everyone makes out from my research .....
I dont think he suggested that its a 'huge risk'. Surely we are right to at least warn people of the potential engine issues? He suggested a warranty and that is sensible and would certainly be my advice (OPC or Hartech plan etc).

For what its worth, my view is that the risks are significant to be termed 'medium' at least.

MTR

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
Callughan said:
Targa only if you like the roof, car was based on cab so is heavier than regular coupe.
Uglier too, to my eye.
It's got the fat 'cab' rear end (as in tall, not wide).

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Monday 22nd August 2011
quotequote all
monthefish said:
Callughan said:
Targa only if you like the roof, car was based on cab so is heavier than regular coupe.
Uglier too, to my eye.
It's got the fat 'cab' rear end (as in tall, not wide).
The 997 version looks better imo

tgr

1,256 posts

202 months

Saturday 27th August 2011
quotequote all
The 996 targa was not based on the convertible unlike 993, it was based on the coupe so structurally far stronger

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
tgr said:
The 996 targa was not based on the convertible unlike 993, it was based on the coupe so structurally far stronger
That's right it would be structurally stronger from my understanding coupe shell strengthened as per cab however this adds 70kg.

Magic919

14,595 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
Callughan said:
tgr said:
The 996 targa was not based on the convertible unlike 993, it was based on the coupe so structurally far stronger
That's right it would be structurally stronger from my understanding coupe shell strengthened as per cab however this adds 70kg.
So what's the difference between a cabriolet shell and a coupe shell that has been strengthened like a cabrio?

A11UUH

249 posts

266 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
Hi, I has a TVR Griffith 500 for about 3 years and absolutely loved it, like you it was a weekend/ sunny day car, I couldn't have used it as a daily driver as it would have driven me nuts.

The Porsche is a completely different animal, again it's my weekend/ sunny day car but I find myself using it alot more in the week, just purely because driving it 'normally' if feels like a normal/ daily car, when you boot it it comes alive.

In some ways I miss the theatre that you get every time you jump into a TVR but I love the Porsche preciseness.

With regards to the engine issues, I see it like peoples 'TVR reliability' views, my view is like most things, buy wisely keep on top of the servicing and enjoy, I never had any issues with the TVR and I don't concern myself about Porsche issues, if something happens then that's life.

So in answer to your question, if you don't mind losing some of the theatre you get from a TVR and your prepared to spend more in fuel (because you can, you will use it more) then just go for it, they are amazing cars.

As for the Targa, I've heard they can squeak but you've owned a TVR so that wouldn't bother you and as it's already been said, a lot of people don't like them (I do) but I just see that as you will get more for your £'s.

Happy hunting, and prepare yourself for the Porsche shuffle, we all do that! D:


Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
Magic919 said:
Callughan said:
tgr said:
The 996 targa was not based on the convertible unlike 993, it was based on the coupe so structurally far stronger
That's right it would be structurally stronger from my understanding coupe shell strengthened as per cab however this adds 70kg.
So what's the difference between a cabriolet shell and a coupe shell that has been strengthened like a cabrio?
The roof;) The lack of causes rigidity problems regardless of how much the structure reinforced and strengthening adds weight. I think this is why when designing the 997 shell they started with the 997 Cab in mind.

Magic919

14,595 posts

232 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
Callughan said:
Magic919 said:
Callughan said:
tgr said:
The 996 targa was not based on the convertible unlike 993, it was based on the coupe so structurally far stronger
That's right it would be structurally stronger from my understanding coupe shell strengthened as per cab however this adds 70kg.
So what's the difference between a cabriolet shell and a coupe shell that has been strengthened like a cabrio?
The roof;) The lack of causes rigidity problems regardless of how much the structure reinforced and strengthening adds weight. I think this is why when designing the 997 shell they started with the 997 Cab in mind.
I do understand the lack of roof bit. However, It's hard to see what point you and TGR are actually making.

Callughan

6,313 posts

223 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
Magic919 said:
Callughan said:
Magic919 said:
Callughan said:
tgr said:
The 996 targa was not based on the convertible unlike 993, it was based on the coupe so structurally far stronger
That's right it would be structurally stronger from my understanding coupe shell strengthened as per cab however this adds 70kg.
So what's the difference between a cabriolet shell and a coupe shell that has been strengthened like a cabrio?
The roof;) The lack of causes rigidity problems regardless of how much the structure reinforced and strengthening adds weight. I think this is why when designing the 997 shell they started with the 997 Cab in mind.
I do understand the lack of roof bit. However, It's hard to see what point you and TGR are actually making.
No point just mentioning extra weight and rigidity. All depends on what OP is looking for in his P

Nano2nd

3,426 posts

287 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
A11UUH said:
Hi, I has a TVR Griffith 500 for about 3 years and absolutely loved it, like you it was a weekend/ sunny day car, I couldn't have used it as a daily driver as it would have driven me nuts.

The Porsche is a completely different animal, again it's my weekend/ sunny day car but I find myself using it alot more in the week, just purely because driving it 'normally' if feels like a normal/ daily car, when you boot it it comes alive.

In some ways I miss the theatre that you get every time you jump into a TVR but I love the Porsche preciseness.

With regards to the engine issues, I see it like peoples 'TVR reliability' views, my view is like most things, buy wisely keep on top of the servicing and enjoy, I never had any issues with the TVR and I don't concern myself about Porsche issues, if something happens then that's life.

So in answer to your question, if you don't mind losing some of the theatre you get from a TVR and your prepared to spend more in fuel (because you can, you will use it more) then just go for it, they are amazing cars.

As for the Targa, I've heard they can squeak but you've owned a TVR so that wouldn't bother you and as it's already been said, a lot of people don't like them (I do) but I just see that as you will get more for your £'s.

Happy hunting, and prepare yourself for the Porsche shuffle, we all do that! D:
pretty much spot on, i had Chimaera 450 for 4 years- great car, but the 911 is better in many respects - performance and handling but certainly not noise and err... economy! strangely enough confused

mjwscorpio

260 posts

240 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
I have owned a Chimaera and now own a Targa. Just been to the Nurburg ring in it and it is such a great car and so different to the TVR. Yes you will have people tell you about engine problems and the roof, but if you like them as I do just go and get one and yes it is a 911. The family fit in which is a big bonus and they all love it.