Need wheel advice!
Discussion
OK, lets have some facts;
18" Turbo Solids are 25.6kg front and 31kg back = 113kg total
18" Turbo hollows are 20kg front and 23.4kg back = 86.8kg total
Net effect is a saving of 26.2kg BUT beacuse this is unsprung weight, its worth 78.6kg in performance terms.
Thats pretty significant.
http://members.rennlist.com/911pcars/WheelWts.html
MTR
18" Turbo Solids are 25.6kg front and 31kg back = 113kg total
18" Turbo hollows are 20kg front and 23.4kg back = 86.8kg total
Net effect is a saving of 26.2kg BUT beacuse this is unsprung weight, its worth 78.6kg in performance terms.
Thats pretty significant.
http://members.rennlist.com/911pcars/WheelWts.html
MTR
MTR, those quoted weights are in lbs and not kgs unless I'm mistaken! 
The lower weight of the hollow spokes is still useful though but worth remembering that any given set of tyres will weigh the same, the total weight saving from the hollwo spoked wheels as a percentage of the combined weight of wheels and tyres will be proportionally less.
You also then have to think about the brake disks, wheel carriers/stub axles and a percentage of the suspension components themselves as it's not just the weight of the wheel that is 'unsprung' which is more or less everything that would be left resting on the ground if you were to 'disconnect' the suspension and raise the monococque up in the air if you follow?

The lower weight of the hollow spokes is still useful though but worth remembering that any given set of tyres will weigh the same, the total weight saving from the hollwo spoked wheels as a percentage of the combined weight of wheels and tyres will be proportionally less.
You also then have to think about the brake disks, wheel carriers/stub axles and a percentage of the suspension components themselves as it's not just the weight of the wheel that is 'unsprung' which is more or less everything that would be left resting on the ground if you were to 'disconnect' the suspension and raise the monococque up in the air if you follow?
Edited by MogulBoy on Friday 26th August 14:04
MogulBoy said:
MTR, those quoted weights are in lbs and not kgs unless I'm mistaken! 
The lower weight of the hollow spokes is still useful though but worth remembering that any given set of tyres will weigh the same, the total weight saving from the hollwo spoked wheels as a percentage of the combined weight of wheels and tyres will be proportionally less.
You also then have to think about the brake disks, wheel carriers/stub axles and a percentage of the suspension components themselves as it's not just the weight of the wheel that is 'unsprung' which is more or less everything that would be left resting on the ground if you were to 'disconnect' the suspension and raise the monococque up in the air if you follow?
Yes, my mistake its Ibs. So the saving is about 12kg. I know little or nothing about unsprung weight except the simple principal. I understand your point about it only being part of the whole but does the 'X3' effect mean that the equivalent body saving is 36kg?
The lower weight of the hollow spokes is still useful though but worth remembering that any given set of tyres will weigh the same, the total weight saving from the hollwo spoked wheels as a percentage of the combined weight of wheels and tyres will be proportionally less.
You also then have to think about the brake disks, wheel carriers/stub axles and a percentage of the suspension components themselves as it's not just the weight of the wheel that is 'unsprung' which is more or less everything that would be left resting on the ground if you were to 'disconnect' the suspension and raise the monococque up in the air if you follow?
Edited by MogulBoy on Friday 26th August 14:04
MTR
Not an expert myself but I am persuaded by the x3 'rule of thumb'.
It's all to easy though to be seduced by the benefits of certain performance enhancements and for me unsprung weight is one of them. It just sounds so believable that the lightest possible wheels must be good (and would present a noticeable improvement). However, it would not surprise me if the total weight of a typical set of contemporary 911 wheels complete with tyres mounted on a set of steel-braked hubs, with calipers full of fluid and all the other unsprung bits would add up to more than 100kgs (circa 4 full holiday suitcases). Therefore, a 10kg saving all round, while worthwhile, may not be noticeable by 'an average driver' in anything but extreme circumstances. e.g. I doubt that many of us could tell much difference if 30kg of weight was taken out of the body for example (i.e. half a tank of fuel??).
Saying that, I once spun my old Impreza on a wet Snetterton with a passenger on board after having done a number of laps one up with no such drama. Hardly scientific but it didn't stop me blaming the 75kgs sitting next to me!
Just to add.. given that dealing with unspung weight is such an important role of the suspension, I would be interested to know if Porsche tune the suspension of PCCB cars differently to their steel braked equivalents as you would have thougth that it would be necessary to optimise the dampers to match..
It's all to easy though to be seduced by the benefits of certain performance enhancements and for me unsprung weight is one of them. It just sounds so believable that the lightest possible wheels must be good (and would present a noticeable improvement). However, it would not surprise me if the total weight of a typical set of contemporary 911 wheels complete with tyres mounted on a set of steel-braked hubs, with calipers full of fluid and all the other unsprung bits would add up to more than 100kgs (circa 4 full holiday suitcases). Therefore, a 10kg saving all round, while worthwhile, may not be noticeable by 'an average driver' in anything but extreme circumstances. e.g. I doubt that many of us could tell much difference if 30kg of weight was taken out of the body for example (i.e. half a tank of fuel??).
Saying that, I once spun my old Impreza on a wet Snetterton with a passenger on board after having done a number of laps one up with no such drama. Hardly scientific but it didn't stop me blaming the 75kgs sitting next to me!

Just to add.. given that dealing with unspung weight is such an important role of the suspension, I would be interested to know if Porsche tune the suspension of PCCB cars differently to their steel braked equivalents as you would have thougth that it would be necessary to optimise the dampers to match..
Edited by MogulBoy on Friday 26th August 15:06
MogulBoy said:
Just to add.. given that dealing with unspung weight is such an important role of the suspension, I would be interested to know if Porsche tune the suspension of PCCB cars differently to their steel braked equivalents as you would have thougth that it would be necessary to optimise the dampers to match..
Good point. Ideally I guess they should, but like most things, there is probably a compromise 'middleground' in the set up to allow for both?Edited by MogulBoy on Friday 26th August 15:06
MTR
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



k of a lot - go for the hollow spokes now