Discussion
Hoping for some advice - fear I'm being stitched up..
My 911 got a puncture on the left-rear. Annoying, but called Porsche Assist and they recovered to my local OPC... so far so good.
Now the issue arises that I have N1-spec tyres all round currently, but they are no longer available. OPC can source N2-spec tyres, but is unwilling to leave N1s on the front and have N2s one the rear, saying it will invalidate the warranty. Other OPCs I've spoke to seem to disagree and would have been happy with the latter approach.
Has anyone encountered anything similar or received the same advice?
Thanks in advance
Ipso
My 911 got a puncture on the left-rear. Annoying, but called Porsche Assist and they recovered to my local OPC... so far so good.
Now the issue arises that I have N1-spec tyres all round currently, but they are no longer available. OPC can source N2-spec tyres, but is unwilling to leave N1s on the front and have N2s one the rear, saying it will invalidate the warranty. Other OPCs I've spoke to seem to disagree and would have been happy with the latter approach.
Has anyone encountered anything similar or received the same advice?
Thanks in advance
Ipso
I can "almost" see the argument about having the same N number across an axle, but all 4 wheels, what utter BS!
Bear in mind that at some time, not so very long ago, your N1's were considered perfectly acceptable footwear for your car - provided they are legal, meet the size and load ratings specified, I cannot see the issue?
Not normally a Porsche/OPC basher, but sometimes they take the biscuit - I mean, they even insist on 3mm, when 1.6mm is the legal limit - WTF has that got to do with anything warranty related?
I have N2's on mine and know that the rears will have to come off in 3k miles, but I'll be damned if I am swapping all 4 out!
Oh and go to another OPC.
Bear in mind that at some time, not so very long ago, your N1's were considered perfectly acceptable footwear for your car - provided they are legal, meet the size and load ratings specified, I cannot see the issue?
Not normally a Porsche/OPC basher, but sometimes they take the biscuit - I mean, they even insist on 3mm, when 1.6mm is the legal limit - WTF has that got to do with anything warranty related?

I have N2's on mine and know that the rears will have to come off in 3k miles, but I'll be damned if I am swapping all 4 out!
Oh and go to another OPC.
I had exactly the same issue recently with a rear puncture.
Swindon OPC said they would have to advise me to replace all four, but they also stated that they have many customers driving around with mixed N numbers and it shouldn't be a problem.
I compared the N1 and N2 PS2s when they were being changed and the tread pattern is identical. I guess the compound could be different but who knows.
Knowing my luck when the fronts wear out Michelin will be on N3 so I still won't get a matching set!
Swindon OPC said they would have to advise me to replace all four, but they also stated that they have many customers driving around with mixed N numbers and it shouldn't be a problem.
I compared the N1 and N2 PS2s when they were being changed and the tread pattern is identical. I guess the compound could be different but who knows.
Knowing my luck when the fronts wear out Michelin will be on N3 so I still won't get a matching set!
I too have N1s front, N2s rear. recently been in for warranty work with no questions asked.
+1 on the "try another OPC". Or arrange your own tyre fitting.
Ask yourself whether it is any different to have part worns on one axle and new on the other of the same N rating or new tyres all round with different N ratings front and rear. My view is absolutely not so happy with my choices.
+1 on the "try another OPC". Or arrange your own tyre fitting.
Ask yourself whether it is any different to have part worns on one axle and new on the other of the same N rating or new tyres all round with different N ratings front and rear. My view is absolutely not so happy with my choices.
Trev450 said:
The op's main issue is in mixing N ratings his OPC won't renew the warranty.
Callughan said:
However when it comes time to renew they must all be the same.
Again, I think latitude between OPC's here - not my personal experience. However, clearly a risk given others' experience.I got all concerned about this a while back and after much research I took came to the same conclusion as others. If you have money to burn, keep all 4 tyres the same N rating.
If you prefer to be cost concious, then mix the N rating front to back and not side to side. I have 10x PS2`s on the go at the moment (6x N2, 2x N3 and 2x N4) and I will rotate them in pairs quite happily.
In closing, you have to ask yourself this question. If you were a target driven sales person working for an OPC what answer would you give the customer? They would tell you that factory would fit 4 tyres with the same N rating.
HTH
If you prefer to be cost concious, then mix the N rating front to back and not side to side. I have 10x PS2`s on the go at the moment (6x N2, 2x N3 and 2x N4) and I will rotate them in pairs quite happily.
In closing, you have to ask yourself this question. If you were a target driven sales person working for an OPC what answer would you give the customer? They would tell you that factory would fit 4 tyres with the same N rating.
HTH
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



te in my time but that takes the digestive

