968 to Boxster?
Author
Discussion

plenty

Original Poster:

5,036 posts

217 months

Sunday 28th August 2011
quotequote all
I may have the opportunity to swap my 968 Sport (KW V3, M030 brakes and arbs) for a pre-facelift Boxster 3.2S.

I've had my 968 for almost three years and 20k miles. I absolutely adore it, but am getting the itch to change.

TBH a Boxster isn't my first choice (would really like an Elise), but 968s aren't selling in today's market, and a bird in the hand and all that.

I took a short test drive in a Boxster S a few days ago and wasn't bowled over on first impression - controls seemed rather over-damped compared with the directness of my 968, and it was almost too civilised (sports cars shouldn't have electric seats IMO). I'm generally not a fan of "modern" cars in general and prefer the involvement that older designs tend to offer.

On the other hand, the engine sounded rather nice (if only they made a 944/968 with a six or V8) and I'm keen to experience the famed mid-engined dynamics.

A couple of squirts up and down a dual-carriageway isn't going to give me much of an impression, so can anyone who's driven both cars hard offer a comparison of their responses? I love the 968's steering, chunky mechanical gearchange and pedals, its balance, stability, and confidence-inspiring predictability. With my suspension mods it absolutely annihilates the B-roads that I spend most of my time on (this is not a daily driver, just a weekend fun car).

Would I enjoy a Boxster's handling following a KW and M030 -equipped 968?

Edited by plenty on Sunday 28th August 13:09

plenty

Original Poster:

5,036 posts

217 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Weekday bump - any insight, folks?

nickfrog

25,478 posts

248 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Never driven a 968 so difficult to compare. My first Boxster was a 2.5 on 17' and M030. Steering was nothing short of telepathic, incredibly involving. Turn in was razor sharp, traction immense, grip insane (particularly at the front), which with the small engine resulted in a car that was so stable that you had to use very high cornering speed to affect stability, which some might call boring, not me though.

My current 987 2.7 on soft suspension is pretty similar but not quite as sharp but sharper than any other sports car of similar price or weight.

2 things : - mid-engine takes a little time to get to use to the handling. The front end in particular feels a little light which may hamper confidence to start with but the level of grip is much higher than one may imagine to start with and enjoyment only really start when you lean on that front grip
- geometry needs to be spot on but I don't think many owners bother.

HTH !

davek_964

11,382 posts

206 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Also not owned a 968 - but I'm in the minority of people who don't see why people rave about the Boxsters so much.

I had a 2008 Boxster S for a long weekend while my 964 was having a much overdue safety recall. While I'm sure it's very different from the 968, the 964 was a similar kind of era - and had very involving steering / handling.

To me, the Boxster didn't have that at all. It may be very capable - but at the time, I owned a 996 turbo and a 964 and the Boxster seemed to combine the worst of both. It had the fairly remote feeling of handling that the 996 turbo has, and yet wasn't much quicker than the 964.

I should point out that I've never been a fan of convertibles so wasn't a big fan of the Boxster to start with - but considering the positive views many people share I expected the car to impress me, even though I don't feel the need to put the roof down. But it really didn't and the whole experience was lost on me.

You might find you enjoy it as you get to know the car. I do enjoy my 996 turbo handling more now, although it's still nothing like an early 90s Porsche. I did do a good few miles in the Boxster though (around 700 I think) so it had a good chance to impress me.

I'm not saying Boxsters are bad, so would prefer to avoid loads of angry posts from Boxster owners. It just didn't do it for me at all, and I think if the OP is comparing it to a 968 it's possible he will find it doesn't do it for him either - and first impressions seem to suggest that.

plenty

Original Poster:

5,036 posts

217 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Thanks both.

I'm no driving god, but after 20k miles I feel I've pretty got the measure of the 968 and the prospect of learning how to punt along with a different weight distribution is rather appealing; nickfrog's description is already giving me attractive mental images of braking deep into corners, leaning on the front end.

Although Davek - you pretty much nailed my concern. The 968 is such an organic package - with a clarity and innate "rightness" which in general I tend to find more of in older cars compared to newer ones. I'm wondering if the Boxster will feel watered-down in comparison, even given the benefits of a flat-six versus a four.

Edited by plenty on Tuesday 30th August 13:13

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
These cars are so different that there is little comparison and it is very subjective in terms of your own needs.

Reading your comments on your 968S set up (Sounds great!) and Boxster experience, it seems to me that you will be utlimately disappointed with the Box (Great car that it is) but maybe its an itch you need to scratch?

I think you either need an extended test drive or a trip in a friends car?

MTR

Wozy68

5,436 posts

201 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Reading between the lines Plenty, I'm of the opinion that you will miss that 968 the second it is sold.

Keep it/sell it? I know how you feel. I've been talked out of selling mine twice now, once by a guy who wanted a track day setup 968, but had a look at mine just in case he wanted a more road going version, and once by my best mate when he took it into Wales for a day whilst his 996 was in for a service just before I was about to sell it and told me I was a fool if I did.

I have met a few people who have owned 986s in the past, and not one of them still doesn't miss theirs.

And I know exactly what you mean by that itch for a change, however I think reading your post your clutching at straws with this boxster. Not knocking them, but a 968 just gets under the skin, and more so because it is IMHO better than the aircooled versions of the same era, who to the general masses do not class it as a 'real' Porsche.


plenty

Original Poster:

5,036 posts

217 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
Wozy, thank you - you are like my stern, sensible mate who I can rely on to give me a strong talking-to when I get out of line.

I cannot dispute that the 968 has well and truly got under my skin, but I'm generally pretty unsentimental and like to look forwards, not backwards. The other consideration is that my car is coming up to 158k miles which would make it the highest-mileage car in the classifieds and therefore not an easy selling proposition despite its good condition. Hence a swap is looking appealing even though a Box wouldn't be my "ideal" in some ways.

softinthehead

1,550 posts

270 months

Tuesday 30th August 2011
quotequote all
A contrarian view, but I can only give my honest opinion. I have had a 968 cab for 7 years and a 944 before that. I went to test drive a 997 recently and stepped out of the car unconvinced and not quite sure. I think it was the sheer size and weight of the beast. No one can doubt oits performance credentials but it didn't feel light and nimble to me, Ok it was a short test drive in an unfamiliar car. I then went for a spin in a newish Boxster S just for curiosity, and felt instantly at home. Yes the handling was different. BUT coming from the 968 I felt totally at ease in the Boxster S, and I had an absolute hoot in it. Much as I love the 968, I wouldn't have had any problems moving to the Boxster and enjoying it thoroughly. However I didn't want another soft top so Ive just bought a Cayman S













winshent

1,174 posts

226 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Are you not tempted to give Noble ownership a second chance ?

Edited by winshent on Saturday 17th September 18:15

ditchvisitor

1,238 posts

252 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
My honest opinion, don't do it. I've just gone from a Boxster S to an 87 3.2 and I much prefer the 911. Your 968 sounds like it's nicely sorted and will probably appreciate were as the Boxster is only heading one way!

ditchvisitor

1,238 posts

252 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
Forgot to add, maybe spend some money on the 968, new Polybushes etc maybe a sports exhaust, try and rejuvenate your love for it, if, like you said it's done high miles maybe a top end rebuild? Im sure if you sold it you would massively regret it.

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
I've got both a Boxster S and a 968CS and I don't think of them as slightly similar cars. The 968 is so raw and every time I drive it is an occasion.
The Boxster is so much more refined and much more of an everyday car yet can be a very quick sportscar.
Going frpm the 968 to a Boxster would be easier than going the other way apart from the sense of boredom if you expect it like you would in the 968.
In my opinion the Boxster has a better tone but 968 has a better drive full stop. It feels like it makes progress quicker, has more torque and you can stick it in 6th at 20mph in town!!

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
So that's a positive then?

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
The OP is asking what it's like going from a 968 to a Boxster S - unless he changed it to 'what don't you like about the 968'.

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Nice!

I'm not with you though. Don't you think the Boxster has a two stage engine note? Sounds boring at low revs but at top revs between 4-5 & 5-6.

plenty

Original Poster:

5,036 posts

217 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
winshent said:
Are you not tempted to give Noble ownership a second chance?
Not ruling anything out, and it will be a very nice car when sorted, but I have someone interested in buying and if we can do an acceptable deal then I will.

Back to topic: the Boxster owner sold his car, so I'm no longer looking in that direction. It was only ever going to be a part-ex deal, and if buying cash it wouldn't be my first choice.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 17th September 2011
quotequote all
are you still thinking of selling it and if so what are the onward purchase options?