Purchase from OPC or Indy Specialist?
Discussion
Look at both and weigh up the individual merits on a case by case basis.
Re: the sub 10,000 miles I would suggest you relax that a bit to bring more cars into scope and make sure you aren't paying several thousand pounds extra for a relatively few extra miles. I'm not sure for instance there is necessarily any material differences between 9k miles and say 14k miles. As with the dealers judge each individual car on it's own merit taking into account all aspects including price.
Good luck on your search.
Henry
Re: the sub 10,000 miles I would suggest you relax that a bit to bring more cars into scope and make sure you aren't paying several thousand pounds extra for a relatively few extra miles. I'm not sure for instance there is necessarily any material differences between 9k miles and say 14k miles. As with the dealers judge each individual car on it's own merit taking into account all aspects including price.
Good luck on your search.
Henry

If you're looking at cars that young then it matters a lot less where you buy from as all cars will still be under the manufacturer's warranty (which can be extended if you wish).
Private sales are worth looking at too, although if you don't know much about the cars then a PPI is a good idea (same goes if buying from a non-specialist dealer) but this isn't a big cost on the scale of things. The broader you go of where you'll buy from the greater choice you'll have and (fairly obviously) the younger cars are the smaller the variance in condition.
Private sales are worth looking at too, although if you don't know much about the cars then a PPI is a good idea (same goes if buying from a non-specialist dealer) but this isn't a big cost on the scale of things. The broader you go of where you'll buy from the greater choice you'll have and (fairly obviously) the younger cars are the smaller the variance in condition.
NoopyS said:
Looking to buy a used Cayman - up to 2 years old with a max of 10k mileage.
Do you prefer to buy from an OPC or from an Indy specialist?
Not sure how much sense the low mileage argument makes. If you are talking about a sub-5k miles/year car a year you may well be looking at a car that has done lots of short journeys - and if you read the horror story threads on here you will see a building consensus (mainly in 997 I admit but with a few caymans thrown in) for cylinder liner scoring possibly as a result of hooning a car from cold on short journeys. Ok it may be just idle forum banter but the point is that for every one person arguing low-miles-is-better there will be another arguing you are better off getting one thats done 20k worth of motorway milesDo you prefer to buy from an OPC or from an Indy specialist?
since your car will almost by definition have the balance of OPC warranty why are you concerned re mileage?
Magic919 said:
Predictable response from the dealers.
Rather harsh I think.I hope Marcus and I gave quite balanced responses as opposed to simply saying buy OPC because you get a better warranty. Any balance of the manufacturer's warranty will be in force regardless of who you buy the car from. OPC warranties can be obtained for cars not purchased through the Main dealer network and there are instances where aftermarket warranties transfer.
So as originally stated take each on their merits including the all important bit - price !
Henry

Buy with the options you're looking for.
Buying from OPC you get the 111-point check and 2 year warranty thrown in which is ~£1800 to apply to a non-OPC car, so factor that in if you intend to put a warranty on it further down the line (the regular indy warranties aren't worth the paper they're printed on imo - Porsche specialist indys notwithstanding)
Buying from OPC you get the 111-point check and 2 year warranty thrown in which is ~£1800 to apply to a non-OPC car, so factor that in if you intend to put a warranty on it further down the line (the regular indy warranties aren't worth the paper they're printed on imo - Porsche specialist indys notwithstanding)
We were originally looking for a low mileage 2010 Boxster S and looked at a number of examples sourced at independents and OPC's most of them were very similar condition and price differential wasn't that great IMO. Having spoken to a number of people whom have purchased from OPC's I can see completely why people recommend independents because I guess when it's somebodies own business its massively in their interests to give good service, also I would assume these people have massive knowledge of the cars they are buying to sell on hence you are benefiting from their knowledge however with a newish car I would guess this is less of a concern.
For us personally we dealt with Tom at Leicester OPC and this OPC seem to be on their game, very professional, very friendly and great coffee LOL! This dealership is the best I have EVER dealt with not just Porsche and I was genuinely quite taken aback with their efforts. We were originally looking at a 5000 mile Boxster S but ended up going on holiday for two weeks upon our return the car had been sold, Tom contacted us and said he had a 2nd hand car of similar specification and price at another dealership but also had some brand new cars just in one of which we might be interested in, we were prepared to compromise on spec. namely not having BOSE and the leather dash and the deal was so good we bought new!
We also felt that having seen the dealership and spoken with the staff including the service people and tasted the coffee we felt more comfortable going via OPC and I guess that's the key going to see some of these dealers both independent and OPC and see whom you feel comfortable doing business with.
Tom has also said he'll organise a drive in a GT3 at Silverstone for me in an attempt to get me out of my Nissan GTR and into a Porsche and after driving the wife's Boxster I can only say I'm a step nearer that as its a cracking car!
Good luck in your search, it's half the fun!
For us personally we dealt with Tom at Leicester OPC and this OPC seem to be on their game, very professional, very friendly and great coffee LOL! This dealership is the best I have EVER dealt with not just Porsche and I was genuinely quite taken aback with their efforts. We were originally looking at a 5000 mile Boxster S but ended up going on holiday for two weeks upon our return the car had been sold, Tom contacted us and said he had a 2nd hand car of similar specification and price at another dealership but also had some brand new cars just in one of which we might be interested in, we were prepared to compromise on spec. namely not having BOSE and the leather dash and the deal was so good we bought new!
We also felt that having seen the dealership and spoken with the staff including the service people and tasted the coffee we felt more comfortable going via OPC and I guess that's the key going to see some of these dealers both independent and OPC and see whom you feel comfortable doing business with.
Tom has also said he'll organise a drive in a GT3 at Silverstone for me in an attempt to get me out of my Nissan GTR and into a Porsche and after driving the wife's Boxster I can only say I'm a step nearer that as its a cracking car!
Good luck in your search, it's half the fun!
Magic919 said:
Predictable response from the dealers.
Giving you the benefit of the doubt I'd assume you mean we gave good advice (such as others later said). 
Magic919 said:
I'd go OPC on this one. Balance of warranty plus two years as an approved car. Nice coffee too.
Do bear in mind that the OPC's have to get their cars from somewhere and so do specialists - these sources of supply are often the same (private owners, part exchanges at non-Porsche dealers etc).So it stands to reason that if you're buying a vehicle in a fancy showroom (drinking their coffee..) you will be paying more for it (£10 million showrooms don't just appear out of nowhere) than from somewhere with smaller overheads. You will get more warranty included in the higher price (as you say), but this takes the choice away from you as to whether you want to pay for that cover or not.
As a policy, we don't usually sell (any brand of) cars that compete with the main dealers, so I have nothing to gain from the advice I gave. I did however get a call recently on our 2006 Cayman S from an OPC looking to buy it from us and sell it at £4k more (than our retail price) to a customer they had wanting one. For that premium they would have got the OPC warranty and the front end painted (it's not bad at all for a 39,000 mile car, hence we haven't done it, but the OPC would as they expect to with virtually every car they buy).....and some OPC coffee, which in my experience is not a patch on our Nespresso
Anyway, the car's really nice and if anything we're short of stock so I declined their offer.I suppose some people will prefer to buy from an OPC, some won't, hence we all manage to stay in business
The point of this thread is for the OP to look at the different merit of the various options (hence I suggested looking at private sales too). thegoose said:
I suppose some people will prefer to buy from an OPC, some won't, hence we all manage to stay in business
The point of this thread is for the OP to look at the different merit of the various options (hence I suggested looking at private sales too). With regards to the mileage, I am flexible depending on the spec, price, etc.
NoopyS said:
Great advice so far guys. I am a complete noob at this, so all your responses have been really helpful so far. I wasn't aware that an OPC warranty can be obtained for a car purchased from an indy specialist, so I will definitely have a look at the specialists too.
With regards to the mileage, I am flexible depending on the spec, price, etc.
The car has to meet certain rules, less then 9yrs or 11yrs, less then 125k miles. Do not quote me on the 9 or 11yrs. It's one or the other.With regards to the mileage, I am flexible depending on the spec, price, etc.
You have to have owned the car for
90 days
pay a few hundred for the Porsche 111 point check, have whatever it needs done to it done
about £1.1 or £1.2k for one year
£2.4k for 2yrs or so.
Koing
Koing said:
The car has to meet certain rules, less then 9yrs or 11yrs, less then 125k miles. Do not quote me on the 9 or 11yrs. It's one or the other.
You have to have owned the car for
90 days
pay a few hundred for the Porsche 111 point check, have whatever it needs done to it done
about £1.1 or £1.2k for one year
£2.4k for 2yrs or so.
Koing
That applies for cars having no Porsche warranty on them (under 9 years old at inception/renewal) and prices are a bit lower too (you've mentioned inspection fee, typically £200, then included it in the warranty prices as well!) and can be reduced further if you opt out of the breakdown cover (£180-ish?).You have to have owned the car for
90 days
pay a few hundred for the Porsche 111 point check, have whatever it needs done to it done
about £1.1 or £1.2k for one year
£2.4k for 2yrs or so.
Koing
For cars under 2 years old, the manufacturer's warranty still applies and hence can be extended when it reaches 2 years old (no minimum ownership period in that case as far as I'm aware).
softinthehead said:
Not sure how much sense the low mileage argument makes. If you are talking about a sub-5k miles/year car a year you may well be looking at a car that has done lots of short journeys - and if you read the horror story threads on here you will see a building consensus (mainly in 997 I admit but with a few caymans thrown in) for cylinder liner scoring possibly as a result of hooning a car from cold on short journeys. Ok it may be just idle forum banter but the point is that for every one person arguing low-miles-is-better there will be another arguing you are better off getting one thats done 20k worth of motorway miles
since your car will almost by definition have the balance of OPC warranty why are you concerned re mileage?
Couldn't agree. Lots of short journeys may be the case but more likely to be a car used in fine weather / weekends only. On average, low mileage is a better bet.since your car will almost by definition have the balance of OPC warranty why are you concerned re mileage?
Up to 2 years old - i would buy from an OPC personally.
Why?
1/ There are some good indies (you need to do your research), but imho the prices of their new-ish stock are not much cheaper (if any) than OPC's. On older stock - i would then seriously consider buying from one of the recommended indies.
2/ Warranty. On a 'up to 2' year old car, you will get the remainder of the *original* 2 year warranty, PLUS an *additional* 2 year Porsche warranty. For example, i have just bought a March 2010 car. My warranty runs until March 2014. So, i have 2.5 years PORSCHE warranty on my used car.
I also echo AndyBrew's comments re Leicester OPC. It's also worth noting Leicester are in group of 6 OPC's, so i'd be very surprised if they do not have a car you like.
Why?
1/ There are some good indies (you need to do your research), but imho the prices of their new-ish stock are not much cheaper (if any) than OPC's. On older stock - i would then seriously consider buying from one of the recommended indies.
2/ Warranty. On a 'up to 2' year old car, you will get the remainder of the *original* 2 year warranty, PLUS an *additional* 2 year Porsche warranty. For example, i have just bought a March 2010 car. My warranty runs until March 2014. So, i have 2.5 years PORSCHE warranty on my used car.
I also echo AndyBrew's comments re Leicester OPC. It's also worth noting Leicester are in group of 6 OPC's, so i'd be very surprised if they do not have a car you like.
Mid Sussex is the best OPC in the world.
Thats said you need to find a recommended OPC of Indy you can trust. I've had bad dealings with some of the London ones and MS are a complete contrast. Also several Indy's come highly recommended on here so worth doing some research.
I've always liked the gravel in the pics on Henry's adverts and can see my car parked on it one day...
Good luck
Thats said you need to find a recommended OPC of Indy you can trust. I've had bad dealings with some of the London ones and MS are a complete contrast. Also several Indy's come highly recommended on here so worth doing some research.
I've always liked the gravel in the pics on Henry's adverts and can see my car parked on it one day...
Good luck

Phooey said:
Up to 2 years old - i would buy from an OPC personally.
Why?
1/ There are some good indies (you need to do your research), but imho the prices of their new-ish stock are not much cheaper (if any) than OPC's. On older stock - i would then seriously consider buying from one of the recommended indies.
2/ Warranty. On a 'up to 2' year old car, you will get the remainder of the *original* 2 year warranty, PLUS an *additional* 2 year Porsche warranty. For example, i have just bought a March 2010 car. My warranty runs until March 2014. So, i have 2.5 years PORSCHE warranty on my used car.
I also echo AndyBrew's comments re Leicester OPC. It's also worth noting Leicester are in group of 6 OPC's, so i'd be very surprised if they do not have a car you like.
Very good point! That would be very convenient for me as I would probably take the Cayman on a 36 month personal contract, as I don't want to have the same car for longer than that. The warranty coverage for the majority of that period would take one less headache away if anything that is not fit for purpose occurs. Why?
1/ There are some good indies (you need to do your research), but imho the prices of their new-ish stock are not much cheaper (if any) than OPC's. On older stock - i would then seriously consider buying from one of the recommended indies.
2/ Warranty. On a 'up to 2' year old car, you will get the remainder of the *original* 2 year warranty, PLUS an *additional* 2 year Porsche warranty. For example, i have just bought a March 2010 car. My warranty runs until March 2014. So, i have 2.5 years PORSCHE warranty on my used car.
I also echo AndyBrew's comments re Leicester OPC. It's also worth noting Leicester are in group of 6 OPC's, so i'd be very surprised if they do not have a car you like.
Thanks
thegoose said:
Do bear in mind that the OPC's have to get their cars from somewhere and so do specialists - these sources of supply are often the same (private owners, part exchanges at non-Porsche dealers etc).
So it stands to reason that if you're buying a vehicle in a fancy showroom (drinking their coffee..) you will be paying more for it (£10 million showrooms don't just appear out of nowhere) than from somewhere with smaller overheads.
I agree. However, from another thread...So it stands to reason that if you're buying a vehicle in a fancy showroom (drinking their coffee..) you will be paying more for it (£10 million showrooms don't just appear out of nowhere) than from somewhere with smaller overheads.
matc said:
People have a very skewed idea of the sort of money an OPC has in their cars, I bet the average margin they make on a used car is less than then most of the specialists we have on here.
OPCs have the luxury of new car margins, dealer bonuses and servicing to top up their income; used car indys don't have this luxury, so they'll need to make more per car.
Your thoughts?OPCs have the luxury of new car margins, dealer bonuses and servicing to top up their income; used car indys don't have this luxury, so they'll need to make more per car.
I agree with Phooey when I was looking the price difference between an independent and an OPC on a less than 12 month old car was marginal for me personally.
The only thing I would say is that the OPC offered me £9,000 for my Z4 3.0 SI and a local trader gave me £12,000 for it which I thought was a bit weird, but to be honest I never pushed that issue just off-loaded it.
I'd get out there and have a look at a few cars and speak to the people in question, depending on where you're based that maybe easier said than done but I would suggest its well worth travelling to the right place and making a day of it if required contact the dealer beforehand so they know you're coming oh and make sure they have a car or two in stock you fancy!
The only thing I would say is that the OPC offered me £9,000 for my Z4 3.0 SI and a local trader gave me £12,000 for it which I thought was a bit weird, but to be honest I never pushed that issue just off-loaded it.
I'd get out there and have a look at a few cars and speak to the people in question, depending on where you're based that maybe easier said than done but I would suggest its well worth travelling to the right place and making a day of it if required contact the dealer beforehand so they know you're coming oh and make sure they have a car or two in stock you fancy!
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



