WTB a porsche....
WTB a porsche....
Author
Discussion

Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
Hi
So I'm wanting to buy a new (used) car. I have a strict budget of £30k, and would prefer to spend less. Added to the mix is that the cheaper it is the sooner I can buy it. I'll probably need to wait till march to get the £30k price, but could do £15k tomorrow.
I am budgeting £2kpa maintenance.

I've looked at M3, M6, 996 Turbo, 996 4S, 997 2 for around 23-29k, and I've been reading about the cars everywhere, and there just seem to be too many options, so I'll ask you for some advice smile
What I've concluded from my trawls of the internet:
996 4S is an all around good choice. Small storage space though. Heard about engines blowing up, but if you get a reasonable high mileage car the problem probably won't manifest.
996 TT is a nice car. I don't know about maintenance/things that go wrong etc, so I'm a little apprehensive about this model...
997 Seems like a more modern car.
Boxter/Cayman only have 2 seats. I've driven both and enjoyed them. Will need extra convincing of the wife so would need a good reason to get these over a 911.
M3/M6 all around nice cars, modern, lots of good tech, lovely high revving engines. Not porsches though..

I don't do much driving so I won't put many miles on the clock. I would like to track it maybe 3-4 times a year, sunday morning drives etc.

Any advice? I'd love to know real costs to maintain these cars, and also how much fun they are to drive on a regular basis.
Cheers

911p

2,361 posts

211 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
Ever considered a 996 40th Anniversary? It has X51, LSD, M030 etc - all the performance options which would be ideal for tracking the car. You could get a very good one for about £27k, quicker than a 3.8 997 C2S.

Khushy will be along soon! hehe

Edited by 911p on Tuesday 6th September 14:47

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
Boogsie said:
996 4S is an all around good choice. Small storage space though.
It's all relative. It's no transit van, but the combination of the rear seat area and the front boot is plenty.


Boogsie said:
996 TT is a nice car. I don't know about maintenance/things that go wrong etc, so I'm a little apprehensive about this model...
Don't be. It is a fantastic machine (I have one). Epic performance.
The biggest thing to look out for is accident damage. It's a fairly reliable machine all in all, but parts can be expensive-ish (a new engine is around £20k from memory).


Boogsie said:
I'd love to know real costs to maintain these cars,
There is a 'costs to run a 996 C4S' thread posted here recently. My turbo is certainly costing no more to run than that.

Boogsie said:
and also how much fun they are to drive on a regular basis.
Cheers
In a word, brilliant. Just a really nice driving experience, with real feedback and poise.


anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
Boogsie said:
Boxter/Cayman only have 2 seats. I've driven both and enjoyed them. Will need extra convincing of the wife so would need a good reason to get these over a 911.
They're cheaper. That should work for her smile

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Boogsie said:
Boxter/Cayman only have 2 seats. I've driven both and enjoyed them. Will need extra convincing of the wife so would need a good reason to get these over a 911.
They're cheaper. That should work for her smile
But she'll fit more shoes and handbags in a 911....

Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
monthefish said:
Don't be. It is a fantastic machine (I have one). Epic performance.
This is what I'd like to hear biggrin It is my favourite of the bunch.


monthefish said:
The biggest thing to look out for is accident damage. It's a fairly reliable machine all in all, but parts can be expensive-ish (a new engine is around £20k from memory).
I'm getting recollections of that thread. I'll look it up.

So what about a warranty? Is it worth it/Recommended? I'm a total cynic when it comes to warranties. Grr... but £20k for an engine would hurt. I suppose in this case it's worth looking into! smile






Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Boogsie said:
Boxter/Cayman only have 2 seats. I've driven both and enjoyed them. Will need extra convincing of the wife so would need a good reason to get these over a 911.
They're cheaper. That should work for her smile
Too true smile but can't fit the kids. This will in all likelihood impact my drive time as well as making it a harder sell.
Also my mind works in mysterious ways. I'll start looking at the 15K mark and before I know it I'd have shelled out 27k on a much newer car!

Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
monthefish said:
uktrailmonster said:
Boogsie said:
Boxter/Cayman only have 2 seats. I've driven both and enjoyed them. Will need extra convincing of the wife so would need a good reason to get these over a 911.
They're cheaper. That should work for her smile
But she'll fit more shoes and handbags in a 911....
Hmm... the new Spyder is a nice car smile

Zp

16,175 posts

220 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
If you decide on the turbo at lest have a very long drive in one.
I was seduced by the insane performance at first, but it quickly dawned on me that that isn't the be all and end all of vehicular enjoyment.

You may love it, but it really wasn't for me and for two years I almost regretted buying it.

For me, I feel I'm having more fun in the Spyder, but realise that's out of hour price range.

Good luck on your decision. smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
Boogsie said:
Too true smile but can't fit the kids. This will in all likelihood impact my drive time as well as making it a harder sell.
Also my mind works in mysterious ways. I'll start looking at the 15K mark and before I know it I'd have shelled out 27k on a much newer car!
I've got that issue too and I've also moved from looking at £15K cars up to £25K+ smile

FeelingLucky

1,186 posts

195 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
Boogsie said:
Hi
So I'm wanting to buy a new (used) car. I have a strict budget of £30k, and would prefer to spend less. Added to the mix is that the cheaper it is the sooner I can buy it. I'll probably need to wait till march to get the £30k price, but could do £15k tomorrow.
I am budgeting £2kpa maintenance.
I have been asking myself this exact same question now for about 12 months, and in that time read most of the posts on this forum.

I came down to a tie between a 6tt and a 7c2s.
Whilst the more modern design of the 7 appeals, continuing posts regarding engine issues do not.
Then again the epic performance of a 6tt draws me in that direction.

The ONLY thing stopping me making the change is that my current E46 M3 is Soooooo good I can't bear to part with her. Fabulous performance and reliability with total practicality. In my five years of ownerdship it's only ever had to go to the dealers once outside servicing, and that was recently for replacement of two sensors (traction control warning, emissions warning, engine management warning lights) Total bill £295






Edited by FeelingLucky on Tuesday 6th September 22:10

ScienceTeacher

408 posts

216 months

Tuesday 6th September 2011
quotequote all
If spending £30K I'd go for a £23-26K car ('06 997 or 996T) and spend the rest on properly servicing and replacing worn bits. In the case of the turbo this could easily cost 5 or 6K. You then have a bullet proof drive - perhaps not the greatest for a quick resale, however.

Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
ScienceTeacher said:
If spending £30K I'd go for a £23-26K car ('06 997 or 996T) and spend the rest on properly servicing and replacing worn bits. In the case of the turbo this could easily cost 5 or 6K. You then have a bullet proof drive - perhaps not the greatest for a quick resale, however.
I'd probably keep it a number of years, so not too worried about resale.

So what about warranties from dealers? Are they worth anything? I've seen a few TTs at RSJ, and they have a warranty scheme.
Or is it worth being aggressive about fixing things that *might* go wrong?

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
Boogsie said:
So what about a warranty? Is it worth it/Recommended? I'm a total cynic when it comes to warranties. Grr... but £20k for an engine would hurt. I suppose in this case it's worth looking into! smile
In my view, yes, but it totally depends on your own 'risk aversion' and your financial position. Each to their own on this.

Some just put money aside every month and pay into their own theoretical 'warranty fund', which sounds good in theory (especially if it is never called upon), however the reality is that it is the big bills that you really want protection from, and it would take many years of saving 'your own warranty fund' to cover such bills.

I looked into Warranty Wise/Warranty Direct (can't remember which) and got a quote from them which semmed quite good, especially if you specify OPC labour rates as part of the deal, however I have heard sufficient stories about them refusing to pay out on big bills that undermined the whole 'safety blanket feeling' which is the whole point of having a warranty in the first place (PM Mike @ Sports and Classic for further details on this matter). If it gets 'nasty', I'm sure they can afford better Lawyers that the general public.

I went with Hartech as, when you analyse the numbers, its a pretty good deal as the monthly cost includes all servicing and MOT, and the warranty inlcudes wear and tear items (you just pay for parts).

Read up and buy informed (there's a warranty thread at the top of the forum list).

If you can buy with OPC warranty, either privately or through and OPC, then that's probably a fairly safe route (although not totally guranteed, and you'll pay for the privilege).

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
911p said:
Khushy will be along soon! hehe
;-)

Koll

425 posts

195 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
£35k and its yours. PM if you have any intrest. thumbup

Available with / without the wrap. Dark Grey underneath.


Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Koll said:
£35k and its yours. PM if you have any intrest. thumbup

Available with / without the wrap. Dark Grey underneath.

Tempting!!
But out of my price range frown

Koll

425 posts

195 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Boogsie said:
Tempting!!
But out of my price range frown
Only just .. wink
Let me know if you change your mind smile

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Koll said:
Boogsie said:
Tempting!!
But out of my price range frown
Only just .. wink
Let me know if you change your mind smile
Plus he wanted a Porsche...

tongue out




Boogsie

Original Poster:

124 posts

182 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Koll said:
Available with / without the wrap. Dark Grey underneath.
How does wrapping work? Can you tell a car's been wrapped? Could I walk past a corner and catch it?