996 GT3 @ 40k vs cayman s @ 25k
996 GT3 @ 40k vs cayman s @ 25k
Author
Discussion

wantacar

Original Poster:

78 posts

191 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
I would like some help on deciding on which car in terms of depreciation and ownership costs.

I have a two year window to own one of these two cars and then I'll be selling up to fund a house extension. Effectively rather then spending the money on a house extension now, I want to use it to own a nice sports car before life gets on top of me too much.

But because I'll need that sum to help with the house extension later, I need to retain as much of it as possible.

If I was to buy the GT3, I would be buying a shed to run for work and keep the GT3 as weekend toy.

If I was to buy the cayman, I would run it as one car for work and probably heap about 30k miles on it in two years.

I like both cars so really it's the figures that may swing it. It's mainly the potential depreciation on the cayman s that worries me, but then upkeep of a gt3 and cost of second car and it's associated costs would be pretty high too...

Any suggestions?

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
If either car is something you envision only ever being able to own within the next 2 years then to me the GT3 would be a no-brainer.

wantacar

Original Poster:

78 posts

191 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
Durzel said:
If either car is something you envision only ever being able to own within the next 2 years then to me the GT3 would be a no-brainer.
I can probably afford to get the cayman or something along those lines again in years to come, but probably not a 40k motor...

good point, didn't think of that...

cragswinter

21,429 posts

227 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
Here's the craic wanta, you're gonna get a load of folks posting up saying the only car to consider is the gt3, 'cos there depreciation proof & might even rise in value yeah?

Yeah right.

Get yourself on the phone to a couple of specialists, dealers etc. Tell them you've got a 996 gt3, what ever spec you think you can afford & ask them what they'll give you for it if it's in mint condition.

25% loss easy

all2ofme

855 posts

219 months

Monday 12th September 2011
quotequote all
Craig's probably right. The GT3 won't be free to run (even if it appreciated a wee bit while you owned it!), but with the memories you'll have from your time with it I'd be very surprised if you cared biggrin

(Speaking of which, and very OT - you going for that other car, Craig?)

sportsandclassic

3,774 posts

249 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
cragswinter said:
Here's the craic wanta, you're gonna get a load of folks posting up saying the only car to consider is the gt3, 'cos there depreciation proof & might even rise in value yeah?

Yeah right.

Get yourself on the phone to a couple of specialists, dealers etc. Tell them you've got a 996 gt3, what ever spec you think you can afford & ask them what they'll give you for it if it's in mint condition.

25% loss easy
YHM

cragswinter

21,429 posts

227 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
sportsandclassic said:
YHM
As do you pal,
You going to have your car back together in time for next months spa/ring trip?

wantacar

Original Poster:

78 posts

191 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
cragswinter said:
Here's the craic wanta, you're gonna get a load of folks posting up saying the only car to consider is the gt3, 'cos there depreciation proof & might even rise in value yeah?

Yeah right.

Get yourself on the phone to a couple of specialists, dealers etc. Tell them you've got a 996 gt3, what ever spec you think you can afford & ask them what they'll give you for it if it's in mint condition.

25% loss easy
Ouch...really!

Damn....will get on the blower...

sportsandclassic

3,774 posts

249 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
cragswinter said:
As do you pal,
You going to have your car back together in time for next months spa/ring trip?
Hi,

car should be back together, not got a passout this year to go frown

Mike

cragswinter

21,429 posts

227 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
it's the way i'd be looking at it mate if you're thinking it's going to be a short term ownership propasition.

fact is a lot of the cars up on pistonheads/autotrader at the moment have been up for sale for the best part of a year. they just aren't shifting at those prices. i can get my hands on a mint low mileage mk1 clubsport but the owner is looking at £40k+ & it just isn't going to happen in my opinion.

cars come & go on the classifieds but i honestly think it isn't because they're selling but more because people can't get shot & pull the ads.

the caymen will definatly lose money, but how much? even if it loses 25% like the gt3 it's still 25% of a much lower initial purchase price.

fact remains, any car that's at a dealer for £40-45k has at least £10k in it for the dealer. not that i think that's a bad thing in any way, the dealer has to pay vat on the difference, buy a warrenty, pay for staff, rent, business rates etc etc so they aren't maing a kiling on those margins. you just have to be aware that if you buy at retail from a dealer, you're going to lose that margin when it comes to sale time.

imho if i was worried about pulling my money out for other uses in anything up to two years time i'd buy the car with the least purchase price thus minimising any potential depreciation.

this of course assumes that all things are equal in two years time. i don't have a crystal ball remember, none of us do. but i'd see that as the least risk possible.

as great as gt3's are thesimple fact is they aren't like RS cars of old-ie a limited edition build that wasn't to be repeated:
gt3 mk1 clubsport
gt3 mk1 comfort
gt3 mk2 clubsport
gt3 mk2 comfort
gt3 mk2 rs
gt3 997 clubsport
gt3 997 comfort
gt3 997 rs.1
gt3 997 3.8 clubsport
gt3 997 3.8 comfort
gt3 997 3.8 rs
gt3 997 4.0 rs
they keep building them & that's bound to force the price of the older models down, simple economics & although in more robust times i don't think it was a problem i think the amount of people who are willing to indulge in a £40k toy are pretty thin on the ground at the moment.

but like i said i don't have a crystal ball & anything could happen re values. just don't expect any or performance car not to lose money in the next 24 months, & if that's your biggest worry it might be time to start looking at the classics smile

mft

1,752 posts

253 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
I can iamgine a £25k Cayman S, with daily-use miles added, dropping at least ~£8k over a couple of years. Add tax, servicing, tyres, fuel, and insurance, and it'll cost a decent amount.

Based on old spreadsheets I have somewhere (!) even the cheapest of cheapo daily stters will cost £1.5-2k in depreciation, tax, servicing, tyres, and insurance per year, depending on the car you choose, with fuel on top. A GT3 may or may not depreciate less than the Cayman (assuming you can sell it on - as above) but will cost less in fuel and consumables (as you'll use it far less) and insurance may be cheaper too, on a limited-miles specialist policy. Overall, there may not be much of a difference financially between the two options, as the cost of the daily will probably cancel out any savings that might transpire on the GT3. Plus a big couple of service bills could occur unexpectedly with either approach, which would throw things out completely.

My point? Don't make the decision financially, as it arguably won't make much difference, barring factors which you can't predict. If you really want to spend your everyday driving life in a shed, and have a GT3 to enjoy at weekends, go for it. Alternatively, buy a Cayman and enjoy it every day.

Or... buy a 996 C4S for £22k. smile It's a bit more special than the Cayman (IMO) and is lower on its depreciation curve... nuts

cragswinter

21,429 posts

227 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
but of course there's also the problems of combined bills of your daily snotter & the gt3 (ask me how i know!).

there's no easy answer is there, i mean you could buy a gt3 run it for two years & it might never need another thing doing to it. or it could go through two rads, some diff plates, front discs & pads etc etc.

smile

Scott Laurie

155 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
with the cayman - you are guaranteed to be losing £500 a month in depreciation as a minimum i would guess,

with the GT3 - you would need to buy a good example privately and aim to sell privately. value will be pretty much the same in two years i would guess, service, repair etc is always a gamble on older cars, but then you will have saved around £12k on depreciation so should have some change

selling GT3s is more difficult as the market is smaller and can take longer to sell, but they will keep their value,

Mk1 GT3's I think are a better bet also as they are rarer. most of the porsche range that was small in production numbers keep their value well and eventually become collectable.

i have had a few 911's, boxsters, GT3 RS and couple of ferraris, the boxster new was £39k, i bought it 12 months old with 9k miles for £22500, i had it two years, did 30k miles and sold it for £15500,

had my RS for 18months, its worth the same or more than I paid,

cheers
scott.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
I suspect if you go the £40K GT3 route you might end up with a garage Queen on your hands. Weekend toys often end up that way if you are busy and especially if you are scared to put miles on it for resale value. As mentioned above, I would put £25K into an older 911 (996 C4S would be a good choice) and use it as your everyday car. £25K should get you a low mileage 2003/4 car already quite low on its depreciation curve. In two years time, putting on average mileage, you could still expect to get £20K ish back. Allow for running costs of around £2K per annum plus fuel and insurance. A newer £25K Cayman would certainly lose a fair bit more in the same timescale and running costs would be similar, maybe a tad less.

puntograle

2,667 posts

239 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
cragswinter said:
25% loss easy
Generally, I agree with the sentiment of Cragswinter's advice in that the market is slower at the moment and if you are dealing with the retail community then you should allow for transactional loss to cover their margins.

However, I think I would differ on the material impact of this. In my view £10K transactional loss on a £40K car is rounding up on the high side. I think the reality is more around £6-8K which is still substantial if you only keep it for one year. However, over a 2 year period (and assuming that core value of the car stays relatively static) then you are talking about £3-4K a year which I think is bearable.

Of course, you can mitigate against this by taking more of your personal time in how and where you buy and sell. As an example, I sold a 996 GT3 this summer and over a 2 year period it cost me 3% (1.5% per year excluding running costs and maintenance) - I had bought from a small independent and sold privately - and had 2 years of absolutely brilliant fun in it.

...I still agree with Cragswinter though in that plan for the worst - you may have to sell in a hurry to a dealer, the core price may reduce a little more, and of course we have not factored in running costs which if you buy carefully should not be that bad...but you never know if you hit a perfect storm of brakes, rads, diff, etc. Therefore you need to be able to use it comfortably and not wrap it up in cotten wool all the time.

Personally, it makes sense to me for what I get in enjoyment for the amount spent...

All IMHO, hope that helps.

agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
cragswinter said:
as great as gt3s are the simple fact is they aren't like RS cars of old-ie a limited edition build that wasn't to be repeated... might be time to start looking at the classics smile
the 996 GT3 RS was built in much lower numbers than the 2.7 RS, 964 RS, 993 RS and 997 RS. in fact, you're more likely to see a carrera GT or a Ferrari F40 than a 6RS. a modern classic. prices are bound to rise.

in my opinion, the most undervalued porsche is the 1989 3.2 ClubSport. buy buy buy.

puntograle

2,667 posts

239 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Sorry, I also forgot to add that on PH you will generally find two types of answers to these kind of questions:

1. Owners who are in love with their cars and believe the prices being asked for are reasonable (and will talk up the market)
2. Potential buyers who will argue that cars are all over priced and due a fall (and will talk down current prices)

Interestingly, if you go back and look at the serial 2s, once they buy one they go oddly quiet about the potential downsides of ownership on such threads!

Of course, since these cars are relatively rare and usually second cars owned by people who do not HAVE to sell, the 1s can afford to stay in their space until the market meets their need and so the prices stay relatively static....this really pees off the 2s!

No disrespect intended to anyone.

smile

Edited by puntograle on Tuesday 13th September 11:49

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
the 996 GT3 RS was built in much lower numbers than the 2.7 RS, 964 RS, 993 RS and 997 RS. in fact, you're more likely to see a carrera GT or a Ferrari F40 than a 6RS. a modern classic. prices are bound to rise.

in my opinion, the most undervalued porsche is the 1989 3.2 ClubSport. buy buy buy.
I don't think you can buy a GT3 RS for £40K. I think the discussion is around the standard GT3 no?

3.2 CS undervalued? I think not chap. I'd agree with that 10 years ago but not today. I looked at buying one a couple of years ago and it was looking like a £35K purchase for a half decent example. I'm a big fan of classic 911s too, but even I wouldn't pay that for a CS! There's nothing particularly special about this car either over a standard C3.2. It's a great car, but at best it was a half hearted factory attempt at a lightweight Carrera. The factory went much further with mods for the 964RS for example. If you want an undervalued Porsche, try a mint 911 SC for around £15K.

cragswinter

21,429 posts

227 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
cragswinter said:
as great as gt3s are the simple fact is they aren't like RS cars of old-ie a limited edition build that wasn't to be repeated... might be time to start looking at the classics smile
the 996 GT3 RS was built in much lower numbers than the 2.7 RS, 964 RS, 993 RS and 997 RS. in fact, you're more likely to see a carrera GT or a Ferrari F40 than a 6RS. a modern classic. prices are bound to rise.

in my opinion, the most undervalued porsche is the 1989 3.2 ClubSport. buy buy buy.
hehe andrew you always post the same thing! how's it going anyways mate you still coming out to the ring/spa next month?

i'm not getting into this craic again but my view still remains, as nice as the 996 gt3 rs is, it's just another in the long line of 996/997 gt3 cars. personally i agree with what you think, if any of them are to hold their value (note the lack of the word increase-you'll have to be in it for the long long game for that to happen) it'll be the 96rs, but who knows? it still has those fking front lights & that aint ever going to change!

as for the 3.2 clubbie, the boats gone mate, you're two years too late. you need £50k to get a good one & even ex race cars/hill climbers are mid to high 30's. they also have one major thing lacking-no RS letters on the back!


agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
i have that post saved so i can just do a cut/paste. see you there mate, partyboat 1st oct then back after the trackday on tuesday.