£22k odd to spend - 993 or 996
£22k odd to spend - 993 or 996
Author
Discussion

plumpchicken

Original Poster:

14 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
I am a newbie - and apologies if this sort of request has been made before.

I am in the privileged position of having a budget of £20k to spend (maximum) - but if I can spend less I would be happy to. I am sold on the idea of a Porsche 911 for everyday use - around a 15 mile daily commute with traffic and a likely annual mileage of around 6-7k. Petrol consumption not an issue. Ideally I fancy a targa. My heart says a 993 (the targa versions do seem to be more expensive at the moment) but my head says a more reliable and comfortable 996 with all the mod-cons (and which are cheaper at prices from £15k). I am undecided between a manual or tiptronic.

If I buy from a private seller I will get a Porsche specialist to check it out and therefore on the face of it I should only be buying a car with a clean bill of health.....

Any helpful comments gratefully rec'd.

Mike Holmes

188 posts

216 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
A 993 without any shadow of doudt , 996 full of water and leaks , 993 all air and getting quite rare

Go for a coupe as well

rolleyes

KH

3,003 posts

216 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
You need to drive both. They are totally different cars. Buy the one you like best and keep £3000 in the piggy bank for yearly maintenance.

marky911

4,434 posts

250 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
As above, get out and view some, drive some, read up loads on 'em both.

Personally, I'd say a 993. Rarer, more raw, although you could interpret that as old (hence, drive some), bullet-proof residuals, prettier (again, that's purely opinion).

Basically, all you'll get in here is opinion, which is good and can be full of info but, you need to get out in some cars to see what floats your boat.

Don't panic about the £3k a year as above. That would be a nice figure to stick aside but, it won't cost that every year! Mind you, an engine failure would wipe out a couple of years savings, instantly. (And I'm not aiming that specificly at the 996).

Get one bought! Good luck. smile

BertBert

21,348 posts

242 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
I've just plumped for 993 targa ownership. Although I've only done the test drive so far, I immediately fell in love!
Bert

PS with the car!

birdcage

2,935 posts

236 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
993 as 996 almost sounds expensive at any price it's so ugly

gibbon

2,182 posts

238 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Yawn, why are people so single minded? Gets very boring.

Both cars do different things well, drive both in quick succession and make your mind up, hard to do it any other way.

Good luck and enjoy.

fel71

478 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
You could try a late 964 also, but whichever you choose just enjoy,all have good and less good points (drive and decide),most comments made seem to just show negatives of certain 911's,lots of model snobbery rather than embracing the marque.confused

mikees

2,909 posts

203 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
Or a couple of grand more and a 997? I'd get a 993 (and I have a 997)

Zeek

882 posts

235 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
I've had both. I had the 996 first, and it's fantastic, a great car to drive, comfortable, behaves well, works properly in all weather etc. Never had any issues with mine.

I moved to a 993 after driving one. Every drive felt more of an event. I still have the 993, and will be keeping it.

If it is your only car, I'd take the 996. The 993 isn't my only car, so when I want to drive a 911, I want it to feel special, and the 993 does that for me. Drive both and you'll know which is the right one for you.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
big money for a 996 however it's got a lot going for it

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3210965.htm

SilverstoneSid

29 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th September 2011
quotequote all
I was planning to buy a 993 based on "received wisdom" etc. Before I did, I bought myself a 911 Evolution driving experience at Porsche Silverstone. Got to try an old 3.2 Carrera, 993 and 997 C2 back to back on all their different tracks.

Really glad I did, as it helped me make a clear decision. 997 was it for me - just so much more fun to drive. Better driving position, better turn-in, much more oomph and really exploitable on and past the limit of grip.

Now the proud owner of a 54 plate 997 C2 bought for just a few grand more than your budget.

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
Mike Holmes said:
A 993 without any shadow of doudt , 996 full of water and leaks , 993 all air and getting quite rare
Are you being serious?

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
monthefish said:
Mike Holmes said:
A 993 without any shadow of doudt , 996 full of water and leaks , 993 all air and getting quite rare
Are you being serious?
It's a matter of fact it has water which will eventually leak (probably from a pump or rad) wink

I would get the 993 for limited depreciation & (subjectively) better looks. Why would it be a worse daily driver ?

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
big money for a 996 however it's got a lot going for it

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3210965.htm
Too expensive for a 2002 C2. Engine mods etc are great but your average buyer would be put off on resale. Personally I'd go for a car with less 'baggage' as it were. There are plenty of low mileage standard cars around with no faults at that price.

johnycarrera

1,935 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
If you don't just take one look and say "Wow it's got to be the 993, it just looks so much better" then you may prefer the newer experience with the funny lights etc.
I believe there's another thread talking about a 997 Carrera for 22k that has 80k miles, wait a couple months and there will be more around at a similar cost. A 993 is a very "personal" choice when you're in the position of being able to buy both (or indeed all 3 if you can afford a 997) and so newest could be favourite if you need to ask smile


Edited by johnycarrera on Wednesday 14th September 15:03

CGT1

33 posts

183 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
993 THE FINEST PORSCHE PORSCHE HAVE BUILT.

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
996 and keep £10K in the bank. No seriously, have a look at the 996 for £10k thread that was running on General Gassing.

pp

plumpchicken

Original Poster:

14 posts

182 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
Many thanks to all your posts - very helpful. I am going to make some appointments and will (all being well) report on the purchase....

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
I would say 993 for many reasons, all mentioned here many times, but one thing I would say is that given your budget limitation, do make sure you try to have some additional money put away just in case of any future unexpected bills beyond normal servicing, no matter which model you buy.