997.1 GT3 RMS - clutch contamination?
Discussion
Hi chaps.
My 997.1 GT3 has just gone in to Porsche, and they have confirmed it's got a RMS oil leak. Full Porsche warranty on the car so they pick up the bill.
They are currently taking the engine out. They said on a test drive that the clutch is slipping slightly.
What I need to know is: is there any chance there can be oil contamination on the clutch plates from a RMS oil leak? The clutch wasn't slipping before. I have told them to take the clutch out so I can examine it, what should I look out for apart from obviously oil on the friction plate?
Also they are saying to change the flywheel which doubles the cost of the clutch change, is this normally necessary and what is the general thoughts on this?
Thanks
My 997.1 GT3 has just gone in to Porsche, and they have confirmed it's got a RMS oil leak. Full Porsche warranty on the car so they pick up the bill.
They are currently taking the engine out. They said on a test drive that the clutch is slipping slightly.
What I need to know is: is there any chance there can be oil contamination on the clutch plates from a RMS oil leak? The clutch wasn't slipping before. I have told them to take the clutch out so I can examine it, what should I look out for apart from obviously oil on the friction plate?
Also they are saying to change the flywheel which doubles the cost of the clutch change, is this normally necessary and what is the general thoughts on this?
Thanks
Its done 33k Kms.
Well, either way I will be holding on to the worn parts, so if they say it's not contaminated I'll get the parts professionally inspected for a second opinion if I think they're trying to pull a fast one.
Surely for the dealer it makes no difference though and they will just tell the truth, as they will not be paying for a new clutch and it means more work their way? My OPC has always been pretty good, even fixing interior trim panels and the like under warranty with no complaints...
Well, either way I will be holding on to the worn parts, so if they say it's not contaminated I'll get the parts professionally inspected for a second opinion if I think they're trying to pull a fast one.
Surely for the dealer it makes no difference though and they will just tell the truth, as they will not be paying for a new clutch and it means more work their way? My OPC has always been pretty good, even fixing interior trim panels and the like under warranty with no complaints...
S1MMA said:
Its done 33k Kms.
Well, either way I will be holding on to the worn parts, so if they say it's not contaminated I'll get the parts professionally inspected for a second opinion if I think they're trying to pull a fast one.
Surely for the dealer it makes no difference though and they will just tell the truth, as they will not be paying for a new clutch and it means more work their way? My OPC has always been pretty good, even fixing interior trim panels and the like under warranty with no complaints...
I believe OPC's are under a lot tighter control from Germany than the old days, and certainly large parts claims etc need to be very well documented, and in some cases photographic evidence is required before they get the OK to carry out the work under warranty. Well, either way I will be holding on to the worn parts, so if they say it's not contaminated I'll get the parts professionally inspected for a second opinion if I think they're trying to pull a fast one.
Surely for the dealer it makes no difference though and they will just tell the truth, as they will not be paying for a new clutch and it means more work their way? My OPC has always been pretty good, even fixing interior trim panels and the like under warranty with no complaints...
ok, they are removing the engine as we speak.
my plan of action is:
call them, tell them to remove engine, and remove clutch.
do not clean anything or do anything further, take pictures.
I will go exampine everything myself and see if I can see any obvious signs of oil contamination on clutch friction plate or flywheel.
go from there, does that sound ok?
my plan of action is:
call them, tell them to remove engine, and remove clutch.
do not clean anything or do anything further, take pictures.
I will go exampine everything myself and see if I can see any obvious signs of oil contamination on clutch friction plate or flywheel.
go from there, does that sound ok?
_gez_ said:
Well, I suppose the worst you could be looking at is the parts costs. There shouldn't be any labour to pay for the clutch change as all that has to come off for the RMS.
Maybe it might be better to aim for 50% contribution to the parts as the clutch will have had some wear?
what my thougts were:Maybe it might be better to aim for 50% contribution to the parts as the clutch will have had some wear?
1) if no oil contamintaion, and the clutch is worn, then i'll pay parts for a new one, OPC has confirmed no labour to pay as engine already out
2) if there is oil contamination, warranty job to replace new clutch
Can I really ask for 50% contribution is clutch isn't too worn and there is no oil contamniation?
_gez_ said:
Sorry, I meant aim for 50% if it isn't clear cut that the oil is the cause - i.e. some evidence of contamination but Porsche say it is not the reason for the slipping.
Ah, makes sense, thanks. If it's obvious oil contamination I think 100% Porsche pay is fair, as it's consequential damage from RMS, if it's debatable then I'll go for 50%.Cheers.
It sounds like this could be confusing and a "chicken & egg" situation - if oil gets on the clutch it'll slip, but this can burn the oil off again, leaving little evidence that the slipping was caused by the leak.
However, I presume there is some data somewhere about friction material thickness when new and when worn out, so the plate in your car could be measured against this? If so and yours is not worn out (whether that'd be 85% or 95% or 99.9% of the thickness that's considered useable I don't know) then blame the leak.
However, I presume there is some data somewhere about friction material thickness when new and when worn out, so the plate in your car could be measured against this? If so and yours is not worn out (whether that'd be 85% or 95% or 99.9% of the thickness that's considered useable I don't know) then blame the leak.

Thanks for the above, I will be inspecting the clutch tomorrow so will report back with findings.
I also told them to check the rear diff, I thought maybe it could be shagged after this milage. Is there any more scientific method of checking it other than turning one wheel when jacked up and feeling resistance from the diff? If the wheel turns freely then diff not working well? Any other methods?
I also told them to check the rear diff, I thought maybe it could be shagged after this milage. Is there any more scientific method of checking it other than turning one wheel when jacked up and feeling resistance from the diff? If the wheel turns freely then diff not working well? Any other methods?
Update -
Went and saw the car, nothing quite prepares you for the sight of your p&j 6 foot off the ground with no back end, no engine, no gearbox and lots of wires/lines hanging from under it, the engine on a workbench, the gearbox on another, and the clutch on another seperate bench. I blurted out "what the hell have you done to my car!" joking of course.
I had a good look at the clutch, just looked worn out to be honest. The friction material had a mm or 2 to go before it was fully flat (worn down so the friction material was all one depth), the pressure plate was spotted and the flywheel also needed to be skimmed. No obvious signs of oil contamination, the service manager also showed my where the leak came from and that the clutch was unaffected. Everything he showed me made sense, they had literally taken the car apart and taped sheeting over all of it till I turned up, inspected it and gave them the green light to go ahead with it.
The service manager was also the man responsible for maintaing and rebuilding the GT3 cup cars here, so he knew his way around the GT3. There was also a nice black Carerra GT on the workshop floor. He said it's best to change the fuel filter as the engine was out, easy access. Also he said everything else inc engine mounts was in good order, nothing else needed to be done.
I told him to check the diff when the car's rebuilt, nothing really more to add - they need to get hold of a pressure plate (friction plate and release bearing in stock), and then rebuild it all back up again.
Will push for a discount on the parts, but other than that they did what I asked and made me feel like the car's in good hands. Must be what it's like to deal with Reading from the reports I've read on here, makes a big difference to have someone who knows his stuff look after your car rather than a 18yr old spotty pleb. At least I know who to deal with next time the car goes to OPC!
Will update if any more problems or when I get the car back, looks like it will be thick end of next week at earliest or the week after most likely. Cayenne S and "lets..............OFFROAD" till then!
Went and saw the car, nothing quite prepares you for the sight of your p&j 6 foot off the ground with no back end, no engine, no gearbox and lots of wires/lines hanging from under it, the engine on a workbench, the gearbox on another, and the clutch on another seperate bench. I blurted out "what the hell have you done to my car!" joking of course.
I had a good look at the clutch, just looked worn out to be honest. The friction material had a mm or 2 to go before it was fully flat (worn down so the friction material was all one depth), the pressure plate was spotted and the flywheel also needed to be skimmed. No obvious signs of oil contamination, the service manager also showed my where the leak came from and that the clutch was unaffected. Everything he showed me made sense, they had literally taken the car apart and taped sheeting over all of it till I turned up, inspected it and gave them the green light to go ahead with it.
The service manager was also the man responsible for maintaing and rebuilding the GT3 cup cars here, so he knew his way around the GT3. There was also a nice black Carerra GT on the workshop floor. He said it's best to change the fuel filter as the engine was out, easy access. Also he said everything else inc engine mounts was in good order, nothing else needed to be done.
I told him to check the diff when the car's rebuilt, nothing really more to add - they need to get hold of a pressure plate (friction plate and release bearing in stock), and then rebuild it all back up again.
Will push for a discount on the parts, but other than that they did what I asked and made me feel like the car's in good hands. Must be what it's like to deal with Reading from the reports I've read on here, makes a big difference to have someone who knows his stuff look after your car rather than a 18yr old spotty pleb. At least I know who to deal with next time the car goes to OPC!
Will update if any more problems or when I get the car back, looks like it will be thick end of next week at earliest or the week after most likely. Cayenne S and "lets..............OFFROAD" till then!
Popolou said:
Reading tend to have a good write up but I still don't see why it was an engine out job - did they say?
My car is @ OPC Dubai.Didn't say why it was an engine out job, but they took it out anyway!
Surely it must say in the Porsche service manuals that it's an engine out job, otherwise why would they do it?
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


