Boxster 3.2S to 911 (930 or 996...???)
Boxster 3.2S to 911 (930 or 996...???)
Author
Discussion

Stevej33

Original Poster:

172 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
We currently have a 54reg 3.2S and are looking to change it for a 911...

The problem we've got is "her in doors" wants a modern car, but I really fancy something 80's!

So, my problem is this: do we change it for a 996 (2000/2001 era) or a 3.2 930 ?

Its only used for low mileage, probably 1500 miles a year, so running costs shouldn't be TOO high...

(love the performance of the 3.2S, just always wanted a 911)

The Boxster will be funding the change so more expensive stuff is out of the question...

(so probably a private sale with inspection)


PGN 500sl

3,048 posts

197 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
The classics look amazing but the old school 'agricultural' feel can often stop buyers in their tracks. Personally, I love the older 911's but in contrast my pal was offered a 89 Supersport recently - he loved the looks, always lusted after an 80's 911, drove it and at that point his interest dropped off a cliff.

Drive both and you will soon make your own mind up. For what it is worth, I'd jump at a 930.

Good luck with the search.smile

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
Stevej33 said:
We currently have a 54reg 3.2S and are looking to change it for a 911...

The problem we've got is "her in doors" wants a modern car, but I really fancy something 80's!

So, my problem is this: do we change it for a 996 (2000/2001 era) or a 3.2 930 ?

Its only used for low mileage, probably 1500 miles a year, so running costs shouldn't be TOO high...

(love the performance of the 3.2S, just always wanted a 911)

The Boxster will be funding the change so more expensive stuff is out of the question...

(so probably a private sale with inspection)
You have quite a few things to discuss at home!

The 3.2 1980s car isn't a 930: The 930 is the 3.3 turbo car (1974-1989) and frankly even if you have the time to find a good one (allow yourself 12-18 months or so minimum) your wife will probably hate driving it and it will be costly to own. They are, frankly, a bit of a handful and in my opinion not that much fun to drive.

The 3.2 Carrera or 3.0SC are more docile but not like driving a modern 911. Unless your wife is used to driving "raw" cars from the 80s I'd be tempted by a 996. I'd have thought a well chosen one would be great value motoring right now.

Stevej33

Original Poster:

172 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
Sorry... Its not a Turbo we're looking for (schoolboy error on my part)

We both have day to day cars for work, so It'll only ever be used sparingly on days off!

I will be mostly using it, but not always... So gotta compromise a little!

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 21st September 2011
quotequote all
Stevej33 said:
Sorry... Its not a Turbo we're looking for (schoolboy error on my part)

We both have day to day cars for work, so It'll only ever be used sparingly on days off!

I will be mostly using it, but not always... So gotta compromise a little!
Owning a modern car (996 onwards) is very different from owning a pre-89 car. I suspect that your wife, unless she's a bit sturdy and a proper petrolhead, will end up not driving a pre-89 car. They are blokes cars really: Heavy to steer at low speeds and tail happy.


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
Manks said:
The 3.2 Carrera or 3.0SC are more docile but not like driving a modern 911. Unless your wife is used to driving "raw" cars from the 80s I'd be tempted by a 996. I'd have thought a well chosen one would be great value motoring right now.
Yep, totally agree with that. If you go down the old school route you would absolutely need to go for a proper test drive in one before embarking on any serious car hunting. They do not drive like any other car built in the last 25 years. Steering is massively heavy at parking speeds (although not too bad once you get on the road), the gear change is truly agricultural (especially earlier 915 boxes, the later G50 boxes are slightly more 'modern'), the floor mounted pedals are plain weird, the heating and ventilation is appalling, the lights and windscreen wipers are next to useless, they're noisy, thirsty (although not an issue for ultra-low mileage use) and they will happily spit you off the road if you don't stay fully focused, especially in the wet. But apart from that they are great fun to drive and provide a real sense of achievement when you arrive home in one piece smile A 996 on the other hand would be totally user friendly like your Boxster and far easier to live with on the whole. But perhaps a bit more dull. I suspect your wife will probably hate the earlier cars, I know mine does. Although she enjoys being a passenger in mine for the sound. But she's scared stiff of actually driving it.

Stevej33

Original Poster:

172 posts

224 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
Just one quick question for you guys...

Being 6'3" is the 996 more roomy than the 80's 911..?

I drove a 3.2 years ago, but was so excited to be finally driving one, I didn't take much
notice of headroom / leg room etc

boxsey

3,579 posts

241 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
As a compromise because your wife would prefer a more modern car, why don't you consider a 964 or 993? They bring power steering, ABS, etc into the equation. You will probably get a good 964 for less than a good 3.2 carrera. A 993 will be more unless you go for a very high miler. If your heart lies with the 3.2 then you just need to start working on how to bribe the Mrs! biggrin

TISPKJ

3,780 posts

238 months

Thursday 22nd September 2011
quotequote all
I wondered when the 993 would drop into the equation ...... would be my choice

Cant say on leg and headroom as never needed either :-) but the 996 is by some margin a pysically bigger car than the 993-964

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
Stevej33 said:
Just one quick question for you guys...

Being 6'3" is the 996 more roomy than the 80's 911..?

I drove a 3.2 years ago, but was so excited to be finally driving one, I didn't take much
notice of headroom / leg room etc
There is acres of headroom in an 80's 911, more so than in most modern cars as the seats sit pretty low. Also tons of legroom and the cabin feels pretty airy. The newer cars are bigger but have loads more trim and much more prominent centre consoles, door panles etc. I'm 6' 1" BTW

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
boxsey said:
As a compromise because your wife would prefer a more modern car, why don't you consider a 964 or 993? They bring power steering, ABS, etc into the equation. You will probably get a good 964 for less than a good 3.2 carrera. A 993 will be more unless you go for a very high miler. If your heart lies with the 3.2 then you just need to start working on how to bribe the Mrs! biggrin
Not a bad idea, although I find the standard 964 pretty dull in comparison to the earlier cars. It's funny how years later the 964 is considered to be more tactile than it was in the day (RS excepted). Probably because the cars that followed were so much more civilised. I haven't had much experience of the 993 other than a quick blast in a Turbo once and it was quite civilised compared to my 964RS I had at the time.

Manks

28,176 posts

253 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Also tons of legroom and the cabin feels pretty airy.
Oddly I thought the 930 felt airLESS. Possibly a combination of hard black leather sports seats and black headlining.

The IB 911 I had by contrast felt bigger inside. It wasn't of course, it just felt that way. Perhaps it was the old style standard seats, lighter head lining and brighter paintwork.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
Manks said:
Oddly I thought the 930 felt airLESS. Possibly a combination of hard black leather sports seats and black headlining.

The IB 911 I had by contrast felt bigger inside. It wasn't of course, it just felt that way. Perhaps it was the old style standard seats, lighter head lining and brighter paintwork.
Probably the black headlining I'd say. Mine feels light and airy with really good visibility all round.

boxsey

3,579 posts

241 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
boxsey said:
As a compromise because your wife would prefer a more modern car, why don't you consider a 964 or 993? They bring power steering, ABS, etc into the equation. You will probably get a good 964 for less than a good 3.2 carrera. A 993 will be more unless you go for a very high miler. If your heart lies with the 3.2 then you just need to start working on how to bribe the Mrs! biggrin
Not a bad idea, although I find the standard 964 pretty dull in comparison to the earlier cars. It's funny how years later the 964 is considered to be more tactile than it was in the day (RS excepted). Probably because the cars that followed were so much more civilised. I haven't had much experience of the 993 other than a quick blast in a Turbo once and it was quite civilised compared to my 964RS I had at the time.
Dull is certainly not a word I would use to describe the 964 driving experience but then again mine is not what anyone would call standard. biggrin

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all
boxsey said:
Dull is certainly not a word I would use to describe the 964 driving experience but then again mine is not what anyone would call standard. biggrin
I did say standard and I have driven plenty of them. I owned a 964RS for 5 years and that was anything but dull, but the standard car was not very exciting. Not compared to the earlier cars anyway. But still a good compromise between old and new school Porsche I think

Stevej33

Original Poster:

172 posts

224 months

Friday 23rd September 2011
quotequote all

Now I'm even more confused.......

I think if I went older, the good lady would leave more of the Sunday driving to me though!!

(good plan I recon')

Always loved the 80's 3.2 styling too.

But those 996 look such good value for money right now...


anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 24th September 2011
quotequote all
Stevej33 said:
Always loved the 80's 3.2 styling too.
If you go down that route, don't rule out the 3.0 SC either. They look exactly the same for all intents and are if anything slightly more focused as a driver's car. They're also generally cheaper to buy although many have been badly neglected over the years as have a fair few C3.2s.

Go across to the Impactbumpers forum for the best advice on the various 80's 911s. Condition of individual cars is everything with these cars and a good example of any 80's 911 would make a great driver's car. But I'd put money on that your wife would hate driving it!!

Stevej33

Original Poster:

172 posts

224 months

Saturday 24th September 2011
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Stevej33 said:
Always loved the 80's 3.2 styling too.
If you go down that route, don't rule out the 3.0 SC either. They look exactly the same for all intents and are if anything slightly more focused as a driver's car. They're also generally cheaper to buy although many have been badly neglected over the years as have a fair few C3.2s.

Go across to the Impactbumpers forum for the best advice on the various 80's 911s. Condition of individual cars is everything with these cars and a good example of any 80's 911 would make a great driver's car. But I'd put money on that your wife would hate driving it!!
Sound advise, thank you...

(means I get to drive it more though!! Result)