HPI and logbook.
Author
Discussion

911fan

Original Poster:

438 posts

291 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
Query: is it an issue if an HPI check shows eg 2 owners, but the logbook shows 1?

Reason for asking: a private owner, "Mr Jones", has transferred ownership to his company, "LTD" which is revealed by HPI, as Mr Jones first owner, then LTD as second owner, whereas logbook still only reflects Mr Jones.

normal, or dodgy?

BertBert

21,328 posts

242 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
Well for a start, the V5 shows keepers, not owners. In the same way so does HPI. Assume it's keepers that are being talked about, then it's odd for the two not to match. It means the change of keeper has happened without using the V5. Or there is a duplicate V5 somewhere in the mix.

If you are satisfied that the keeper situation is above board, then it's not the worst thing in the world.

What does Mr Thingy say about it and how does he explain how the keeper change took place?

Bert

chris7676

2,685 posts

251 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
As normal/dodgy as HPI and DVLA...
Mine Eunos (Japanese MX5) had the HPI saying it has never been imported...

911fan

Original Poster:

438 posts

291 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
BertBert said:
Well for a start, the V5 shows keepers, not owners. In the same way so does HPI. Assume it's keepers that are being talked about, then it's odd for the two not to match. It means the change of keeper has happened without using the V5. Or there is a duplicate V5 somewhere in the mix.

If you are satisfied that the keeper situation is above board, then it's not the worst thing in the world.

What does Mr Thingy say about it and how does he explain how the keeper change took place?

Bert
Mr Jones is being candid and says it was to get his insurance premium down due to him being almost banned from driving.

911fan

Original Poster:

438 posts

291 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
911fan said:
Query: is it an issue if an HPI check shows eg 2 owners, but the logbook shows 1?

Reason for asking: a private owner, "Mr Jones", has transferred ownership to his company, "LTD" which is revealed by HPI, as Mr Jones first owner, then LTD as second owner, whereas logbook still only reflects Mr Jones.

normal, or dodgy?
is this a frequent occurance please?

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Wednesday 7th December 2011
quotequote all
Have you checked that it's the current V5C you're looking at, and hence the valid one?

Go to www.vehiclelicence.gov.uk click "vehicle enquiry" then "next" then enter the reg, choose the make and then enter the V5C reference number, then click "next". If the ref no entered is from the most up to date V5C then the results (which include date of first reg, colour, capacity, road tax/SORN expiry date and tax cost) will show the same date of issue as shown on the document - if it doesn't return a date than the V5C is not the most up to date, valid, one - in which case you need to find out where it is.

My guess is that you're looking at a no longer valid V5C if it doesn't have enough keepers on it. smile

911fan

Original Poster:

438 posts

291 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
thegoose said:
Have you checked that it's the current V5C you're looking at, and hence the valid one?

Go to www.vehiclelicence.gov.uk click "vehicle enquiry" then "next" then enter the reg, choose the make and then enter the V5C reference number, then click "next". If the ref no entered is from the most up to date V5C then the results (which include date of first reg, colour, capacity, road tax/SORN expiry date and tax cost) will show the same date of issue as shown on the document - if it doesn't return a date than the V5C is not the most up to date, valid, one - in which case you need to find out where it is.

My guess is that you're looking at a no longer valid V5C if it doesn't have enough keepers on it. smile
Cheers. It seems to be the right one but number still doesn't match; i wonder what's going on?

Magic919

14,583 posts

232 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
So are you saying V5 states number of former keepers = 0?

911fan

Original Poster:

438 posts

291 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
Magic919 said:
So are you saying V5 states number of former keepers = 0?
it says 1 owner but hpi says 2; 1st is an individual 2nd is his company.

Magic919

14,583 posts

232 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
Ok. V5 doesn't say owners. It lists number of former keepers. Former keepers. I buy a car new, sell it to you. It says 1 former keeper. Is this any different?

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
'number still doesn't match' is confusing

Did the reference number in the online check match the paper document produced by the purported seller? Did it give a date of issue?



Given HPI and purported seller both suggest a transfer has occured the paper document produced certainly appears to be out of date.

The distinction between keeper / owner doesn't seem to offer any explanation here.

I wouldn't assume the purported seller is being at all 'candid'. Tread carefully.

MrCooke

796 posts

226 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
[quote]it says 1 owner but hpi says 2; 1st is an individual 2nd is his company.
[/quote]

Is this just simple confusion between the V5 showing number of FORMER keepers and the HPI showing TOTAL keepers?

1 former keeper plus 1 current keeper = 2 keepers...

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Thursday 8th December 2011
quotequote all
911fan said:
thegoose said:
Have you checked that it's the current V5C you're looking at, and hence the valid one?

Go to www.vehiclelicence.gov.uk click "vehicle enquiry" then "next" then enter the reg, choose the make and then enter the V5C reference number, then click "next". If the ref no entered is from the most up to date V5C then the results (which include date of first reg, colour, capacity, road tax/SORN expiry date and tax cost) will show the same date of issue as shown on the document - if it doesn't return a date than the V5C is not the most up to date, valid, one - in which case you need to find out where it is.

My guess is that you're looking at a no longer valid V5C if it doesn't have enough keepers on it. smile
Cheers. It seems to be the right one but number still doesn't match; i wonder what's going on?
That sounds like you're contradicting yourself? If you enter the doc ref no and it doesn't give an issue date in the results then you have taken the doc ref no from an out of date, invalid, V5C. Find the correct one and try again or get the current registered keeper to apply for a duplicate - this can be done by phone (£25 payment required) and will arrive in 2/3/4 days. If they're not prepared to do this then you're taking a big risk buying the car - you may have a car that purports to be ABC car but in reality you have no documentary evidence of this i.e. it could be a stolen car with a VIN grafted on being sold with an out of date V5C that isn't worth the paper it's printed on.

I've often had cars with 2 V5C's where the owner has had a new one issued and not binned the old one - if someone got hold of one of these all they have to do is steal a similar car, re-identify it and they have a genuine V5C for it (but out of date and invalid of course) which most people will think is kosher. I have of course always destroyed the out of date document.

There is another way to check the V5C but it's not free. As part of an HPi check you can specify that you want a V5C check and you will then have to enter the serial no which appears in the white disc in the top right corner of the front page of the V5C (this number is never used by anyone other than HPi AFAIK), along with the date of issue, shown next to the doc ref no on the other pages. The HPi check will then confirm whether the V5C is the valid one.

Stevej33

172 posts

224 months

Saturday 17th December 2011
quotequote all
MrCooke said:
1 former keeper plus 1 current keeper = 2 keepers...
That's where most people make mistakes...

The V5 doesn't state "total" keepers, just "previous" keepers PLUS the current registered keeper!