Do I need Porsche battery?
Do I need Porsche battery?
Author
Discussion

royobannan

Original Poster:

131 posts

223 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
Quick question. My battery is completely dead. Porsche want £335 or halfords for their best £135. Is the Porsche one worth it?

Johnboy Mac

2,666 posts

209 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
No you don't need a Porsche branded battery. What price is a Bosch one?

royobannan

Original Poster:

131 posts

223 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
£135 from halfords with fitting

Steve_T

6,356 posts

303 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
Costco a bit cheaper if you want a Bosch one.

Nano2nd

3,426 posts

287 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
have you got extended warranty with Porsche? if yes then you do need a porsche one, thouhg make sure you ask for a discount on the £335

royobannan

Original Poster:

131 posts

223 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice! No porsche warranty to think about. The RAC guy put in a bosch silver one for £120 which seemed reasonable!

m3evo321

149 posts

258 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
Porsche want £335


!!!!!!!!!!!THAT IS JUST CRIMINAL!!!!!!!!!!!!

MATT993

28 posts

179 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
COSTCO, Bosch Silver, fitted on to my 993 a couple of weeks ago.
Can't remember the exact price, but less than £100 I think.

rhkumar

164 posts

187 months

Wednesday 7th March 2012
quotequote all
Cheapest place is Eurocarparts. Just purchased S5 Bosch for £100.

rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
Nano2nd said:
have you got extended warranty with Porsche? if yes then you do need a porsche one, thouhg make sure you ask for a discount on the £335
Not quite! "You can fit a non-standard battery, but risk invalidating any future claim linked to fitting such non-standard item." So said my OPC. But of course, always check with your own as not all OPCs seem to be the same!

Popolou

1,269 posts

238 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
Yup, Bosch S5 all the way. IIRC, rated a little higher than the Porsche Moll battery with a noticeable oomph in cranking.

Ekona

1,685 posts

233 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
rog007 said:
Nano2nd said:
have you got extended warranty with Porsche? if yes then you do need a porsche one, thouhg make sure you ask for a discount on the £335
Not quite! "You can fit a non-standard battery, but risk invalidating any future claim linked to fitting such non-standard item." So said my OPC. But of course, always check with your own as not all OPCs seem to be the same!
Not quite again wink That only applies to a brand new car under EU block exemption rules. The OPC have no control over the terms of the extended warranty, and using a non-Porsche battery will void the entire thing.

E30M3SE

8,493 posts

227 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
rhkumar said:
Cheapest place is Eurocarparts. Just purchased S5 Bosch for £100.
Should've tried these guys

londonagent

635 posts

199 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
I bought a Bosch S5 from Nipparts for £68 last month

gsewell

724 posts

314 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
Ekona said:
rog007 said:
Nano2nd said:
have you got extended warranty with Porsche? if yes then you do need a porsche one, thouhg make sure you ask for a discount on the £335
Not quite! "You can fit a non-standard battery, but risk invalidating any future claim linked to fitting such non-standard item." So said my OPC. But of course, always check with your own as not all OPCs seem to be the same!
Not quite again wink That only applies to a brand new car under EU block exemption rules. The OPC have no control over the terms of the extended warranty, and using a non-Porsche battery will void the entire thing.
OK, so I get the block exemption thing for the manufacturers guarantee. So how would this affect things if I changed the battery in the first 2 years (under block exemption). Would that still invalidate the 3rd year insurance based warranty?

rog007

5,832 posts

255 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
Ekona said:
rog007 said:
Nano2nd said:
have you got extended warranty with Porsche? if yes then you do need a porsche one, thouhg make sure you ask for a discount on the £335
Not quite! "You can fit a non-standard battery, but risk invalidating any future claim linked to fitting such non-standard item." So said my OPC. But of course, always check with your own as not all OPCs seem to be the same!
Not quite again wink That only applies to a brand new car under EU block exemption rules. The OPC have no control over the terms of the extended warranty, and using a non-Porsche battery will void the entire thing.
Not quite again and again (is that right?). I was on extended warranty; OPC was quite clear that if I fitted, and I was allowed to, a non-Porsche battery, it did not invalidate my warranty per se. But it may invalidate it if any subsequent claim was as a direct result of that non-standard item being on the car. That's wot e sed! Anyway, I chickened out and fitted a Porsche battery!!

Ekona

1,685 posts

233 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
They're wrong. OPC don't underwrite the warranty, and I can promise you if the engine went pop and there was a non-Porsche battery in there, they wouldn't pay out a thing. It's all in the warranty booklet, and sadly even the nicest Aamd best-meaning OPC person can't override the contractual terms of that.

mohitos

1,313 posts

230 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
Here's the trick. Call Porsche's breakdown assistance. Tell them the battery has died and it needs replacing. They will collect a battery from the OPC, fit it, and I think it was about £200, way cheaper than if you were to go directly to the OPC. Check the prices it that was the situation a couple of years ago. Odd but true!!

Wilkoj

11 posts

176 months

Thursday 8th March 2012
quotequote all
or fit any battery you like and keep the original Porsche one.
If the engine goes pop, get towed home then swap battery and call recovery again to tow to dealers.

Nano2nd

3,426 posts

287 months

Friday 9th March 2012
quotequote all
Wilkoj said:
or fit any battery you like and keep the original Porsche one.
If the engine goes pop, get towed home then swap battery and call recovery again to tow to dealers.
or just buy the porsche battery and save all the hassle (and fraud) okay its overpriced which sucks, but you did buy a Porsche rather than a Ford