So do I buy a 997 gt3 or get another 996 gt3 and save £20k?
So do I buy a 997 gt3 or get another 996 gt3 and save £20k?
Author
Discussion

lucky no 7

Original Poster:

16 posts

165 months

Wednesday 26th December 2012
quotequote all
I have money in the bank and time off work, nothing other to do than look for another car then!! my 996 gt3 got stolen and written off earlier in the year and its now time to get another car.

I love the look of the 997 GT3's but worry they are still going to loss £5 plus k per year with ease? They are also £20k more than a sorted 996 gt3..The 997 clubsport I wanted and was going to close a deal on tomorrow it now seems may have a murky past.. Is it therefore better to stick with the 996 gt3 and get a real nice one such as the red one at rpm? or yellow one at dovecourt? subject to a wright tune check over?

any ideas as its doing my head in now... even thought about a 996 rs at JZM. The way I see it is that the RS and even the 996 gt3 were made in a lot less numbers than the 997, do you think they are at the point now of holding value? I had a 993 for over a year and a half, just sold it and lost £1000 in that time....

fire away!!

agtlaw

7,394 posts

235 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Best 'investment' of the cars mentioned would be a 996 RS. Perhaps think about a 996 GT2 or a 993 turbo if your main concern is depreciation. Take your DME analysis kit if you're visiting JZM for an RS.

My crystal ball says that a 997 GT3 will be £35-40k in a couple of years.

lucky no 7

Original Poster:

16 posts

165 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
agtlaw. thank you Sir for you advice.

I too have a feeling the 997 will dip sub £40 in a couple of years max, big hit to take.. though what a nice looking car, I will need finance to buy one so it is a double hit really. I think I will just get another 996 GT3, I really don't do that many miles a year in my cars so it makes the most sense. I just hope the Dove house one does have aircon as per the ad as I do like the look of that one... keen on the red one at rpm too. My old gt3 was silver and so want to get a different colour.

mind you mr 911;'s red and white rs sub £50 looks good too!!

thanks


x12yhp

903 posts

217 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
I'd say it depends on what you want the car for. If you really do want to go tracking it and going as fast as you can then surely the 997 is the best bet. If you are looking for something special but not so fussed on the track then the 996 will probably hit the mark and save you a whole load of cash.

lucky no 7

Original Poster:

16 posts

165 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Yes I see your point, its more just for letting of steam from work and driving to our house in France .. Gt2 would probably suit the latter but I prefer the look of the gt3.

I am a bit of a tart though, I like the idea of the newer model but not the cost!! easy to get carried away with these things and panic later on!

cheers

x12yhp

903 posts

217 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
My big thing against the GT2 (also remember I have not driven one...) is that they are all boring looking! There are plenty of GT3s in nice colours or with graphics on them... GT2s seem to be super bland!

acf69

407 posts

200 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
I went through a similar thought process myself earlier in the year except the choices were a 996TT or 997TT. I ended up deciding the difference in price just was not worth it for me as it's a second car. I haven't regretted my choice for one minute and know I can upgrade to a newer car another day if I want to

Slippydiff

16,341 posts

252 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
lucky no 7 said:
I too have a feeling the 997 will dip sub £40 in a couple of years max, big hit to take.. though what a nice looking car, I will need finance to buy one so it is a double hit really. I think I will just get another 996 GT3, I really don't do that many miles a year in my cars so it makes the most sense. I just hope the Dove house one does have aircon as per the ad as I do like the look of that one... keen on the red one at rpm too. My old gt3 was silver and so want to get a different colour.
I can only speak as a polisher of these cars biglaugh But the yellow Dove House car won't have air con.

This picture of it's engine bay shows no air con pipes routed to an air con compressor :



Whereas in this picture they're clearly visible and I've highlighted them with a red marker :



The Dove House cars heater control also indicate it has no air con (or manual air con rather than automatic climate control) but on the basis of the lack of compressor, I suspect it has none whatsoever.

jackwood

2,963 posts

237 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
x12yhp said:
I'd say it depends on what you want the car for. If you really do want to go tracking it and going as fast as you can then surely the 997 is the best bet. If you are looking for something special but not so fussed on the track then the 996 will probably hit the mark and save you a whole load of cash.
I'm surprised that nobody has contradicted you on this yet. With its passive suspension and small difference in performance the 996 is often regarded as the better track car.

terryb

1,008 posts

273 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
lucky no 7 said:
I have money in the bank and time off work, nothing other to do than look for another car then!! my 996 gt3 got stolen and written off earlier in the year and its now time to get another car.

I love the look of the 997 GT3's but worry they are still going to loss £5 plus k per year with ease? They are also £20k more than a sorted 996 gt3..The 997 clubsport I wanted and was going to close a deal on tomorrow it now seems may have a murky past.. Is it therefore better to stick with the 996 gt3 and get a real nice one such as the red one at rpm? or yellow one at dovecourt? subject to a wright tune check over?

any ideas as its doing my head in now... even thought about a 996 rs at JZM. The way I see it is that the RS and even the 996 gt3 were made in a lot less numbers than the 997, do you think they are at the point now of holding value? I had a 993 for over a year and a half, just sold it and lost £1000 in that time....

fire away!!
If you're concerned about depreciation hen stay away from a 997 GT3 for now. I'm sure it's a buyers market at the moment so could probably do a good deal on any cars for sale. For your needs, I'd suggest a 996 and buy on condition, rather than history/ mileage. Get a proper PPI too and then go and have some fun smile

By the sound of it, you still have unfinished business with the 996 GT3, as it takes a year or 2 to learn how to get the best out of them smile

terryb

1,008 posts

273 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
If you're looking for inspiration smile


HoHoHo

15,398 posts

279 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
terryb said:
lucky no 7 said:
I have money in the bank and time off work, nothing other to do than look for another car then!! my 996 gt3 got stolen and written off earlier in the year and its now time to get another car.

I love the look of the 997 GT3's but worry they are still going to loss £5 plus k per year with ease? They are also £20k more than a sorted 996 gt3..The 997 clubsport I wanted and was going to close a deal on tomorrow it now seems may have a murky past.. Is it therefore better to stick with the 996 gt3 and get a real nice one such as the red one at rpm? or yellow one at dovecourt? subject to a wright tune check over?

any ideas as its doing my head in now... even thought about a 996 rs at JZM. The way I see it is that the RS and even the 996 gt3 were made in a lot less numbers than the 997, do you think they are at the point now of holding value? I had a 993 for over a year and a half, just sold it and lost £1000 in that time....

fire away!!
If you're concerned about depreciation hen stay away from a 997 GT3 for now. I'm sure it's a buyers market at the moment so could probably do a good deal on any cars for sale. For your needs, I'd suggest a 996 and buy on condition, rather than history/ mileage. Get a proper PPI too and then go and have some fun smile

By the sound of it, you still have unfinished business with the 996 GT3, as it takes a year or 2 to learn how to get the best out of them smile
If you're worried about depreciation stay away from Porsche full stop based on a number of threads on the 996 and 997 recently wink

nxi20

786 posts

234 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
If you can wait for a month or so, I know of a very good 996.1 Clubsport that will be available then; well, he keeps on saying it's going to be anyway smile

bridey0

2,961 posts

214 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Take your DME analysis kit if you're visiting JZM for an RS.

Whats this mean?

terryb

1,008 posts

273 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
Don't listen to the scaremongering. Your money is safe is a good value 996GT3

bridey0

2,961 posts

214 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
terryb said:
Don't listen to the scaremongering. Your money is safe is a good value 996GT3
but an RS or regular gt3?? JZM are prob the best out there no?

marky911

4,433 posts

248 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
bridey0 said:


Whats this mean?
According to AGTlaw the white/red RS at JZM has a lot of over-revs recorded.

bridey0

2,961 posts

214 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
marky911 said:
According to AGTlaw the white/red RS at JZM has a lot of over-revs recorded.
Sure but that would be available to see from JZM surely?

agtlaw

7,394 posts

235 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
36471 range 1 and 274 range 2, both at 853 hrs. Total operating hours 861.

It you don't ask, you don't get.

bridey0

2,961 posts

214 months

Thursday 27th December 2012
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
36471 range 1 and 274 range 2, both at 853 hrs. Total operating hours 861.

It you don't ask, you don't get.
i wish i knew what that meant!