Porsche Macan, opinions please
Porsche Macan, opinions please
Author
Discussion

Nigel Worc's

Original Poster:

8,121 posts

210 months

Monday 7th January 2019
quotequote all
What ho chaps

Just a quick request for feedback, my mate is looking at Macan models

May I ask for any advice/ feedback on these cars please ?

Plus points, bad points, any issues, things to look out for ?

This is the kind of thing he is looking at :

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201...

Many thanks in advance

Cheib

25,002 posts

197 months

Monday 7th January 2019
quotequote all
Link appears to be broken!

If he’s looking at a Diesel read up on DPF issues...apparently not suitable for frequent short journeys because filter doesn’t get up to temp.

I’ve got a Turbo PP which I love. Sweet spot in the range is the GTS. The 2.0 petrol cars lack a bit because they engine is a but ordinary IMHO but you get the Macan quality and chassis which is second to none in its class.

m88ony

337 posts

123 months

Monday 7th January 2019
quotequote all
I have had a Macan S Diesel for over 3 years for the Mrs. Great car. Never had an issue with it.

Trevor555

5,056 posts

106 months

Monday 7th January 2019
quotequote all
We had a GTS for a short while.

Lovely thing, but only thing that disappointed us was the rain water going into the boot.

Open the tailgate in the rain, or with dew on it, and it drips down, and some goes into the boot over my wifes school books.

Service manager said they know about it, characteristic of the car sir.

Well worth having the full leather option.

You then get the whole of the door card in leather, with the stitching going along the top of the panel.

Personal thing I know, but I wouldn't buy one without that.

Enjoy, lovely cars.

W12GT

4,220 posts

243 months

Tuesday 8th January 2019
quotequote all
Absolutely love my turbo - it does everything so well and is incredibly capable. I tried both diesel variants and the 2.0 petrol and found all lacking in the power I was looking for. The Macan S is a great car but for me the Turbo performance and residuals made sense, the mpg is pretty bad though. I don’t know what I’d swap it for; I’m considering a Rapide or Giulia Quadrifoglio but need to try and get some long test drives before I make final decision. Have a suspicion this will be staying a while though.

notsomadmick

175 posts

182 months

Tuesday 8th January 2019
quotequote all
I've had 6 Macans. 2 DS and 4 GTS. I've owned a lot of cars over the years. 15 of them Porsches. I drive fast when it is safe to do so. The Macan GTS - with PASM, PTV+, 20 inch Spyder wheels and 18-way seats is the most complete vehicle you can ever buy. It does more things in one package than any other car can. It's almost a sports car, it can take the dogs, the kids, and goes round corners in a way that defies belief - certainly for an SUV anyway. Don't bother with the sunroof - unless you need it. Full leather is nice to have if you can. Don't bother with air suspension, you loose feel. Don't waste your money on Bose. It's no better than the standard set up - and steals useful floor space in the boot. LEDs are nice to have, but not a deal breaker. The 3.0 DS in similar spec is still a great car. You don't really need a turbo version unless cash is of no concern. Dip you bread it's a buyers market at the moment.

Porsche911R

21,146 posts

287 months

Tuesday 8th January 2019
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
What ho chaps

Just a quick request for feedback, my mate is looking at Macan models

May I ask for any advice/ feedback on these cars please ?


Many thanks in advance
Why does he want an SUV ? They do nothing well ?

So my advice is talk him out of it :-)

Koln-RS

4,080 posts

234 months

Tuesday 8th January 2019
quotequote all
Whilst the Macan is not a true Porsche sports car, it is hard to fault as luxury, sporting SUV. If he really needs a versatile 4/5 seater, then he won't be disappointed - but its not a 911 or a Cayman.

I've driven several variants, but not the latest 'facelift' model, and they are all good in different ways. The GTS sounds lovely, but quite thirsty. The DS also sounds pretty good with the sports exhaust, very good mid-range power delivery and will do a genuine 40 mpg.

Nicest options are the sports seats (18 way), Air Suspension and PASM for the best ride/handling, I wouldn't go above 20" wheels, panoramic roof is popular.

Yellow491

3,358 posts

141 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Porsche911R said:
Nigel Worc's said:
What ho chaps

Just a quick request for feedback, my mate is looking at Macan models

May I ask for any advice/ feedback on these cars please ?


Many thanks in advance
Why does he want an SUV ? They do nothing well ?

So my advice is talk him out of it :-)
Dont listen to the r twoddle
Get one,the petrol versions are gutsy on fuel,diesel are brilliant.
Not much room in a macan but the cayenne is great,they aint no sports car though.I had a tourag for 5 years,the cayenne is on a differant level especialy towing with air suspension etc

W12GT

4,220 posts

243 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
W12GT said:
Absolutely love my turbo - it does everything so well and is incredibly capable. I tried both diesel variants and the 2.0 petrol and found all lacking in the power I was looking for. The Macan S is a great car but for me the Turbo performance and residuals made sense, the mpg is pretty bad though. I don’t know what I’d swap it for; I’m considering a Rapide or Giulia Quadrifoglio but need to try and get some long test drives before I make final decision. Have a suspicion this will be staying a while though.
Forgot to say the PDSL is really useful, 18way seat are superb and by far the best seats I’ve ever sat in - and that includes the Bentley!

Two things that are annoying - the door mirrors don’t dip down far enough to see the kerb which is a PITA when parking, also the rear view camera needs cleaning regularly as it collextsnalot of road dirt. I genuinely can’t think of anything else that I don’t like.

GT4RS

4,999 posts

219 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
On the third one, perfect everyday car.

My only advice would be get a gts rather than the diesel, IMO they drive far better.

GT4RS

4,999 posts

219 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Porsche911R said:
Nigel Worc's said:
What ho chaps

Just a quick request for feedback, my mate is looking at Macan models

May I ask for any advice/ feedback on these cars please ?


Many thanks in advance
Why does he want an SUV ? They do nothing well ?

So my advice is talk him out of it :-)
What a complete tool!

Porsche911R

21,146 posts

287 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Yellow491 said:
Dont listen to the r twoddle
Get one,the petrol versions are gutsy on fuel,diesel are brilliant.
Not much room in a macan but the cayenne is great,they aint no sports car though.I had a tourag for 5 years,the cayenne is on a differant level especialy towing with air suspension etc
So don’t listen to me but don’t buy one lol classic