996 C2 or C4S

[jimbo22]

C4S's are now coming into £40k price territory and was wondering what people's opinions are on them?

Had my heart set on a 3.6 C2 with PSM but should I be considering these as well? I wasn't a big fan of a C4 (just preffered the front end on the C2) but does the track and suspension changes on the S make a big enough difference to start considering one?

[Rob_T]

to be blunt i would go for a c4s simply because it is the best looking of the n/a 996 imo.

never driven a c2, but the c4s i owned was lovely. big fat arches, 295's or the rear, turbo brakes and 4 wheel drive meant you had to work hard to lose it.

why don't you drive both and decide on that basis.

[rob05]

Its a long standing topic here on phers, i agree try them both.
My opinon is the C2 as for the C4,i hated it,maybe the 997 model will be better