New Porsche - Oil Change Necessary?
New Porsche - Oil Change Necessary?
Author
Discussion

hutchingsp

Original Poster:

68,623 posts

241 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
Thought I'd start a separate thread on this as I've seen it pop up on numerous threads including my own.

I have a MY07 987 with just over 3k on the clock. Obviously the first service isn't due until 20k miles.

Should I change the oil now?

There seem to be two schools of thought (I'm paraphrasing specific comments but they kind of sum the two up):

One is "you spent £x on a new car so what's £150 or so for an oil change to get all the run-in crap out the engine"

The other is "Porsche bench test every engine for a few hundred miles equivalent which flushes any crap out, so they've run it in for you".

Which is right?

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
Personally I would do an oil (and filter) change after about 1500 miles on any new car if it has been bench tested or not.

Other than that it would depend how you use the car. I change my oil after every 2-3 track days or every 5-7K road miles but then mine only really gets taken out to be driven 'enthusiastically' on the weekends.

Even with the advances in oil technology I wouldnt like to leave the same oil in for 20,000 miles. For everyday driving I would change every 10K miles at least.

I use Silkolene Pro Race Oil in my car which lasts about 2-3 times as long in track situations as regular synthetic oil before it starts to shear.

Some good info in the stickied thread from oilman (Opie Oils) in general gassing.




anglebox10

2,733 posts

242 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
Personally I wouldn't disagree with changing the oil that early. All I would say is when I picked my car up from the factory a few years ago, they told me there was no need to, as they'd already done it.
They must be pretty confident as regards the warranty side of things, otherwise I don't see why they wouldn't insist it was done. After all it's not an unreasonable stipulation for them to impose,if it was actually required.

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
I have a MY07 987 with just over 3k on the clock. Obviously the first service isn't due until 20k miles.

Should I change the oil now?
Yes.

singh911

957 posts

272 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
Watch out for OPC oil changes if you ask them to do it.

My opc tech told me they don't change oil filters on a 12k service which was shock horror to me. And if you take your 3k porsche to the opc for an oil change, they'll do just that unless you tell them to change filter too.

seems madness to ever change oil and leave the old filter

Ajit

Defo oil change if i were you. ask the opc tech to show you the oil or be there when its done and you'll see that you were right

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
Globulator said:
hutchingsp said:
I have a MY07 987 with just over 3k on the clock. Obviously the first service isn't due until 20k miles.

Should I change the oil now?
Yes.
I'll second that. You CANNOT change oil too frequently.


Oli.

997gt3

3,139 posts

245 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
zcacogp said:
You CANNOT change oil too frequently.

Oli.

Once a week!??? rolleyes

singh911

957 posts

272 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
997gt3 said:
zcacogp said:
You CANNOT change oil too frequently.

Oli.

Once a week!??? rolleyes


I guess if he does five trackdays in the week...

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
997gt3 said:
zcacogp said:
You CANNOT change oil too frequently.

Oli.

Once a week!??? rolleyes
If you can afford it, more frequently.


Oli.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Saturday 9th December 2006
quotequote all
Article in Evo this month on oil changes and are there really oils which can do 20,000 miles in a modern performance engine.

Basic position is the manufacturer wouldnt specify changes at 20,000 miles if the oil couldnt do it.

It does go on to say though that in all the testimonials of people whose cars have done huge (500K+) mileages they have changed oil every 3000 miles regularly.

If you give your car some stick then I think you should change every 5000 miles at least. A lot more with trackdays (about 8 hours track use max)

9hellheaven

1,595 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th December 2006
quotequote all
I think you change the oil to a large extent by topping up! My 997s burns a bit I believe by design. While i have not kept a record I reckon I have fed it a couple of litres or so in the first 4800 miles. The oil consumption will I think reduce with miles put on the motor at about plus 10 to 15 thousand. Its more than likely that the technology exists more in the filter than the oil. That said I will change my own oil and filter at 5k or 1 year. Oil is the life blood of both reliabilty and a long life for these engines in my opinion.

southwesteleven

3 posts

228 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
I have a similar quandry. I have just bought a 2006 987 Boxster which has done 7k miles. I rang OPC in Chiswick and asked about an oil change and they spoke to me like I was mad. My car is now 18 months old and has never been back to the garage so I think I will get an oil change done regardless of what the OPC says.

pikey

7,704 posts

315 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
hutchingsp said:
I have a MY07 987 with just over 3k on the clock. Obviously the first service isn't due until 20k miles.

Should I change the oil now?
No.

Confused? hehe

I had a Cayman S that they said "no need", when it was 12months old I tried again and was told "no need". In the end, at 18 months old & 15,000 miles I booked it in for it's 2 year, 20k service because I couldn't understand how it could do that!

My take is if it needed an earlier change, then they'd say so. It's in their interest.

Dr S

5,163 posts

257 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
anglebox10 said:
They must be pretty confident as regards the warranty side of things, otherwise I don't see why they wouldn't insist it was done.
Of course they are confident as warranty claims do not exisit, it's all down to driver abuse as you know...wink

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
I would, but then I also get a kind of strange pleasure out of an oil change. I love seeing the old stuff drain out. It's just a delight pouring in lovely, clear gold stuff. The money I spend on oil changes is the equivalent to the money some people would spend on nice bottles of wine. I get the same pleasure! And I don't care what anyone says, they are faster and smoother after an oil change, heheheh. driving

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
I would, but then I also get a kind of strange pleasure out of an oil change. I love seeing the old stuff drain out. It's just a delight pouring in lovely, clear gold stuff. The money I spend on oil changes is the equivalent to the money some people would spend on nice bottles of wine. I get the same pleasure! And I don't care what anyone says, they are faster and smoother after an oil change, heheheh. driving
It also empties out all the swarf from the bedding in process.

Stealth997

388 posts

239 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
hutchingsp said:
I have a MY07 987 with just over 3k on the clock. Obviously the first service isn't due until 20k miles.

Should I change the oil now?
No.

Confused? hehe

I had a Cayman S that they said "no need", when it was 12months old I tried again and was told "no need". In the end, at 18 months old & 15,000 miles I booked it in for it's 2 year, 20k service because I couldn't understand how it could do that!

My take is if it needed an earlier change, then they'd say so. It's in their interest.
Why do you think they make the first service interval at 2 years? Surely it's because they want you not to bother and trade in for another new one? In my cynical opinion, they dont care about the long-term well being of your car. An oil change can only be a good thing!

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
Every 5000 miles or 1 year. Any more often on a production engine and you're just spending money for the sake of it with nothing in return.

pikey

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
Stealth997 said:
Why do you think they make the first service interval at 2 years?
Maximum 2 years or 20,000 miles - the computer will tell you the actual point necessary.

Stealth997 said:
Surely it's because they want you not to bother and trade in for another new one? In my cynical opinion, they dont care about the long-term well being of your car.
Disagree.

They'll extend the warranty to 10 years or 125,000 miles - how many other sports car companies will do that? They clearly have a huge amount of faith in the long term reliability of them or they'd cap the warranty extension much lower. How many 911s around with monster mileage compared to... well ANYTHING?! It's all well made, good stuff.


RT

919 posts

276 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
There is some evidence that oils themselves have a run-in period before they lubricate optimally, so I disagree with the statement that you can't change oil too often.

For me annually or abour 6k miles (with a filter change) makes sense.

I cannot for the life of me fathom out why Porsche don't recommend a filter change - it's only a few quid for the element FFS!