Dilemma - 996 C4S or 997 C2 or C2S
Dilemma - 996 C4S or 997 C2 or C2S
Author
Discussion

Dalton

Original Poster:

15 posts

233 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Hello,

Hope you may provide me with some advise.

Been lurking for a while and at the same time looking to buy my first Porsche.

Really like the look of the 996 C4S, have considered a late one with low mileage and a decent spec, however we are talking about £50k here so the dilemma is to go for the C4S or an early 997 with a few more miles on the clock than say the C4S has. I probably prefer the S version over the standard Carerra.

What do you reckon, mostly this will be my daily car so I guess the 997 suits better with the extended service intervals for example, however I can't get the look of the C4S out of my head.

Any advice would be really appreciated.

Dalton

Wanta996

5,622 posts

238 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
I am in the same boat, C4S is a beautiful looking car but not worth a penny more than £45k IMO and the increase in its weight means it also drinks more fuel than the standard 997 especially if you are going to use it as a daily drive. Also having those beautiful Turbo look Alloys comes with Turbo Brake Pads/Disks costs which your OPC will gladly take approx £1200 for changing them.

I think that the 997 is a better car in most ways to the to the 996 from the interior to the finish and i would think that it will hold its value allot better - You find the odd 2002 C4S at £37k on the Autotrader but its hard to find a 997 under £45k at the moment. 997 S's seem to be at £48-£52K privately.

Latter 2004 C4S's also came with the increased service intervals i think?? (according to a salesman they do anyway)
If your budget is upto £50k then buy a 997. No doubt a fellow Pistonheader will advise a 996 Turbo as there are plenty to be had at £50k.

Thorny

1,076 posts

241 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Go for the 997 - quicker and much nicer interior IMO - and you're getting a newer car...

s99ane

1,262 posts

265 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Hey WANNA you not put your hand in your pocket yet and bought a car? Just get out there and do the deed!

30121980

1,930 posts

239 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Just to add, i sold my 997 c2s a 2004/54 with 28,000 on the clock for £46,500 recently...so they can be had - although it was a colour not to everyones taste, guards red...but when you do the sums ...£76,500 new and £46,500 just over two years later, some one got a good deal IMHO

I have just picked up a 996tt x50 with low miles for just over the £50,000 mark..but each to his own....You`ll never win on the forum, if you buy a 997 c2s they`ll tell you, you should have bought a 996tt and then on the other hand the others will say why didnt you buy a c2s 997 instead off your turbo as your daily drive..

i am sure you`ll get pleanty off opinions back

tonikaram

324 posts

241 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Haven't driven any, but I say it's a battle between availability and your patience. A 997 is of course the newest one (better to drive than a C4s, that's for sure, and I'd want a 997 much more than a 996 since it's the current model), but I guess just keep searching until you're satisfied/tired/exasperated and are ready to just give in to the last one you found.


Kay

Bumcrack

977 posts

296 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Dalton said:
Hello,

Hope you may provide me with some advise.

Been lurking for a while and at the same time looking to buy my first Porsche.

Really like the look of the 996 C4S, have considered a late one with low mileage and a decent spec, however we are talking about £50k here so the dilemma is to go for the C4S or an early 997 with a few more miles on the clock than say the C4S has. I probably prefer the S version over the standard Carerra.

What do you reckon, mostly this will be my daily car so I guess the 997 suits better with the extended service intervals for example, however I can't get the look of the C4S out of my head.

Any advice would be really appreciated.

Dalton
No way would I pay nearly 50K for a 996 C4S, the prices will continue to drop and you’ll loose more money on it than you would if you bought the 997 model for similar money. The 997 is better in almost everyway imo, apart from the steering feel is slightly better in the 996 imo.
Porsche has improved the 911 with the 997, its better built, nicer inside and generally feels like a more modern car than the 996 models.

That’s not to say the 996 isn’t a brilliant car, but I wouldn’t pay top money when you can get the newer version for 50K

Regards

steve.B

457 posts

238 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
QUOTE 1 From tonikaram,
Haven't driven any..........
A 997 is of course the newest one (better to drive than C4s thats for sure

QUOTE 2 From Wanta996,
increase in its weight means it also drinks more fuel than the standard 997.

I should say nothing but having read the kayc and wanta996 exchanges I must agree with kayc about ownership before comments.
If you have never driven these cars how can you state ones better than the other.
On to the next, I found that the mpg are very much the same 30 to the gallon on a run.
and now wanta996 your an expert on the pricing of porsche
wantaTVR has a great ring about itredcard IMO!nearly forgot.wink

Grant3

3,710 posts

286 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
If you are spending £50k on Pork ensure you test drive two cars............
996TT (X-50 possibly)
997S
Then decide which you personally like best, both great cars, with different strengths, only you know what you want
Low £40ks & the C4S also comes into play if you want to spend less, great looking car & great to drive.

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
IMO if you're spending £50k on a car and consider fuel consumption as a prohibitive 'running cost' (rather than as a 'range' issue)...should you be spending £50k on a car? Surely depreciation should be your main concern as that will eat up your capital..£1k in fuel is neither here nor there in relative terms.

Wanta996

5,622 posts

238 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Friend of mine bought a Land Rover Vouge at £50k and putting £150 a week on fuel pissed him off more than what he may lose come trade in time. A few Pistonheaders have commented that one of the gripes of the tiptronic is how terrible it is on fuel so i guess it does bother some owners.

I may be wrong but i am sure the C4S weighs in approx 100kg more than the standard 997 C2.

Edited by Wanta996 on Friday 15th June 22:42

Jonathanf

47 posts

278 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Anyone considering spending the same on a 996C4S as a 997S needs their head examined.

1)A 997S is fractionally faster in a straight line (up to 190mph with lots of roll ons the 997S won)

2)on a country road it is a 100x more fun (no scientific proof it just was)

3) it probably drinks similar amount of fuel (absolutley no idea but we both filled up at the same time)

4) it will depreciate far less. I lost 16k in 2 years and 20k miles and the C4S lost a shit load more than you can imagine. I won't say the numbers because I will spare the owner the shame.

So if you want the answer to 996C4S v 997S don't even compare if similar money. If the 996 is far less money then that is a different ball game.

As for a 997 v 997S I have no idea as I never raced one over 3000 miles through Europe wink

Bumcrack

977 posts

296 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
baz1985 said:
IMO if you're spending £50k on a car and consider fuel consumption as a prohibitive 'running cost' (rather than as a 'range' issue)...should you be spending £50k on a car? Surely depreciation should be your main concern as that will eat up your capital..£1k in fuel is neither here nor there in relative terms.
Think you have to take MPG as a consideration imo, it's not a deal breaker, but I don't mind spending 50K on a car, but want a reasonable MPG (for a sports car). That’s why I wouldn’t buy a big 4X4 or Impreza/Evo as an everyday car.).

JOHNY

5 posts

259 months

Saturday 23rd June 2007
quotequote all
I am also looking to spend 50k and do like the 996 4s and the 997 4s went to opc this week to have a look, and once youve sat in the 997 the 996 seems very dated. The 997 4s still up in the 60k margin so i might hang of for 6 months until it drops into the 50k margin. Going back over the next few weeks to test drive both so i'll let you know after the drive, but i do think i'm now heart set on the 997 4s. Im very keen on the tiptonic though as i'm round town more than out.

flattotheboards

6,689 posts

237 months

Saturday 23rd June 2007
quotequote all
id go for the 997 carrera s if you can as its a more modern car and itll b more reliable and thanks to longer servicing intervals probably cheaper to run. get the best spec you can good luck.

mikeg996

875 posts

253 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
30121980 said:
Just to add, i sold my 997 c2s a 2004/54 with 28,000 on the clock for £46,500 recently...so they can be had - although it was a colour not to everyones taste, guards red...but when you do the sums ...£76,500 new and £46,500 just over two years later, some one got a good deal IMHO
I was looking at a Guards Red 997C2 today that was excellent value. £49,995 with 7800 miles on the clock. It occurred to me that it could be resprayed a different colour, like that EVO chap with his Carrera GT going from silver to yellow (before he stuffed it into a wall, that is).

chillerman

191 posts

243 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
Jonathanf said:
Anyone considering spending the same on a 996C4S as a 997S needs their head examined.

1)A 997S is fractionally faster in a straight line (up to 190mph with lots of roll ons the 997S won)

2)on a country road it is a 100x more fun (no scientific proof it just was)

3) it probably drinks similar amount of fuel (absolutley no idea but we both filled up at the same time)

4) it will depreciate far less. I lost 16k in 2 years and 20k miles and the C4S lost a shit load more than you can imagine. I won't say the numbers because I will spare the owner the shame.

So if you want the answer to 996C4S v 997S don't even compare if similar money. If the 996 is far less money then that is a different ball game.

As for a 997 v 997S I have no idea as I never raced one over 3000 miles through Europe wink
Where do I get a 997s or a 996 C4S that does up to 190 mph ? Neither will get near that without major tuning. If you want a stock porsche that can do that sort of speed, buy a different model and stop dreaming.

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
Wanta996 said:
Friend of mine bought a Land Rover Vouge at £50k and putting £150 a week on fuel pissed him off more than what he may lose come trade in time. A few Pistonheaders have commented that one of the gripes of the tiptronic is how terrible it is on fuel so i guess it does bother some owners
The issue is not consumption per se but how often you need to refuel. To me this is a pain in the a. Moneywise I couldn't care less

chillerman

191 posts

243 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
Dr S said:
Wanta996 said:
Friend of mine bought a Land Rover Vouge at £50k and putting £150 a week on fuel pissed him off more than what he may lose come trade in time. A few Pistonheaders have commented that one of the gripes of the tiptronic is how terrible it is on fuel so i guess it does bother some owners
The issue is not consumption per se but how often you need to refuel. To me this is a pain in the a. Moneywise I couldn't care less
Agreed. Fuel range on 996 tt X50 is crap.

djohnson

3,687 posts

254 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
If you've got £50k to spend there can be only one answer = 996tt.