GT3's taking flak at the ring..
GT3's taking flak at the ring..
Author
Discussion

Rawhide

Original Poster:

980 posts

244 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
I've noticed the reputation of Porsche's are taking some abuse on the Nurburgring forums.

http://bridgetogantry.com/index.php?option=com_con...

I hope this was no-one off here. I'm off there in a couple of weeks in my C2 which has never dropped any fluids. However I'm considering a coolant swap now if someone has died as a consequence.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all


Jesus.

Maybe one of the techincal boys on here (Baz or Weltmeister) might have some advice on what's gone on here. Are they just overfilled and boiling over when they're thrashed?




clubsport

7,417 posts

289 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all


Kettles boiled,,,,milk and 2 sugars please! smile

rick111s

397 posts

264 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
more like

"throw another shrimp on the barbie..."








serious note: sorry to hear about the crash and the bike rider.


OllieW

168 posts

250 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
When will the management at the Ring learn that cars and bikes on their track don't mix at all well...

We were there at the end of May and there were two deaths that weekend, both bikers, and there were numerous incidents of bikers getting inside of cars in corners and vice versa.

Appreciate the issue of a car dumping its coolant is a real problem but I am sure it is not only 911's that do this and perhaps he's just being a dick for implying this

MaKSiNG

382 posts

257 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
Are GT3s renowned for header tank problems though?
I thought that was the Carrera engine.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
MaKSiNG said:
Are GT3s renowned for header tank problems though?
I thought that was the Carrera engine.
Same tank.

I think these cars are being over filled and boiling over.

flattotheboards

6,689 posts

237 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
thats awful that a bloke was killed because of some tw4t driving whilist dropping all of his coolant. i wouldnt have thought that you will break your porsche the cars seen on here look like they pound the ring alot and therefore are going to break from time to time.

SidewaysSid

523 posts

289 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
MaKSiNG said:
Are GT3s renowned for header tank problems though?
I thought that was the Carrera engine.
We know lots of GT3 owners and have never heard of a GT3 boiling over here. More to this than meets the eye.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
flattotheboards said:
thats awful that a bloke was killed because of some tw4t driving whilist dropping all of his coolant.
terrible news but thats very unfair. there's nothing to suggest he knew he was dropping fluid. it could happen to anyone.

Henry-F

4,791 posts

276 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
GT3`s can overheat for a number of reasons and obviously when driven hard everything is put to the test.

Header tank split.

Header tank water cap not put on properly after checking the coolant the night before you set off round the ring (very easy to do)

Front rads leaking & not picked noticed

Front rads holed whilst on the ring

Air in the system when not bled properly

Any one of a number of hoses damaged / not fitting or pushed in properly

Head gasket failure

Cracked head

The light by the water temp will flash as the level drops in the header tank but very hard to spot when your eyes are focused on driving, ditto the temp guage. Porsche coolant is horrific when dropped on tarmac & turns it into an ice rink. I would imagine the people had no idea they were dropping fluid although if they did is there anywhere to pull over on the ring even if you wanted to ? Similarly it`s not like a circuit where you have marshals waving red & yellow flags as soon as they see someone dropping fluid (or rather not marshals by every corner as per a circuit).

Henry

Edited by Henry-F on Thursday 28th June 21:31

Neilpeel59

279 posts

250 months

Thursday 28th June 2007
quotequote all
This is exactly why I stopped taking my bike to the Nurburgring. No matter how good you are, if there is dumped oil or coolant all over the track it's game over. Oil is obvious but coolant is the silent killer. Tragic :-(

runnersp

1,061 posts

251 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
Ride a car or a bike on a track, get rid of the coolant and put water in. Its the only solution.

Kurgen

1,447 posts

265 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
Been having this conversation on another forum..

The Nordschleife on a public day.. is a public toll road.
Just like the A24 at Box Hill is a public road (with speed limits)

If you ride a bike (I have an R6R as well as a GT2) then it is your responsibility to ride with all possible eventualities in mind..

There are always vehicles dropping diesel/petrol/oil/coolant/brake fluid..etc etc... all the time on public roads.

If a biker decides to ride cranked over, knee down, on the limit.. around a blind bend, then slides on a dropped fluid.. then he only has himself to blame!

IMO
Rob

timmo

1,788 posts

265 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
Ive had 3 radiators replaced in my GT2s/GT3s over the past 4 years
I now have a mesh guard protecting the the front Inlets before any stones etc hit the rads
My condolences go out to the person killed at the ring and after reading the reports he was an experienced biker/nurburgring attendee
( being an ex-biker and courier I do sympathise )
Ive often thought there is a flaw in the 996 Porsche having the Rads exposed and no protection against stones etc which at over 120mph hit the rads like bullets
keeping the aircooled shape with a rear engine watercooled car

There are pictures of the GT3s leaking on that BTG website

Very Sad!


Kurgen

1,447 posts

265 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
timmo said:
Ive had 3 radiators replaced in my GT2s/GT3s over the past 4 years
I now have a mesh guard protecting the the front Inlets before any stones etc hit the rads
My condolences go out to the person killed at the ring and after reading the reports he was an experienced biker/nurburgring attendee
( being an ex-biker and courier I do sympathise )
Ive often thought there is a flaw in the 996 Porsche having the Rads exposed and no protection against stones etc which at over 120mph hit the rads like bullets
keeping the aircooled shape with a rear engine watercooled car

There are pictures of the GT3s leaking on that BTG website

Very Sad!
Have just had 2 rads replaced, + the chicken wire.. Anybody got Rance's address for the bill!! biggrin

Wetwipe

3,019 posts

244 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
what an utter complete load of cock

i would suggest the person most responsible for attempting to kill that biker is no other than himself.

to single pork out as the main culprit of coolent loss on the ring is simply stupid

if he thinks his life is at risk then dont run on the ring. same as a base jumper bemoaning the possibility that his 'chute may not open - lets face it that is the reason they do it in the first place

Kurgen

1,447 posts

265 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
Wetwipe said:
what an utter complete load of cock

i would suggest the person most responsible for attempting to kill that biker is no other than himself.

to single pork out as the main culprit of coolent loss on the ring is simply stupid

if he thinks his life is at risk then dont run on the ring. same as a base jumper bemoaning the possibility that his 'chute may not open - lets face it that is the reason they do it in the first place
Controversial, Wetwipe..!

But sadly, I agree.


angry

180 posts

261 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
But if we are going to run on the Ring,we should keep our cars in tip top condition and check for leaks regularly,because i personally dont like seeing bikers getting killed whilst having fun in/on thier choice of vehicle.If through the neglegance of the maintanence of my car somebody had an accident and died,i would feel pretty sick.We are all humans.
Dan

PGM

2,168 posts

280 months

Friday 29th June 2007
quotequote all
Happened to me on the ring last year, split expansion tank. When I came back in fluid was on floor and steam out of lid.

Stopped lapping at that point but how are you supposed to know during the lap?