Warranty battle or accept defeat ?
Warranty battle or accept defeat ?
Author
Discussion

andyscoobs

Original Poster:

337 posts

247 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
A month ago my 996TT developed a fault. (code 9142)
Popped into my local OPC thinking everything would be sorted out under warranty. Code 9142 refers to a faulty instrument cluster.
Got a phone call and they said its not good. They said there's a wiring fault and its not covered under warranty. To fix it will take about 6 ish hours costing nearly £800 in labour. At 1st I thought poke it but then I wanted the car sorted so I authorised the work.
CANT BELIEVE this isn't covered under warranty. Wiring is not a wear and tear part.
Only had the car about 3 months and the shine of owning a Porsche is a little bit ruined.
Car had been left at a friends for a bit and he lives at a farm.
A theory the garage has is that a mouse has climbed into the engine bay and had a nibble at the wires?
Bull or a possibility ?
Re the warranty claim. Is it worth a battle or should I accept an expensive fate.

Cheers

Andy

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
if they won't do the work under warranty, why give them the business? A good specialist will charge around £50 per hour, so that's saving you £500 already. They will also probably do it in less hours, saving you potentially more. At least you can get a second opinion from a good specialist, might be lucky and find out it's something simple.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
I'd be very tempted to re-open the lines of communications, rather than just accepting the entire bill. It needs fixing, presumably, as its affecting something, rather than just throwing an error code?

If it needs doing then it has to be done, and somebody has to pay for it, whether thats you or the warranty. If they think its mice chewing things, and can prove it then by all means swallow the bill, as its a bit of s stuff happens thing that you wouldnt think to be covered by the warranty.

If, on the other hand, its simply faulty wiring or relays, then its down to them.

Calm, rational, composed and persistent. You know it makes sense.

headlesshorseman

619 posts

237 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
what he said,defo

Paulburrell

648 posts

264 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
If you don't get anywhere with OPC, try a breakers yard or EBay, you can usually source a replacement from one of these two.

Stevesmilesmile

phelix

4,684 posts

280 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
Whomever replaces the part, ask to see it and keep it so that you can understand what happened. Is it rodent damage? Is it a poorly installed harness that was pinched/damaged over time?

LeoSayer

7,863 posts

275 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
Who did you buy the car from? Main dealer, Independent or private?

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
If it's rodent damage it's possibly covered on the house (farm) insurance?

lanesra10

314 posts

262 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Beware the OPC will make sure it looks like rodent damage. Get an Inde to do the work to save money. If its genuinly faulty then claim from the insurance company!!

andyscoobs

Original Poster:

337 posts

247 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Bought the car private and then paid the £900 for the warranty.
They found the problem. Two wires which were both live had worn and were touching each other. The mechanic must of been working on it for about 6 - 8 hours but they only charged me for 5 hours.
A lot of dosh for 2 wires but it needed sorting.
I'm going to write a snotty letter to Porsche customer services about this not being covered under warranty as it seems unfair.
They said they had never come across a problem like this before. I guess I was just lucky........................not

///ajd

8,964 posts

237 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
So the wires had just rubbed against each other? How many miles has the car done? If not many then you wouldn't expect this - perhaps the wires/loom was not correctly installed at the factory hence the problem? Or perhaps not reinstalled following repairs.

You wouldn't expect a production car to have this kind of problem unless its not been put together properly (warranty issue, or perhaps even SOGA covers?) or its done loads & loads of miles (>150k)- all such issues should be carefully designed out during development & test phases.

993AL

1,939 posts

249 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Had a similar problem with my 993, started to run as rough as hell, put it into a well respected independant, he found that two of the HT leads had been badly chewed by mice, they had also eaten a fair bit of the sound insulation in the engine bay. The little gits had also munched other rubber items in the garage but didnt see anything made of plastic that had been eaten, I guess the wires you talk about are plastic coated? your mice are on a different diet perhaps?

andyscoobs

Original Poster:

337 posts

247 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Its just hit 42k miles and its a 2001 model !

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 27th September 2007
quotequote all
" 6 ish hours costing nearly £800 in labour"

yikes they have their lawyer do the work?

andyscoobs

Original Poster:

337 posts

247 months

Thursday 27th September 2007
quotequote all
£800 was the original quote. But they only charged me for 5 hours which ended up being £650

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Thursday 27th September 2007
quotequote all
andyscoobs said:
£800 was the original quote. But they only charged me for 5 hours which ended up being £650
would have been £250-£300 at a good independent smile

andyscoobs

Original Poster:

337 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
This keeps getting better. On driving it home I discovered the front left indicator isn't working. I thought it maybe the bulb so I swapped it round and guess what. NO difference !

Plugged my durametric in and I'm now getting an error code 25.

So they fixed the original problem but have now created more errors. I'm thinking are they going to blame everything on the wiring so that they dont have to pay up under warranty !!!!

HELP

Andy

andyscoobs

Original Poster:

337 posts

247 months

Sunday 7th October 2007
quotequote all
Fixed the indicator myself. The experts at the OPC had bent the pin inside the connector so I repaired that myself.

The code left on my DME was just telling me the battery had been disconnected and another OPC cleared that for me.

Back to the wire mystery.
They said the wire which was damaged was something to do with the lights on the licence plate. I have had a look inside my engine bay and can see this wire. Its under the air box and goes into the back bumper.
Even the mechanic said these never go wrong with wiring ! My car only went wrong after it had a full service. The one where the rear BUMPER comes off !
I bet this is when that wire got damaged but I will never be able to prove it.
This new wire they have put in the car starts in the bumper and goes all the way to the front and looks like it has been hardwired onto the battery. I'm sure this wasn't there b4 the OPC started fiddling with it. Its doesn't look very professional. If the wire was damaged shouldn't they have changed the entire loom affected ? It looks like a quick fix ????

Anyway....................
Letter of complaint on way to customer services.
Do I take it back to Porsche to make a better job of the wire or dont let the butchers near it?

Wish I could go back in time !

///ajd

8,964 posts

237 months

Sunday 7th October 2007
quotequote all
Sounds to me like you have a good case for come back IF it seems obvious that it was caused by bumper removal and then inadequate reinstallation of wires. This would cause the fault but its 100% down to the techs who didn't put it back right. If this was the OPC then what case do they have not to be responsible?

fastfreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Sounds like the technician messed up and tried to cover his tracks. Expect the OPC to deny everything and brush off your complaint. If you do get them to admit to making a mistake, be sure to post it here as we don't see many admissions of guilt from them these days.

And I always chuckle to myself when I hear they've used the "never seen that before" line. Almost as common as the "you need new brake discs and pads" line biggrin