2nd gear syncro gone mins after leaving garage, advice pls
Discussion
Hi guys
I would like your wisdom and advice on the situation I find myself in this week.
I have purchased a GT3 froma fellow pistonheader who has been very helpful and very honest about the history and work carried out to the car in the past. I decided to have the car inspected by an independent Porsche specialist as the car is being shipped to Spain and I thought it would be far easier to get any bits sorted in the UK rather than here.
The report seemed very thorough and all that needed doing was the front suspension units refurbed, I was happy with this and waited impatiently for 3 weeks for this to be done. As the car was being driven down to the shippers the 2nd gear kept jumping out, the car was taken to Camtune in Surrey who have been out in the car and confirm our thoughts that the 2nd gear syncro has gone.
I am now gutted as have to wait approx another 3 weeks while they order the parts and I look forward to a best guestimate of approx 2800 plus vat to cover the labour and parts. My question is do I just swallow this and say OK we all know GT3's are renowned for this or is there any degree of comeback to the company that carried out the inspection or is it totally impossible to tell beforehand and it's just one of those things that happens?
I would like your wisdom and advice on the situation I find myself in this week.
I have purchased a GT3 froma fellow pistonheader who has been very helpful and very honest about the history and work carried out to the car in the past. I decided to have the car inspected by an independent Porsche specialist as the car is being shipped to Spain and I thought it would be far easier to get any bits sorted in the UK rather than here.
The report seemed very thorough and all that needed doing was the front suspension units refurbed, I was happy with this and waited impatiently for 3 weeks for this to be done. As the car was being driven down to the shippers the 2nd gear kept jumping out, the car was taken to Camtune in Surrey who have been out in the car and confirm our thoughts that the 2nd gear syncro has gone.
I am now gutted as have to wait approx another 3 weeks while they order the parts and I look forward to a best guestimate of approx 2800 plus vat to cover the labour and parts. My question is do I just swallow this and say OK we all know GT3's are renowned for this or is there any degree of comeback to the company that carried out the inspection or is it totally impossible to tell beforehand and it's just one of those things that happens?
Not sure you have much grounds against the company who inspected 
Do you have a Porsche warranty on the car still? It is a known issue and in some circumstances they will cover it having inspected parts for mistreatment. (According to rennlist so with Porsche GB in the UK, they probably just laugh and tell you to piss off).
Failing that, give yourself the cup car final drive as a bonus for having to get the box done anyway. It will make the car 10-15% faster at the loss of 20mph top end. That should take the edge off the pain

Do you have a Porsche warranty on the car still? It is a known issue and in some circumstances they will cover it having inspected parts for mistreatment. (According to rennlist so with Porsche GB in the UK, they probably just laugh and tell you to piss off).
Failing that, give yourself the cup car final drive as a bonus for having to get the box done anyway. It will make the car 10-15% faster at the loss of 20mph top end. That should take the edge off the pain

Edited by DanH on Tuesday 25th September 21:07
mikeknivett said:
good idea, do you have any cost of the cup final drive? are there any negatives to doing this except the top end speed loss which is no big deal in reality these days?
The final drive is about 1200 quid and requires a gearbox rebuild as its what all the ratios attach to, so you are most of the way there anyway.Potentially more wear through the box as more torque in a given gear but Steve at JZ didn't even think that was the case and not something to worry about. I was quoted about 3.5k all in to get the final drive and cup diff plates (as the original fit wears and also doesn't ramp up to enough lock on road tyres) IIRC from JZ, but I'm terrible at remembering quotes. I guess with a few new synchros it might be higher...
Finally get the car here in spain after 5.5K bill for gearbox rebuild, new clutch and single mass fly wheel, 2 mins after picking up the car starts completely misfiring!
Took it into a superb garage here, very difficult to say that in spain but these guys are the Manthey guys here and their setup is bloody impressive, 2 mins plugged into the Porsche laptop and 5th cylinder misfiring, it was the coil packs? I think they were called.
They showed me 4 of these coils and even to my untrained ignorant eye they were totally fxxkxed, all split and easily letting moisture in.
I took the advice of you guys on here after the gearbox episode re the fact that the syncro could have gone after my "extremely thorough inspection" to quote the garage I used but I have been told today there is no way that these coils should not have been picked up by the garage in the UK.
I dont want to name names as dont know if thats the done thing on here? but if I was buying another used Porsche I certainly wouldn't use this garage to do an inspection again.
Should have got a recommendation from here or stuck with Camtune where my GT2 and other Porsches have always come from.
Took it into a superb garage here, very difficult to say that in spain but these guys are the Manthey guys here and their setup is bloody impressive, 2 mins plugged into the Porsche laptop and 5th cylinder misfiring, it was the coil packs? I think they were called.
They showed me 4 of these coils and even to my untrained ignorant eye they were totally fxxkxed, all split and easily letting moisture in.
I took the advice of you guys on here after the gearbox episode re the fact that the syncro could have gone after my "extremely thorough inspection" to quote the garage I used but I have been told today there is no way that these coils should not have been picked up by the garage in the UK.
I dont want to name names as dont know if thats the done thing on here? but if I was buying another used Porsche I certainly wouldn't use this garage to do an inspection again.
Should have got a recommendation from here or stuck with Camtune where my GT2 and other Porsches have always come from.
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



