The day the Porsche brand died
The day the Porsche brand died
Author
Discussion

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
- Prompted by a recent post of someone upset they can`t buy a GT2 off Porsche -

Let me start my rant by saying I have never been involved in selling new cars for over list, in fact we don`t sell new cars at all. My take is that the main dealers are the best placed people to buy a new car from. They have a close relationship with Porsche AG, they are privy to any technical issues affecting the cars and hopefully are in a position to give feedback to Porsche AG. We get offered quite a few cars where owners are hoping to profit from a shortage of stock, we decline.

It genuinely saddens me that Porsche operate in the way they do. In the past few weeks I have received a number of promotional publications from the dealer network extolling the virtues of the new GT2. Why bother? Why waste my time and your paper getting my dick all hard over a car I can`t buy - you don`t have any for sale. All you do is annoy your customer. The vast majority of people who can afford the cars don`t want to put down deposits 2 years in advance, they don`t even know there is a waiting list for a car that doesn`t exist yet. They wait until Porsche send them a brochure, say yes, that`s nice I`ll have on and then place an order.

I will bet you a pound to a penny that as soon as the new GT2 is released into the UK someone like Tom Hartley has one available for immediate delivery at a vastly increased price. It will be sold, the new owner will use it and when it comes time to sell on will remember only too well the price he paid. Not list price but way over that. He then equates Porsche cars to big depreciation.

I know the theory, you limit production, keep the prices high and residuals are rosy. I`m not convinced it works like that. People live for today, if they can`t get your product then they look elsewhere for something similar. As for your old customers, the ones you`ve nurtured, the ones who have bought your product over the years, even the cars that weren`t all that hot, the ones who have suffered the teething problems often suffered with a new model - you sweep them under the carpet.

I remember trying to buy a Cayenne when they came out, I exchanged a couple of letters with Andy Goss (head cheese at Porsche GB), I spoke to dealers and all I got was "no chance." I wanted to use the Cayenne as a work horse towing our GT3 race car, towing Porsche road cars round the country for collection, delivery, service and repair. I got no help at all. I even met people who had just walked into the right dealer at the right time and bought one there and then but no one was prepared to find one for me. Eventually a friend found one for me at a dealer in Northern Ireland, I bought it and kept the car for 3 years. People used to film me on their mobile phones and video cameras as I towed with it, particularly with the GT3 race car. I was advertising Cayennes for Porsche - the company who couldn`t be bothered to help me find one - at list price!

The same thing happens with 997 cup cars, at one stage I tried to buy one but gave up. I`ve raced Porsches for years and never once has Marion, the Carrera Cup organiser contacted me to see if I fancy trying my hand in the Carrera Cup, a hotbed of Porsche talent and activity I think a whole 12 cars turned up to the last round ! compare this against 2 grids of 44 cars (with reserves waiting in the wings) for the Porsche club showing at the World touring car meet at Brands this weekend. Then poor old Marion, numbers dwindling says Porsche have got a great idea. With 18 or so 2008 model 997 cup cars arriving (a lot quicker than the 2006 & 2007 cars), she is going to bolster numbers by having a new class for the old cars, just to make sure you look a total knob at the back of the grid and getting in the way as you are lapped, you not only get to drive a slower car you also get to use harder tyres (ie slower). The good news is you`ll save 4-500 quid a meeting because you`ll only buy 6 tyres rather than 8. That`s handy when you`re shelling out £160,000 - 200,000 for the year (including car). I think we`re getting the picture of how you view your customers Porsche - idiots.

I know a chap who was one of the last people to be delivered his Carrera GT for what ever reason despite weighing in with his depo bright and early, he still has it and it`s one of the best know cars in the country flying the flag for Porsche. Yet Porsche made him sit and watch as car after car was delivered to other customers only for them to offer them up for sale at over list. Still, Porsche look after him with tickets to go to all the Carrera cup rounds and park his Carrera GT outside the food tent - oh no, my mistake, I was thinking of another brand there. They do sweet f*ck all. This for a man that`s spent £320,000 on a car and who uses it to promote both the Carrera GT and the Porsche brand in publications.

How do you get it so wrong Porsche? There are some good people in the Porsche gang. Geoff Turrel, the general manager at Porsche is a great guy. He speaks the language, is an enthusiast and when ever I`ve spoken to him we have a laugh, so why is there all this angst. At what point does everything break down. Is Porsche AG the arrogant one with it`s head in the sand? Am I wrong in thinking Porsche GB has anything at all to do with the problem?

Then you`ve got a Porsche club with whom Porsche have an understand of mutual satisfaction or some such thing that`s organising national shows with 4 cups of tea and 2 bacon butties per 300 attendants and rain drenched Goodwood stands with a perfectly good roof for the £100,000 race / display truck they left at home. All in the name of "political correctness to the mother company".

I`m buggered if know. To me it isn`t rocket science to make sure your best customers get the latest offerings, if need be hold back the registration documents for a year & insist they must be sold back to the network within that period. If you`ve got more than 20 people who want to spend £130k with you then make a few more cars. This bollox about protecting residuals is nothing compared to how the poor sods you forced to pay 10, 20 or £30k over list will feel when it comes to resale. If you want to get into bed with an owners club help them out a bit by making them realise they don`t have to get their heads up your arses quite so far and give them a few tips on organising good jollies, (if you do ever blag your way into the Porsche golden circle at an event they treat you like royalty and are fab).

It`s a massive rant and possibly a bit off topic (hence the separate post), but I say it because I care, both for the Porsche brand and also for the Porsche club. I`d love to see people viewing Porsche as a friendly brand that put their arms round their customers and looked after them. All I hear are moans about hassles buying cars off them and problems when cars go wrong. Similarly I would dearly love to see a Porsche club carry that love on by focusing their efforts on delivering great social gatherings that work hand in hand with Porsche to spread the happiness.

After all that lot I`m off for a cup of tea !

As ever, keep smiling & remember I only say it because I care. I mean no harm or ill feeling towards anyone involved in either Porsche or the Porsche club.

Henry

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
Eloquently put.


kleonard

767 posts

255 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
great read and great points henry...!!porsche open is making the carrera cup look pretty shitty with grids averaging 13 cars... i talked to marrion during the year about a 997cup car and its seems a simular story to a new gt2... NO u cant spend 100k with us but u can buy a second hand car off one of the current teams in her close circle for about 20k less at around 80k.. after which the car needs a 20k rebuild = 100k the same price of the new model coming out..!! in other words if your not on track already you wont get one..!! The porsche open will grow bigger again next year as people get much better value and the standard of cars improve and drivers also...!! The only reason there is 3 classes this year in carrera cup is to get the grids up as the msa were going to kick them off the touring car package due to poor grids...!!
Getting back to the gt2... it seems that like most things if you know the right people you will get a car...!! i just dont understand why porsche dont make about 80 cars to look after demand....!!the people that cant get them like u said will buy other brands insteed with impluse buying...!! do porsche want all us guys buying ferraris or lambos.. ???

Edited by kleonard on Tuesday 25th September 23:02


Edited by kleonard on Tuesday 25th September 23:04

dazren

22,612 posts

292 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
Quality post. clap

Like you I don't believe Porsche give a stuff about residuals. I predict a flood of deliveries in year 2........

C2look

3,858 posts

256 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
clap great rant Henry!

4sure

2,438 posts

242 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
i agree wholeheartedly...even countax sent me an invite to the lancs show this summer...unfortunately it was cancelled due to adverse weather..but i still felt looked after ! wavey

Paracetamol

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
Henry-F said:
-
I remember trying to buy a Cayenne when they came out
surely thats the day the Porsche brand died!!

Jappo

1,121 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
I was at Brands last Sunday and the Porsche race you refer to was the best motor racing entertaiment I have had for many Years - it was the last race of the day I and many stayed on to watch it. It's a brilliant series and shows the way to go if the Porsche brand is to remain inextricably linked with racing cars. It was brilliant at the Silverstone Classic too.

PolarExpress

6,796 posts

258 months

Tuesday 25th September 2007
quotequote all
Well said Henry. thumbup

And respect for speaking your mind and telling it as you see it. bow

smile

Stevorocket

408 posts

250 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Well said Henry! A good insight there.

As a customer of a well known dealership in G----ford it really does p me off to get a card saying my aircon needs a squirt or my mot may be due or fill in this questionaire. (thats all)
My Neighbour who has bought 2 boxters and 2 997s from them got that brochure with the GT2 splash as well - he gave it to me with the message he didn't really get on well with Porsche G--F--D - after he's spent the best part of 250 grand with them over the last few years, they've peed him off too.
So where are the occasional free invites to events?
What about the odd garden party?
Maybe they could have put their backs and budgets behind the disastrous Ragley Hall fiasco instead of leaving it to the organisationally incompetent!

IMI A

9,997 posts

232 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Henry-F said:
- Prompted by a recent post of someone upset they can`t buy a GT2 off Porsche -

Let me start my rant by saying I have never been involved in selling new cars for over list, in fact we don`t sell new cars at all. My take is that the main dealers are the best placed people to buy a new car from. They have a close relationship with Porsche AG, they are privy to any technical issues affecting the cars and hopefully are in a position to give feedback to Porsche AG. We get offered quite a few cars where owners are hoping to profit from a shortage of stock, we decline.

It genuinely saddens me that Porsche operate in the way they do. In the past few weeks I have received a number of promotional publications from the dealer network extolling the virtues of the new GT2. Why bother? Why waste my time and your paper getting my dick all hard over a car I can`t buy - you don`t have any for sale. All you do is annoy your customer. The vast majority of people who can afford the cars don`t want to put down deposits 2 years in advance, they don`t even know there is a waiting list for a car that doesn`t exist yet. They wait until Porsche send them a brochure, say yes, that`s nice I`ll have on and then place an order.

I will bet you a pound to a penny that as soon as the new GT2 is released into the UK someone like Tom Hartley has one available for immediate delivery at a vastly increased price. It will be sold, the new owner will use it and when it comes time to sell on will remember only too well the price he paid. Not list price but way over that. He then equates Porsche cars to big depreciation.

I know the theory, you limit production, keep the prices high and residuals are rosy. I`m not convinced it works like that. People live for today, if they can`t get your product then they look elsewhere for something similar. As for your old customers, the ones you`ve nurtured, the ones who have bought your product over the years, even the cars that weren`t all that hot, the ones who have suffered the teething problems often suffered with a new model - you sweep them under the carpet.

I remember trying to buy a Cayenne when they came out, I exchanged a couple of letters with Andy Goss (head cheese at Porsche GB), I spoke to dealers and all I got was "no chance." I wanted to use the Cayenne as a work horse towing our GT3 race car, towing Porsche road cars round the country for collection, delivery, service and repair. I got no help at all. I even met people who had just walked into the right dealer at the right time and bought one there and then but no one was prepared to find one for me. Eventually a friend found one for me at a dealer in Northern Ireland, I bought it and kept the car for 3 years. People used to film me on their mobile phones and video cameras as I towed with it, particularly with the GT3 race car. I was advertising Cayennes for Porsche - the company who couldn`t be bothered to help me find one - at list price!

The same thing happens with 997 cup cars, at one stage I tried to buy one but gave up. I`ve raced Porsches for years and never once has Marion, the Carrera Cup organiser contacted me to see if I fancy trying my hand in the Carrera Cup, a hotbed of Porsche talent and activity I think a whole 12 cars turned up to the last round ! compare this against 2 grids of 44 cars (with reserves waiting in the wings) for the Porsche club showing at the World touring car meet at Brands this weekend. Then poor old Marion, numbers dwindling says Porsche have got a great idea. With 18 or so 2008 model 997 cup cars arriving (a lot quicker than the 2006 & 2007 cars), she is going to bolster numbers by having a new class for the old cars, just to make sure you look a total knob at the back of the grid and getting in the way as you are lapped, you not only get to drive a slower car you also get to use harder tyres (ie slower). The good news is you`ll save 4-500 quid a meeting because you`ll only buy 6 tyres rather than 8. That`s handy when you`re shelling out £160,000 - 200,000 for the year (including car). I think we`re getting the picture of how you view your customers Porsche - idiots.

I know a chap who was one of the last people to be delivered his Carrera GT for what ever reason despite weighing in with his depo bright and early, he still has it and it`s one of the best know cars in the country flying the flag for Porsche. Yet Porsche made him sit and watch as car after car was delivered to other customers only for them to offer them up for sale at over list. Still, Porsche look after him with tickets to go to all the Carrera cup rounds and park his Carrera GT outside the food tent - oh no, my mistake, I was thinking of another brand there. They do sweet f*ck all. This for a man that`s spent £320,000 on a car and who uses it to promote both the Carrera GT and the Porsche brand in publications.

How do you get it so wrong Porsche? There are some good people in the Porsche gang. Geoff Turrel, the general manager at Porsche is a great guy. He speaks the language, is an enthusiast and when ever I`ve spoken to him we have a laugh, so why is there all this angst. At what point does everything break down. Is Porsche AG the arrogant one with it`s head in the sand? Am I wrong in thinking Porsche GB has anything at all to do with the problem?

Then you`ve got a Porsche club with whom Porsche have an understand of mutual satisfaction or some such thing that`s organising national shows with 4 cups of tea and 2 bacon butties per 300 attendants and rain drenched Goodwood stands with a perfectly good roof for the £100,000 race / display truck they left at home. All in the name of "political correctness to the mother company".

I`m buggered if know. To me it isn`t rocket science to make sure your best customers get the latest offerings, if need be hold back the registration documents for a year & insist they must be sold back to the network within that period. If you`ve got more than 20 people who want to spend £130k with you then make a few more cars. This bollox about protecting residuals is nothing compared to how the poor sods you forced to pay 10, 20 or £30k over list will feel when it comes to resale. If you want to get into bed with an owners club help them out a bit by making them realise they don`t have to get their heads up your arses quite so far and give them a few tips on organising good jollies, (if you do ever blag your way into the Porsche golden circle at an event they treat you like royalty and are fab).

It`s a massive rant and possibly a bit off topic (hence the separate post), but I say it because I care, both for the Porsche brand and also for the Porsche club. I`d love to see people viewing Porsche as a friendly brand that put their arms round their customers and looked after them. All I hear are moans about hassles buying cars off them and problems when cars go wrong. Similarly I would dearly love to see a Porsche club carry that love on by focusing their efforts on delivering great social gatherings that work hand in hand with Porsche to spread the happiness.

After all that lot I`m off for a cup of tea !

As ever, keep smiling & remember I only say it because I care. I mean no harm or ill feeling towards anyone involved in either Porsche or the Porsche club.

Henry
agree with your general sentiment. after 15 years with the brand can't say my next car will be from stuttgart for defo

sal 965

586 posts

242 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Henry,

Spot on. Porsche have lost their way. Whilst i may be speaking a little out of turn there are too many "Porsche People" who for £xxx a month in the short term become Porsche's "prime customers" whereas those who are dedicated to the brand though the years get left behind. This is where the waiting lists, and selling over list, becomes a gripe for those who would buy Porsche after Porsche after Porsche compared to the quick buck merchants courted by the OPC's.

Porsche really need to examine who they want buying their cars in the future. The GT2 is a clear example of under supplying a reasonable UK demand so that a small number of car dealers/individuals can gain some capital growth by quick resale.

paultje

1,042 posts

270 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Well said Henry.....I see the pills have worn off.....!!!

MogulBoy

3,066 posts

254 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Good post!

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Very well put by Henry(if a tad long)..however its sounds similar to what ive been saying about Porsche for about 18 months on this forum and getting castigated for it..simple fact is Porsche is now aiming at a mass market with large turnover and huge profits..they dont give a f@ck about someone being a Porsche enthusiast,those people just get in the way and take up too much time.Cayman's,Cayennes..the new stupid 4 door thing(on its way) make lots of money for Porsche and attract the 'money-borrowing-badge-jockeys' who dont give a shite about heritage/racing history(or quality)they just want to show the neighbours they can borrow enough money to buy a Porsche..that to me is Porsches' target customer now not some bearded car enthusiast waffling on in the showroom about his 964rssoapbox

Edited by kayc on Wednesday 26th September 07:37

cuneus

5,963 posts

273 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Henry

you've only got yourself to blame - you did buy a Cayenne (I said the C word)

exboxster

386 posts

267 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Porsche should have taken a leaf out of Ferrari's book with the launch of the Carrera GT and the GT2- you "invite" people to purchase one. As I understood it there were quite strict controls on the sale of Enzos, and Porsche should have done the same.
Also I dont think the dealer network do the brand any favours. The sheer arrogance of (some of) the sales teams is shocking.


Edited by exboxster on Wednesday 26th September 08:08

AdamT

2,825 posts

283 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
I think then the only cure is to call Herr Alois Ruf.

Believe me, its like being in an extended family. No doubt what it was like in the 60s/70s with porsche...

best,
adam

DoctorD

1,542 posts

287 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
kayc said:
Very well put by Henry(if a tad long)..however its sounds similar to what ive been saying about Porsche for about 18 months on this forum and getting castigated for it..simple fact is Porsche is now aiming at a mass market with large turnover and huge profits..they dont give a f@ck about someone being a Porsche enthusiast,those people just get in the way and take up too much time.Cayman's,Cayennes..the new stupid 4 door thing(on its way) make lots of money for Porsche and attract the 'money-borrowing-badge-jockeys' who dont give a shite about heritage/racing history(or quality)they just want to show the neighbours they can borrow enough money to buy a Porsche..that to me is Porsches' target customer now not some bearded car enthusiast waffling on in the showroom about his 964rssoapbox
For a moment I thought you were talking about BMW... it seems they're all going to the dogs.

Can anyone cite an affordable-ish enthusiasts brand that isn't headed in this same direction?

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Wednesday 26th September 2007
quotequote all
Exactly, with buyers clammering to buy the Cayenne in the early days it showed Porsche what it's buyers wanted and the direction they need to take.

996 GT2/3 owners were forever griping about depreciation, now that they can't get a car?? If you look back at the number of aircooled "motorsport" based cars RS/GT2 produced, the numbers are smaller and it gives a halo effect for the brand.....CGT, great car, but they were clearly optimistic about how many $500k cars you can sell in a relatively short period of time.
Porsche is juat playing the game to what the majority of customers want, sadly these days the enthusiast buyer appears to be in the minority confused