996 for 25K ? ?
Author
Discussion

drfrank

Original Poster:

785 posts

233 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
Hi

I am deciding between purchasing a 911 (996) or M3 (E46). I have around 25K to play with and I am struggling to decide between the two.

Obviously I can get a much newer M3 (03/04) and my head is saying to go with the M3. My heart however says get the 911 !!

My question is....for 25K are the 911s around at that price complete dogs or can a gem be found ?
My gut instinct is to go with the M3, save my pennies and get the 911 in a couple of years.

Any thoughts ?

Thanks

Koln-RS

4,129 posts

243 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
Personally, unless I need a bit more rear room, I would go for the 996.

You might need to stretch your budget a bit, but worth looking for as late and low mileage as possible 3.6 'facelift' with good spec and full OPC history and extended warranty. Warranty can be added if it passes the OPC inspection at £895 pa.

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
You should be able to find a really nice '99 with the warranty already on for that kind of money ... It's a no brainer.

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
You don't state a preference for tip/man/coupe/cab but this opc warranted '99 is the sort of car you can get ..

It's been on a while , surely a good buy if you put in a cheeky offer of £24.5k boxedin



http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/181163.htm

stubbsy996

785 posts

244 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
drfrank said:
Hi

I am deciding between purchasing a 911 (996) or M3 (E46). I have around 25K to play with and I am struggling to decide between the two.

Obviously I can get a much newer M3 (03/04) and my head is saying to go with the M3. My heart however says get the 911 !!

My question is....for 25K are the 911s around at that price complete dogs or can a gem be found ?
My gut instinct is to go with the M3, save my pennies and get the 911 in a couple of years.

Any thoughts ?

Thanks


I had same dilemma at similar money when I bought mine, 996 C2 or M3. My heart ruled my head and went for the 911. No regrets and having had the 911 for over a year now no desire now to own an M3!
For 25k you should find a 996 (pre face lift) in good condition with not too high a mileage. Good luck and look forward to hearing what you decided/what you bought.

drfrank

Original Poster:

785 posts

233 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice !

I know little about the 911 (996) so I am unsure as to which variant would be best.

What are the servicing costs involved and how regularly ?

Practicality....what is the boot like, will the golfclubs go in ? will a large suitcase fit?

Easy enough to drive ?

I have driven an M3 and found it harsh particularly on the donkey tracks they call roads over here (Ireland) how does the Porsche compare ?

Thanks

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
You're opening a can of worms drfrank...

The majority on this forum would suggest to go for a C2 manual Coupe as it's the classig 911, lighter than the C4 and with the driver's choice of a gear box. All a matter of personal preferences though. Go for a test drive of different variants and decide for yourself.

If you're driving on "donkey roads" then stay away from the sports suspension. Make sure the interior has the full leather pack as the plastic on the earlier 996's looks cheap. There are gazillions of factory options which can make up a significant part of the original purchase price (10k is nothing unusual). Worth checking what you want and what your desired car actually has.

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
I got a great 996 for less than 25k - ran it for about a year with it only needing a battery, and sold it on - as far as i know its still running strong.

IMHO the 996 and M3 are very different cars with similar performances - depending on your practicality requirements.

I'd go for the Porsche every time, but thats me - try both and see which suits you best.

JKay

573 posts

232 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
Hey DFrank

Firstly this is a Porsche forum so I'd definately say 911 smile

I had a very similar dilemma recently, and have decided that when I get one it will be the 996.

It was more like what my heart felt really. The 996 just made me "feel" better, and I cant really explain why

Servicing wise theres not much between them (in fact I think its cheaper to service a 996if you compare the major service, M3 costs upwards of £800 for insp 2), and my mate who went from M3 to 996 said the 996 returns better MPG.

I also didnt need the extra space in the rear etc so thought the 996 would be the better choice for me

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
drfrank said:
I know little about the 911 (996) so I am unsure as to which variant would be best.
If you want the experience of having a drivers car , and want to drive the dang thing , then C2 coupe manual (my opinion)

drfrank said:
What are the servicing costs involved and how regularly ?
Less than an M!! .. Service every year , about £300 for a 12k service and £600 for a 24k. Factor for tyres , brakes and incidentals .. You'll get em , it's a 10 year old car.

drfrank said:
Practicality....what is the boot like, will the golfclubs go in ? will a large suitcase fit?
Put the clubs in the rear seats with the seat backs folded. Medium wheelie bin bag will fit in the luggage compartment , the C4 has about 30% less front compartment luggage space than the C2


drfrank said:
Easy enough to drive ?
Yes .. Easy to tip around in , won't bite yer arse unless you provoke it , daily driver no problem

drfrank said:
I have driven an M3 and found it harsh particularly on the donkey tracks they call roads over here (Ireland) how does the Porsche compare ?
I had a 996 for 2 years , and live in Ireland , absolutely no problems with the roads.
The M3 is slightly harsher.


One big advantage over the BMW is that the porsche warranty is way ahead .. Get a car that's already on a warranty , and it's like driving one off a Porsche forecourt .. without that horrible 'recently shafted' feeling in your nethers!!


drfrank

Original Poster:

785 posts

233 months

Saturday 29th September 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the info !

Just need to find the right one....


Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Sunday 30th September 2007
quotequote all
drfrank said:
Just need to find the right one....
911&P.W. did a very good buyers guide a bout 3 years ago .. It'd still be available to buy through their publishers.
One thing I would say is don't dive in , make yourself as informed as possible , they're a bloody fabulous car , but there's plenty of neglected dogs out there for sale posing as 'mint condition' porkers..

Pm me if you're looking for more info , Doc.. Always happy to help a fellow countryman if I can!


drfrank

Original Poster:

785 posts

233 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
Where would you suggest I start looking ?

At my price range I would guess Porsche approved would be a waste of time.

I have seen a couple of specialist 911 dealers: 911virgin etc

Has anyone got any experience with these dealers ?

Thanks

Drfrank

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
Trawl the classifieds on here and autotrader.

At this budget any indy or garage is going to be selling a dog - you'll get a lot more for your money privately, you'll just need patience and care.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
At this budget any indy or garage is going to be selling a dog.

That's rubbish, there will be good ones at (independent) dealers for £25k and less. There will (as privately) be not-so-good ones too. A good specialist should give a decent description and provide an honest trustworthy service though, as their reputation depends on it. This is admittedly less likely with a bread-and-butter used car dealer who knows little about the brand and is just selling on something he bought to "smoke round in" himself before he has to spend any money on it.

Fidgits said:
you'll get a lot more for your money privately, you'll just need patience and care.
I don't know about a "lot" but sure this is usually the case due to the increased rick and lack of come-back, but there will still be a variety of quality out there and most private sellers always describe their cars as lovely. Usually this is because it was when they bought it and having lived with it everyday they haven't noticed any deterioration as much as a fresh set of eyes would (understandable but still annoying if you've gone to the trouble of viewing it and it's a big let down from what you expected).

There will be good cars out there from various sources. Find a good one from a source you're comfortable dealing with, get an OPC warranty and go enjoy!

73 Duchess

346 posts

249 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
drfrank,
Was in the market for a 996 seriously for the last 6 months but had been toying with the idea for a lot longer. I too am in Ireland and had considered an M3 and ZM Coupe. Had the same budget as yourself. Also recieved a lot of good and invalueble advice on here and off Ballcock. Bought my 996 last week and haven't looked back. 996 all the way I'm afraidcool.

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
thegoose said:
Fidgits said:
At this budget any indy or garage is going to be selling a dog.

That's rubbish, there will be good ones at (independent) dealers for £25k and less. There will (as privately) be not-so-good ones too. A good specialist should give a decent description and provide an honest trustworthy service though, as their reputation depends on it. This is admittedly less likely with a bread-and-butter used car dealer who knows little about the brand and is just selling on something he bought to "smoke round in" himself before he has to spend any money on it.

Fidgits said:
you'll get a lot more for your money privately, you'll just need patience and care.
I don't know about a "lot" but sure this is usually the case due to the increased rick and lack of come-back, but there will still be a variety of quality out there and most private sellers always describe their cars as lovely. Usually this is because it was when they bought it and having lived with it everyday they haven't noticed any deterioration as much as a fresh set of eyes would (understandable but still annoying if you've gone to the trouble of viewing it and it's a big let down from what you expected).

There will be good cars out there from various sources. Find a good one from a source you're comfortable dealing with, get an OPC warranty and go enjoy!
My opinions were based on first hand experiences - okay, perhaps over 12 months old - but still valid IMO.

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
If you think you can get a 04 BMW M3 for £25k then go for that. I looked at 1998-1999 pre-facelift 996s and they looked shabby to be honest and i would be wary of paying 25k for a car that you may not be able to get a Porsche warranty on in a years time as from what i have heard - things can get really expensive.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
Mine is going up this week. It was the cover car for Total911 issue 1.

2000 W Carrera 2 Tip
70k miles
Vesuvius grey, full graphite leather
Porsche warranty
Full Porsche history with every invoice from new.
Big spec.

I'll be looking for around 26k.

Have a look at my profile.



Edited by Vesuvius 996 on Monday 1st October 15:34

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Monday 1st October 2007
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
My opinions were based on first hand experiences - okay, perhaps over 12 months old - but still valid IMO.
Fair enough, but prices will have come down in the last 12 months. So I'm right then wink