Yet another person who needs some buying advice......
Discussion
Please help me out folks.
I’ve been saving the pennies, doing the research, taking the test drives, but I simply cannot decide what to go for.
The criteria – well, it’s got to have six cylinders and have a manual gearbox (and its obviously got to be a Porsche). Why a Porsche? Well, I’ve tried most flavours of sports car apart from it and having spent the past year or so reading this forum, while I knew that in my mind I HAD to have one one day, it really does seem from the tales that I’ve been reading on here that I am missing out on something pretty special and should take the plunge sooner rather than later.
I’m not totally alien to what the driving/ownership experience might be like – I owned a mk1 Clio v6 which I then traded for an Elise 111R so the mid/rear engine thing – and rear wheel drive driving style - is something I’m familiar with. Trouble is, with the Clio you always had in the back of your mind it MIGHT one day try to kill you going round the same bend in the same manner you always used to, and with the Elise, it was amazing, but perhaps just a bit too raw….. It went for an Audi A3 3.2 that I’ve currently got but have just sold privately, so perhaps those few cars tell you a little bit about the type of car I go for when buying.
So, its time for some Porsche, but here lays my problem. I’ve got about £22/23k, which would appear to buy anything from an early 996, through to a Boxster (S, I might add), down to a 993 (actually not totally desperate for one of these) or – for a fair bit less, a 964. I have to say, from everything I’ve read my heart is steering me to a 964 C2, as late as I can find one. This leads me on to another point/problem though. Every car I’ve ever owned has been next-to-brand-new. I can’t afford a new Porsche, fact. But, I could afford a 5 year old Boxster S with 30k miles on it – that wouldn’t scare me. I think I could also stomach an early 996 with about 60k on it – seems I could get one of those for my budget too. A 964 on the other hand – well, doesn’t seem that there’s many with less than 100k on the clock – and I know that you should buy on condition not miles at this point – but it’s still something that has obviously gone totally against my thinking so far. I’ve always had cars that have been pretty new, covered by manufacturers’ warranties and as a result the thought that they might go wrong or breakdown has been a long way in the back of my mind.
I’m not particularly mechanically minded: I could change oil and filters no problem but beyond that I’m stumped, so doing my own maintenance and sorting out things that went wrong from time to time would not really be possible for me. That said, I’m realistic enough to know that any of the cars I’ve mentioned are relatively “exotic” so a couple of grand a year on maintenance for something that in return will deliver – I hope – more ownership satisfaction than I’ve ever had from a car to date is something that is worth bearing I reckon.
It won’t be used during the week (so again, another reason why it need not be so brand new) but it’ll have to sit outside on the road as I don’t have a garage. It’ll have to do a few track days a year too (obviously).
If you were in my situation, what would you get?.....
Thanks in advance, Tim.
I’ve been saving the pennies, doing the research, taking the test drives, but I simply cannot decide what to go for.
The criteria – well, it’s got to have six cylinders and have a manual gearbox (and its obviously got to be a Porsche). Why a Porsche? Well, I’ve tried most flavours of sports car apart from it and having spent the past year or so reading this forum, while I knew that in my mind I HAD to have one one day, it really does seem from the tales that I’ve been reading on here that I am missing out on something pretty special and should take the plunge sooner rather than later.
I’m not totally alien to what the driving/ownership experience might be like – I owned a mk1 Clio v6 which I then traded for an Elise 111R so the mid/rear engine thing – and rear wheel drive driving style - is something I’m familiar with. Trouble is, with the Clio you always had in the back of your mind it MIGHT one day try to kill you going round the same bend in the same manner you always used to, and with the Elise, it was amazing, but perhaps just a bit too raw….. It went for an Audi A3 3.2 that I’ve currently got but have just sold privately, so perhaps those few cars tell you a little bit about the type of car I go for when buying.
So, its time for some Porsche, but here lays my problem. I’ve got about £22/23k, which would appear to buy anything from an early 996, through to a Boxster (S, I might add), down to a 993 (actually not totally desperate for one of these) or – for a fair bit less, a 964. I have to say, from everything I’ve read my heart is steering me to a 964 C2, as late as I can find one. This leads me on to another point/problem though. Every car I’ve ever owned has been next-to-brand-new. I can’t afford a new Porsche, fact. But, I could afford a 5 year old Boxster S with 30k miles on it – that wouldn’t scare me. I think I could also stomach an early 996 with about 60k on it – seems I could get one of those for my budget too. A 964 on the other hand – well, doesn’t seem that there’s many with less than 100k on the clock – and I know that you should buy on condition not miles at this point – but it’s still something that has obviously gone totally against my thinking so far. I’ve always had cars that have been pretty new, covered by manufacturers’ warranties and as a result the thought that they might go wrong or breakdown has been a long way in the back of my mind.
I’m not particularly mechanically minded: I could change oil and filters no problem but beyond that I’m stumped, so doing my own maintenance and sorting out things that went wrong from time to time would not really be possible for me. That said, I’m realistic enough to know that any of the cars I’ve mentioned are relatively “exotic” so a couple of grand a year on maintenance for something that in return will deliver – I hope – more ownership satisfaction than I’ve ever had from a car to date is something that is worth bearing I reckon.
It won’t be used during the week (so again, another reason why it need not be so brand new) but it’ll have to sit outside on the road as I don’t have a garage. It’ll have to do a few track days a year too (obviously).
If you were in my situation, what would you get?.....
Thanks in advance, Tim.
I'd recommend driving as many of the cars you fancy to see what you think from the driving seat.
If it were me I'd either go for a 3.2 which are a lot cheaper than your budget but a more involving driving experience, extremely reliable and the cheapest for maintenance. I'd probably spend a few quid on a re-map (+20bhp or so) and suspension etc to make it drive more like a Club Sport version which is absolutely fantastic on track. Or I'd choose a 993 - again more reliable than a 964 but mainly because I prefer the shape.
If it were me I'd either go for a 3.2 which are a lot cheaper than your budget but a more involving driving experience, extremely reliable and the cheapest for maintenance. I'd probably spend a few quid on a re-map (+20bhp or so) and suspension etc to make it drive more like a Club Sport version which is absolutely fantastic on track. Or I'd choose a 993 - again more reliable than a 964 but mainly because I prefer the shape.
Haven't driven a 993 or 964, but did have an early 996 with optional factory sports pack (lower suspension/LSD/Traction control/18" wheels/Sports seats)and would thoroughly recommend that if you can find one for the money.
Plenty fast enough and pretty involving to drive, at least IMO.
Anyway good luck whatever you go for.
Plenty fast enough and pretty involving to drive, at least IMO.
Anyway good luck whatever you go for.
With your budget I would heartily recommend either a 964 very low mileage pampered example and a nice big chunk of change to spend on the car and really make it as good as it should be, or a 996/boxster.
The 996 is probably the best financial buy, but the 964 will be something special.
You would just get in to a 964 turbo LHD at that budget.....Buy carefuly though.
The 996 is probably the best financial buy, but the 964 will be something special.
You would just get in to a 964 turbo LHD at that budget.....Buy carefuly though.
tim79 said:
Please help me out folks.
So, its time for some Porsche, but here lays my problem. I’ve got about £22/23k, which would appear to buy anything from an early 996, through to a Boxster (S, I might add), down to a 993 (actually not totally desperate for one of these) or – for a fair bit less, a 964. I have to say, from everything I’ve read my heart is steering me to a 964 C2, as late as I can find one. This leads me on to another point/problem though. Every car I’ve ever owned has been next-to-brand-new. I can’t afford a new Porsche, fact. But, I could afford a 5 year old Boxster S with 30k miles on it – that wouldn’t scare me. I think I could also stomach an early 996 with about 60k on it – seems I could get one of those for my budget too. A 964 on the other hand – well, doesn’t seem that there’s many with less than 100k on the clock – and I know that you should buy on condition not miles at this point – but it’s still something that has obviously gone totally against my thinking so far. I’ve always had cars that have been pretty new, covered by manufacturers’ warranties and as a result the thought that they might go wrong or breakdown has been a long way in the back of my mind.
Tim,So, its time for some Porsche, but here lays my problem. I’ve got about £22/23k, which would appear to buy anything from an early 996, through to a Boxster (S, I might add), down to a 993 (actually not totally desperate for one of these) or – for a fair bit less, a 964. I have to say, from everything I’ve read my heart is steering me to a 964 C2, as late as I can find one. This leads me on to another point/problem though. Every car I’ve ever owned has been next-to-brand-new. I can’t afford a new Porsche, fact. But, I could afford a 5 year old Boxster S with 30k miles on it – that wouldn’t scare me. I think I could also stomach an early 996 with about 60k on it – seems I could get one of those for my budget too. A 964 on the other hand – well, doesn’t seem that there’s many with less than 100k on the clock – and I know that you should buy on condition not miles at this point – but it’s still something that has obviously gone totally against my thinking so far. I’ve always had cars that have been pretty new, covered by manufacturers’ warranties and as a result the thought that they might go wrong or breakdown has been a long way in the back of my mind.
As a current 3.2 Carrera owner (my second), having come from an Audi S3, plus having owned a 993 C4 and driven friends Boxster S and 996 C2 I'll give you my view.
3.2 Carrera - great value £16k+ will get you a top example (they're availble for less but you'll often need to renew oil pipes, shocks, clutch etc) very reliable, quite heavy (due to no PAS) but a great car with a raw driving experince and relatiely cheap to run due to mechanical simplicity and zero depreciation.
Suggest 3.2 Coupe 1987-89.
964 - great value, similar price to 3.2 Carrera, but running costs are slightly higher. All the initial 964 tappit issues etc should have been upgraded by now on a decent car. Great drive, newer feel with ABS, PAS. Suggest C2 Coupe manual.
993 - more modern than the 3.2/964, cheaper to run than the 964, reliable, fast and a nice drive. Prices are strong £25k+ for a good one so not as good value as above but low depreciation. Suggest C2 Coupe manual.
996 - most up to date, smooth and fast drive if not as involving as a 993/864/3.2.
Higher depreciation, not as well built as early cars and reliability issues on some cars. Prices have been hit and are below 993 due to reliability concerns and pre-facelift image being a little bland.
Boxster S - great all rounder, quick, great drive, modern feel. Some reliability issues with RMS which are easily fixed. Victim of it's own success as they've sold so many it's a buyers market so there's are alot of good cars to choose from at low prices £20k+. Suggest a facelift 2003 model with glass window.
If you buy on condition, get a check done and look at receipts to see what was done recently you should be fine, don't discount well cared for cars due to mileage just adjust the price accordingley and use the money you've saved to get it running perfectly.
If it was my £22/23k and I was using it at the weekends then I'd go:
3.2 Carrera - fun, cost to run and budget plus you won't loose money
993 - high miler in good condition
Boxster S - value for £, soft top, modern, but likely to be harder to resell
964 - fun, low depreciation now
996 - wouldn't due to image, reliability and depreciation (all above are better)
As you haven't got a garage, attempting to preserve an older car like a 3.2 Carerra parked outside and not used during the week could be very demoralising! I tried it years ago and it wasn't a good experience. So I'd be inclined to take the easy option of a relatively new Boxster S. Age will be on its side.
Thanks all of you very much, interesting to hear what you'd do with the cash. I hadn't mentioned a 3.2, but had certainly thought about one too. You're right on the 964, from what I've read, they seem to be about the most expensive mainstream Porsche to service regularly but that doesn't make it any easier for head to rule over heart!!!
And without wishing to sound like a complete wuss, is it really not going to hurt an older model 911 keeping it outside in all weathers - because I really don't have much of an option unfortunately!....
And without wishing to sound like a complete wuss, is it really not going to hurt an older model 911 keeping it outside in all weathers - because I really don't have much of an option unfortunately!....
Per annum servicing for my 91 964 is c.600 as all the heavy work has already been done. Coupled with insurance of 500 fully comp limited miles makes the 964, in my opinion, a fairly reasonably cheap runner (and arguably more engaging and pure than a boxster). you can buy a good one for 18 and use the remaining for insurance and servicing and you still have plenty enough change for mods etc
g7jhp said:
Tim,
All my 3.2's have lived outside with no adverse effects as long as the bodywork is sound you'll be fine. Don't let it put you off by keeping a 911 on the street.
GP
You can get away with it for a daily driver, but not a weekend toy that sits outside on the street all week. Lots of rusty ones around to prove it! All my 3.2's have lived outside with no adverse effects as long as the bodywork is sound you'll be fine. Don't let it put you off by keeping a 911 on the street.
GP
Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



