Noise like a Supercharger
Noise like a Supercharger
Author
Discussion

noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all

My 2002 986 S has developed a supercharger noise. It's most noisy after cold start and can be heard mainly between 1500 and 3000 rpm. Clutch in or out makes no difference, so not gearbox. Not speed related, so not a bearing. Car also seems a little slow to lock/unlock, but that could be my imagination. It was slow to turn over after being left for a fortnight. What so you think, alternator bearing on the way out? How do I diagnose further?

In fact the noise has always been there, but recently it's become noisier. I had put it down to the emissions pump. Doh!

The air con has also stopped working, but I've not had that on for ages, so that pump shouldn't be engaged/turning.

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
I think the Air Con pump spins whenever the engine is on.
I would say to stick your head in the engine bay and listen ... but I know thats not possible on new Porsche's is it.

japhilip

5,374 posts

229 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Sounds like a bearing wearing on something that's attached to the engine. Alternator, waterpump? Possibly cam belt (if it has one) is too tight. I'm no expert with these cars, far from it, and would suggest you get it looked at sooner rather than later.

935

250 posts

252 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Try the fan belt!

noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
The air con pump has two parts, the main pump and the wheel that connects to the belt. It's only engaged when turned on with an electromagnetic lock. I could be wrong, but I don't think the wheel on it's own is under enough strain to make such a noise.

It's not a fanbelt noise, but a mechanical bearing whine noise. There is only one belt on a 986 and that is self tensioning. It was replaced with a new belt 2,000 miles ago.

I can get to the engine bay, but it's fiddly. Open top half way, disconnect two line clips, disconnect two dust cover clips, move bottom of roof up. Remove rear storage bin by removing two twist clips. Remove two more twist clips and rear carpet. Undo five more clips and the engine cover lifts out. This is what you need to do to check the PAS fluid.

Unfortunately, the belt is behind the rear bulkhead which isn't as easy. This is accessed by sliding the rear seats forward. Taking out the rear carpet, again this is twist clips. Then the tin plate over the engine is secured by around a dozen small bolts.

Edited by noumenon on Monday 8th October 10:58

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Many years back I had a car with a noisy wheel bearing on one of the back wheels. My mechanic had a bit of a listen, and decided it wasnt too bad, didn't need sorting right away, and told me turn my radio up a bit to cover the noise.

6 months later I went back and said I think it's time I had the bearing done.
He was a little shocked and couldn't believe that I hadn't got it done by now.

My explanation was simple... my radio was on full volume and I could hear the bearing whine again.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all


Check the Pentosin level.

If it's low then the power steering pump growls.


noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all

Actually checked the pentosin before the last journey. I had a PAS pump pack up as it had run dry. Strangley my pump failed with no warning whine. So that's a new part and has plenty of the green stuff.

ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
i have a similar noise on my 944 turbo and basicaly had to strip the alternator belt, followed by power steering belt which left 2 options..tight cam belt which the chap said in an earlier message or the waterpump..further checks leave me confident that its the water pump bearing and thus ive brought a new waterpump ready to go on, but u are right, it does sound like a damn supercharger,

noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all

What's the process to test an alternator? Is it possible to turn it by hand and hear the noise.

How about the charging? Would that be impacted if the bearing was going? Or is it just purely noise? If the charging is impacted, how is that tested?

ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
hi there, if you took the belt off and the noise is gone, that would suggest the alternator bearing is suspect. As for spinning it by hand and listening to it..."well if its really Fxxxxd you will hear it grinding.but its hard to turn it fast enough manually to determine noise faults.

As to your second question..if the alternator is noisey it still can be running fine..i.e output charge rate will be fine , just be a noisey nusiance thats all. With regards to checking th output , its easy, simply buy a decent volt metre that does Volts, Amps, Watss etc.

They cost bout a tenner. connect across the battery red lead to the + and black to the - on the battery. if the alternator is ok it should be carging between at least 13 to 14 volts..sometimes up to 15 is normal. when u switch ur head lights and heater on it should drop to no less than 13.. try an make sure the revs are held between 1000 and 1500 revs. If it does that means its not charging under load. if u still stuk tex me on 07761502213 ill put u right.good luck

Edited by ash7764 on Wednesday 10th October 12:17

noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Wednesday 10th October 2007
quotequote all

Thanks Ash. I have a multimeter, so I'll check out the charging voltage tonight.

The belt drives everything, including the water pump. Hence it can't be disconnected in iolation.

Fortunately I don't need to use the car daily, so I have time to figure it out.

noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all

The Durametric tester I ordered arrived yesterday. While the car was running, voltage was between 13.98V and 14.02V. Didn't seem to make any difference on RPM or what was turned on (headlights, radio, and so on).

Next step, I'll try a regular multimeter. Though looks like it's just a bearing and not impacting how it works (assuming it is the alternator).

noumenon

Original Poster:

1,282 posts

235 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all

The Durametric tester I ordered arrived yesterday. While the car was running, voltage was between 13.98V and 14.02V. Didn't seem to make any difference on RPM or what was turned on (headlights, radio, and so on).

Next step, I'll try a regular multimeter. Though looks like it's just a bearing and not impacting how it works (assuming it is the alternator).

ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
output voltage seems to be fine, im sure your battery is being replenished at a decent rate. investigate further or might be time to just get a second professional opinion, unfortunately without be able to see the vehicle it gets a bit difficult for acurate diagnosis. good luck