Flat 8
Author
Discussion

arej

Original Poster:

425 posts

233 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
How come Porsche have never(?) made a flat 8 engine for their cars, would that not be an advantage or a natural progression from the flat 6? Is there something about the flat 8 which doesn't work or is not mechanically efficient as it is never used? I'm not saying it is something that would be used in the 911 but even in more exclusive models like the Carrera GT or the 959, or even instead of the V8 in the cayman!

Rawhide

980 posts

244 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
It appears there already is a Porsche Flat 8

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat-8


zaktoo

805 posts

238 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
They have had flat 8s, in the 908, and even a 906 had a flat 8 in one of the variants. And of course a flat 12 in the 917.

arej

Original Poster:

425 posts

233 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
OK in which case a change in question, why has it only been used in racing cars as opposed to road cars?

lightweight

1,165 posts

279 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
it suited the rules at the time. most porsche engins are developed in racing flat 8 was technical dead end after the rules alowed 5litre cars as long as 25 were hermologated

Rawhide

980 posts

244 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm guessing it's down to design costs. It would have to be wider taking up more room in the cabin. Also boxer flat engines are more expensive to desing than traditional layouts.

I'd suggest the engine may not be as well balanced either. Maybe not an issue in race cars but more of a concern in road cars.

Edited by Rawhide on Monday 8th October 15:20

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
lightweight said:
hermologated
that sounds like a painful operation.

i dont think its immediately obvious why a flat 8 is out the question, i mean it would only add about 120mm in length to the 6, scumbaru flat 4's are balanced enough for a road car so no reason a flat 8 shouldnt be and without changing anything else take it out to 4.8L - 550bhp n/a hehe smile OMG!

hot66

700 posts

248 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
arej said:
.... or even instead of the V8 in the cayman!
you do realise the cayman doesn't have a V8 don't you ? wink


arej

Original Poster:

425 posts

233 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Oops, I thought that was weird too, I'm sure I read it somewhere!! whistle

Loach

3,357 posts

247 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
hot66 said:
arej said:
.... or even instead of the V8 in the cayman!
you do realise the cayman doesn't have a V8 don't you ? wink
He does now. Personally, I think a Porsche flat-8 would be ace. Be lovely to see one in the Panamera, though I'm sure they won't bother. Be lovely if a flat-8 gave off a small flat-4 that could be used in a little Porsche open club racer, but I'm sure that wouldn't appeal to the Porsche board either. After the Panamera, I would expect to see a cross-over SUV thingy taking up their time and development resources. Which is a bit sad.

zaktoo

805 posts

238 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
The engine for the Panemera will be a V8 developed from the V8 in the Cayenne.

arej

Original Poster:

425 posts

233 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
zaktoo said:
The engine for the Panemera will be a V8 developed from the V8 in the Cayenne.
Sure you don't mean the cayman tongue out. Shame it won't be a flat 8, I agree Loach!

lightweight

1,165 posts

279 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
Porsche should build a flat 4 under 2 litre open sports car/ club racer, run a one make seris for it. It should weigh in at 950 all in no elec no aircon options FIA cage and kit. base price should be Circa £28K

They wont do it but it would help them meet there emissions targets

carreraboy

826 posts

249 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
It's difficult enough with the weight of 6 pots hanging over the rear wheels? When Porsche go 998 sure it will be an all new mid-engined V8 a la Audi R8 with the Carrera GT v10 to follow the next generation 911!

Loach

3,357 posts

247 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
lightweight said:
Porsche should build a flat 4 under 2 litre open sports car/ club racer, run a one make seris for it. It should weigh in at 950 all in no elec no aircon options FIA cage and kit. base price should be Circa £28K
My thoughts exactly. I'd buy one of those. Though you did forget that it will cost 28k basic, 35k with a few extra horsepower, and with short shift, LSD, battery cut off, race seats and a few other bits, it'll cost 45k.

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
arej said:
OK in which case a change in question, why has it only been used in racing cars as opposed to road cars?
Porsche did build a road-going 914/8 as a birthday present for the Professor. It was in the Design Museum exhibition a few years ago.

SS7

lightweight

1,165 posts

279 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
I hav seen the 914 that had a 2.7 RS engine in it that was built for ferry but never saw a flat 8 in anything other than the hilclibe 910 and the race 908

This link may interest you all sold now but I know where there is a 917 engin if you want one.
http://www.pelicanparts.com/vasekauction/engine_in...

It shows both Flat 8 engin designes

Edited by lightweight on Monday 8th October 17:32


Edited by lightweight on Monday 8th October 17:33

65 mat

86 posts

231 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
[quote=carreraboy]It's difficult enough with the weight of 6 pots hanging over the rear wheels? When Porsche go 998 sure it will be an all new mid-engined V8 a la Audi R8 with the Carrera GT v10 to follow the next generation 911!
Interesting comments! Could be worth a bet actually Des !!!wink

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
carreraboy said:
It's difficult enough with the weight of 6 pots hanging over the rear wheels? When Porsche go 998 sure it will be an all new mid-engined V8 a la Audi R8 with the Carrera GT v10 to follow the next generation 911!
Turning the Carrera in an upgraded Cayman?

martin thomas

1,079 posts

262 months

Monday 8th October 2007
quotequote all
surely a flat 8 would be to heavy to hang out over the ass of a 911 it's took decades to get the 911 to handle properly so i'm assuming it would be a recipe for disaster..