From Cayman to 997
From Cayman to 997
Author
Discussion

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Hello all,

Going to upgrade the Cayman to a 997. Decided on a manual, 2 not a 4 and an S not a non-S. As for the spec, the S is pretty well up there for me, but I would also like the sports exhaust, BOSE and Nav as a minimum. Other options such as sports seats, different wheels and a sunroof are certainly nice.

I may appear to be be alone on this forum in thinking that the OPCs provide a service that is worth the cut and profit they make, but I suspect are more than those who are vocal due to the fact they're in business! The bid price for mine has been consistent across 3 OPCs in different parts of the country (£36 for those wondering) and about what I was expecting so it's just down to finding the right car in the network.

We've been looking around and although there are a lot in the network it's difficult to find precisely what you want (hence the advantage & cost of buying new!) but we've come across a few. One of them seems right, but (on different thread) 1 year old and being the 4th owner seems "not right", even though it only has 6k miles. Another dealer had one for the same price, with our minimum and similarly well specced, but newer, 1 owner and with less mileage. Asking the salesman more questions, the mileage jumped from 3k to 5k and all the carbon interior disappeared (previous owner removed it). All of a sudden, it's not so attractive (and I don't have too much faith in the dealer, particularly when they're 300 miles drive away just to see it).

So this is where I am. New, second hand, OPC, indie, private. Who knows! I just know I want one smile I'm ok to pay for OPC service and reassurance, but if they don't have one and I'm not comfortable..?

Anyway onto Erik's thoughts:
Erik997 said:
However, make sure you buy well as 997s are depreciating at a horrible rate. I've lost a stack on mine already and with the facelift around the corner you need to make sure you get the right spec at the right price or otherwise you're guaranteeing yourself a big loss and a pain to shift it in 2-3 years.

New/used OPC cars are in for a big loss so I'd be staying well clear and buying a good private.
Anyone care to add their opinion?

Thanks

Ben

GregE240

10,857 posts

298 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Ben, the only thing that makes me wince about buying from an OPC mate is knowing full well that anything they might wish to sell you has been bought at rock bottom prices and sold on to you, the potential punter at a huge profit. Now, I appreciate that they've got a business to run, but FFS, you're going to take it there for routine servicing, and God knows they make their corn out of that, too.

As far as I know, you can purchase the Porsche warranty separately so the prospect of saving a bundle and buying private seems a good idea.

Thats my tuppence. I know of at least 2 people who took baths at Porsche dealers, and their cars were sold on for considerably more.

Irish

3,991 posts

270 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
GregE240 said:
Ben, the only thing that makes me wince about buying from an OPC mate is knowing full well that anything they might wish to sell you has been bought at rock bottom prices and sold on to you, the potential punter at a huge profit. Now, I appreciate that they've got a business to run, but FFS, you're going to take it there for routine servicing, and God knows they make their corn out of that, too.

As far as I know, you can purchase the Porsche warranty separately so the prospect of saving a bundle and buying private seems a good idea.

Thats my tuppence. I know of at least 2 people who took baths at Porsche dealers, and their cars were sold on for considerably more.
Northway have a nice 996 turbo?

Personally I would sell private and buy cash but that is often not worth the hassel. I would not restrict myself to an OPC. Try Uncle Henry.....you never know?

Jacko99

74 posts

237 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Ben - can't believe you are selling your treasured Cayman. Presumably you are the author of the website "pikey.net"?

I have a very similar cayman to yours and I too have been thinking about what I will upgrade it to - although I am about 18 months away from a change as I bought it new from an OPC in March 07.

Out of interest, what's made you decide to go for a 997? I am not convinced that it will be a massive jump from your Cayman and it seems difficult to justify the extra cost - presumably an extra £20k at least?

Anyhoot, I wish you luck. I agree with your sentiments re service from OPC - I got mine from Solihull and the services was excellent.

That said, I would always put saving money above getting a bottle of moet from an OPC!

Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Can I suggest that you try to borrow one for a day before you make the decision.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Do this…

phone Hello, Herr Ruf..? Yeah, I have a Cayman that’s not quick enough…

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Having gone from 986S to 997S two things changed:

- the driving feel was very different due to change in layout
- there was substantially more oomph

As you're upgrading from a Cayman S, the power hike will be smaller. Having driven the Cayman S and the 997S back to back, I think the difference is there but not massively big. You should ask yourself if you are looking for more power and/or a very different driving feel/experience. If it's only about the former, then there are a number of options to make your existing car faster. One of them Podie outlined:

Podie said:
Do this…

phone Hello, Herr Ruf..? Yeah, I have a Cayman that’s not quick enough…

Irish

3,991 posts

270 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Dr S said:
Having gone from 986S to 997S two things changed:

- the driving feel was very different due to change in layout
- there was substantially more oomph

As you're upgrading from a Cayman S, the power hike will be smaller. Having driven the Cayman S and the 997S back to back, I think the difference is there but not massively big. You should ask yourself if you are looking for more power and/or a very different driving feel/experience. If it's only about the former, then there are a number of options to make your existing car faster. One of them Podie outlined:

Podie said:
Do this…

phone Hello, Herr Ruf..? Yeah, I have a Cayman that’s not quick enough…
If it is power, 996 turbo. I think the depreciation will hit less and you can still get a warranty....

Then, in 2 years,

Hello, Mr. Ruf, I have this Turbo.....

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
More than a bit suprised after your continued defence of the Cayman,,please don't say they wore you down in the end?

Having driven both I would take the Cayman S, the only factor I can see weighing in favour of the 997 is if you need the 2 little rear seats.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Jacko99 said:
Presumably you are the author of the website "pikey.net"?
Close! pikeynet.com smile

Irish

3,991 posts

270 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Dr S said:
Having gone from 986S to 997S two things changed:

- the driving feel was very different due to change in layout
- there was substantially more oomph

As you're upgrading from a Cayman S, the power hike will be smaller. Having driven the Cayman S and the 997S back to back, I think the difference is there but not massively big. You should ask yourself if you are looking for more power and/or a very different driving feel/experience. If it's only about the former, then there are a number of options to make your existing car faster. One of them Podie outlined:

Podie said:
Do this…

phone Hello, Herr Ruf..? Yeah, I have a Cayman that’s not quick enough…
Herr Ruf is a miracle worker....you could try:

phone Hello, Herr Ruf..? Yeah, I have this loft conversion…

OFF-TOPIC: I am planning on a loft conversion, can you PM me you diary link and do you mind if I ping you some numpty questions?

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi Pikey, have you taken the 997 out for a test drive?If so, what did you think compared to your Cayman? Reason being is that i think the Boxsters/Caymans drive allot better than the 997's. Obviously the 997's are allot quicker on the straights but make sure that you are upgrading for the right reasons as you may end up feeling slighly disapointed. GT3's or TT's are a different kettle of fish but i found the 997 a bit too normal.

Note that it is the basic 997 i have taken out, not the 997S so there maybe a big difference.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Podie said:
Do this…

phone Hello, Herr Ruf..? Yeah, I have a Cayman that’s not quick enough…
yes

Pikey, lad. You might as well have a bonfire with 20k.

I want to change mine but it's just not worth the cost!! Keep it, get it RUF'ed and spend the 10k you'll save on Ecurie25.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Ok, a little clarification:

We absolutely LOVE the Cayman. I think it's really really great, still feels and drives like a new car. I still regard the options I chose back in Nov'05 to be bang on (for me!). Still gives me that grin, that buzz, that cloud9 when driving. I still look at it and say "wow". It's GREAT and I am a massive supporter of this excellent, excellent car. I'm happy with the purchase price, the running costs (£360 for a 2 year / 20k service!) and the depreciation (expectations aligned!).

However... it only has 2 seats. smile

We've just got (getting) a dog (lab puppy) and hence will use the Yaris more and more and the Cayman less and less. Makes sense to get a 4 seater sports car so when we do want to use the nice car, we can take the dog and aren't restricted.

We love the Porsche marque and haven't found anything else we want, hence it's a natural progression!

Actually I must say I did think drive was quite different to the Cayman and thoroughly enjoyed it.

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
You know the puppy will grow, right..? hehe

996/997 not really got enough room in it chap, you're in Cayenne territory. If you want the mutt with you, buy the proper dog basket and be done with it - Audi RS4 Avant.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
GregE240 said:
Ben, the only thing that makes me wince about buying from an OPC mate is knowing full well that anything they might wish to sell you has been bought at rock bottom prices and sold on to you, the potential punter at a huge profit.
I've mapped out how much they buy them for, sell them for, the interest, warranty costs, prepping costs, VAT, business tax, overheads, legal responsibilities... and the net profit is not as massive as you may think.

With this cost you are buying a service and personally I think that is 'may be' worth paying for. Of course if I don't buy then I never regarded the price as right..

My new Cayman went wrong lots when I bought it and the OPC looked after me very well. This piece of mind is important to me, particuarly for this kind of money.

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
Ok, a little clarification:

We absolutely LOVE the Cayman. I think it's really really great, still feels and drives like a new car. I still regard the options I chose back in Nov'05 to be bang on (for me!). Still gives me that grin, that buzz, that cloud9 when driving. I still look at it and say "wow". It's GREAT and I am a massive supporter of this excellent, excellent car. I'm happy with the purchase price, the running costs (£360 for a 2 year / 20k service!) and the depreciation (expectations aligned!).

However... it only has 2 seats. smile

We've just got (getting) a dog (lab puppy) and hence will use the Yaris more and more and the Cayman less and less. Makes sense to get a 4 seater sports car so when we do want to use the nice car, we can take the dog and aren't restricted.

We love the Porsche marque and haven't found anything else we want, hence it's a natural progression!

Actually I must say I did think drive was quite different to the Cayman and thoroughly enjoyed it.
Mate, just LISTEN to yourself hehe

You're going to burn 20k because you (meaning your other half) want to take a mangey diseaase ridden puppy out for a ride.

FFS buy a god damned Land Rover for a couple of grand.

You're bonkers!!

hehe






clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Huh, a dog in the back of a 997, fair enough for short trips, but will it not end up in the front of the car with you under braking and cornering if you enjoy the 997 as you should, the Yaris with hound in the back sounds like more fun to me!

Irish

3,991 posts

270 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Vesuvius 996 said:
pikey said:
Ok, a little clarification:

We absolutely LOVE the Cayman. I think it's really really great, still feels and drives like a new car. I still regard the options I chose back in Nov'05 to be bang on (for me!). Still gives me that grin, that buzz, that cloud9 when driving. I still look at it and say "wow". It's GREAT and I am a massive supporter of this excellent, excellent car. I'm happy with the purchase price, the running costs (£360 for a 2 year / 20k service!) and the depreciation (expectations aligned!).

However... it only has 2 seats. smile

We've just got (getting) a dog (lab puppy) and hence will use the Yaris more and more and the Cayman less and less. Makes sense to get a 4 seater sports car so when we do want to use the nice car, we can take the dog and aren't restricted.

We love the Porsche marque and haven't found anything else we want, hence it's a natural progression!

Actually I must say I did think drive was quite different to the Cayman and thoroughly enjoyed it.
Mate, just LISTEN to yourself hehe

You're going to burn 20k because you (meaning your other half) want to take a mangey diseaase ridden puppy out for a ride.

FFS buy a god damned Land Rover for a couple of grand.

You're bonkers!!

hehe
You just can buy that kind of wisdom. Soovy for prime minister

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Irish said:
Vesuvius 996 said:
pikey said:
Ok, a little clarification:

We absolutely LOVE the Cayman. I think it's really really great, still feels and drives like a new car. I still regard the options I chose back in Nov'05 to be bang on (for me!). Still gives me that grin, that buzz, that cloud9 when driving. I still look at it and say "wow". It's GREAT and I am a massive supporter of this excellent, excellent car. I'm happy with the purchase price, the running costs (£360 for a 2 year / 20k service!) and the depreciation (expectations aligned!).

However... it only has 2 seats. smile

We've just got (getting) a dog (lab puppy) and hence will use the Yaris more and more and the Cayman less and less. Makes sense to get a 4 seater sports car so when we do want to use the nice car, we can take the dog and aren't restricted.

We love the Porsche marque and haven't found anything else we want, hence it's a natural progression!

Actually I must say I did think drive was quite different to the Cayman and thoroughly enjoyed it.
Mate, just LISTEN to yourself hehe

You're going to burn 20k because you (meaning your other half) want to take a mangey diseaase ridden puppy out for a ride.

FFS buy a god damned Land Rover for a couple of grand.

You're bonkers!!

hehe
You just can buy that kind of wisdom. Soovy for prime minister
Selling your Porsche so that you can get a car to put your other half's puppy in. FFS!

Pikey = Pussy Blind AICM5P.

I bet your house is full of scatter cushions, wedding magazines and she's made you throw away all your scat porn as well.


hehe


(Sorry dude....)







Edited by Vesuvius 996 on Tuesday 9th October 10:14