Why Does Everyone Diss Boxsters?
Why Does Everyone Diss Boxsters?
Author
Discussion

car.chic

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?

I've found my Boxster S to be a great all round sports car, which loves to be driven hard and has extremely good capabilities, no it's not a 911 neither does it pretend to be, they're two different ball games entirely, when will others get it into their heads?

silver996

46 posts

235 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
they wont

NEXT!

AdamT

2,825 posts

283 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Dont let it get to you- often these people are jealous.

Just keep enjoying the boxster for what it is, a fantastic machine.

best,
adam

Edited by AdamT on Tuesday 9th October 11:37

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?
Jealousy. Nothing more, nothing less.

They're also a bit too common for their own good (image wise that is)

car.chic

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?
Jealousy. Nothing more, nothing less.

They're also a bit too common for their own good (image wise that is)
Just seen your profile, beautiful car lick Very jealous!

If I was to go the 911 route I'd certainly be going for an old one, probably keep the Boxster too as well smile

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
I had a 07 plate Boxster as a courtesy car and it drove better than my C4S, handling felt more like my Elise and i would think overall would be more fun.Some people need the rear seats and also crave more power that the 911 has even though they may not use it and some people just have a bad attitude.smile

Also note that Chris Harris of Autocar has commented on the Cayman S being the best handling car Porsche make at the moment so not everyone thinks that the more expensive/powerful models are better which can also be seen with the reviews the new GT2 seems to be getting when compared to the GT3.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
I see lots of Boxster drivers going out of their way to look superior on the roads, the other day I was driving my orange peugeot 207 diesel and one came up behind me in slowish town traffic roof down, baseball cap on, right up my arse doing the "I'm driving a Porsche dontcha know" routine.

I tend not to see 911 drivers doing that. It's almost like Boxster drivers *think* they have something to prove. Not that they do as far as I'm concerned.

SM

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?

I've found my Boxster S to be a great all round sports car, which loves to be driven hard and has extremely good capabilities, no it's not a 911 neither does it pretend to be, they're two different ball games entirely, when will others get it into their heads?
Its because the Boxster represents the start of the demise of Porsche being a premium brand.

Dinoboy

2,600 posts

248 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Its because the Boxster represents the start of the demise of Porsche being a premium brand.
[/quote]



What about the 924 ?

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
KayC - Its because the Boxster represents the start of the demise of Porsche being a premium brand.

Not the Porsche 924 KayC? There is a myth that Porsche was a premium brand before the Boxster.

MaxAndRuby

6,792 posts

263 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
kayc said:
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?

I've found my Boxster S to be a great all round sports car, which loves to be driven hard and has extremely good capabilities, no it's not a 911 neither does it pretend to be, they're two different ball games entirely, when will others get it into their heads?
Its because the Boxster represents the start of the demise of Porsche being a premium brand.
And the beginning of them making a profit in the 90s. If they hadn't built the Boxster you would've never experienced your 996TT. Boxsters sell so well because they're fantastic cars. Like 3 series BMWs, for some reason some people feel the need to abuse them. As the OP said, usually from behind the wheel of utter sheds.

Boo152

979 posts

230 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?

I've found my Boxster S to be a great all round sports car, which loves to be driven hard and has extremely good capabilities, no it's not a 911 neither does it pretend to be, they're two different ball games entirely, when will others get it into their heads?
I had one of the first Boxsters in the UK back in '97, and thought it brilliant.

However, one day, sat outside the pub admiring it opposite on the car park when two blokes walked past,(who incidently had arrived in a Ford) and one said to the other:
"That looks a nice car, what is it?" "Oh its one of those new cheap Porsches" His mate replied. I was gutted!

And although I eventually traded it for a 911,(I found the 2.5 a bit underpowered), I still think Boxsters are great cars, especially the 'S' versions, so you carry on enjoying it!

pikey

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!
It's to wind you up... and it's worked!

Why? Not bothered by it are you? smile

kayc

4,492 posts

252 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
MaxAndRuby said:
kayc said:
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?

I've found my Boxster S to be a great all round sports car, which loves to be driven hard and has extremely good capabilities, no it's not a 911 neither does it pretend to be, they're two different ball games entirely, when will others get it into their heads?
Its because the Boxster represents the start of the demise of Porsche being a premium brand.
And the beginning of them making a profit in the 90s. If they hadn't built the Boxster you would've never experienced your 996TT. Boxsters sell so well because they're fantastic cars. Like 3 series BMWs, for some reason some people feel the need to abuse them. As the OP said, usually from behind the wheel of utter sheds.
They could have done what other manafacturers have done..make a relatively small amount of top quality cars and put prices up..they chose to produce shitloads of mass produced cars,keep the price nearly the same,dilute the brand name and make previous low depreciating cars into cars that lose money as quickly as BMW/audi/aston etc.I think this started around Boxster/996 time and its no surprise that air cooled's are bid and boxster launch cars onwards are offered..all imo of course..

Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all


It's jealousy.

I was driving the 911 in the City yesterday. A scruffy bloke in a green suit and slip on shoes walked across the road and pointed at me.

"Shit car." he said.

I pointed back.

"Shit life mate."



Koln-RS

4,129 posts

243 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
It's nothing to do with Boxsters - there are plenty of people with an irrational hatred of all sorts of cars - 4x4s probably come top, but busses, white vans, Volvos, BMWs, 'max-powered' tin tops, caravans, anything big and expensive, mini cabs....... .

You name it someone will hate it, and probably Boxsters and 911s in equal numbers. There's no logic, they probably just have a chip on their shoulder about something.

The motoring press don't have these isues. Since it was launched, the Boxster has always been regarded as the 'best medium sized roadster in the world', so it probably boilds down to envy.




car.chic

Original Poster:

5,995 posts

246 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Vesuvius 996 said:
It's jealousy.

I was driving the 911 in the City yesterday. A scruffy bloke in a green suit and slip on shoes walked across the road and pointed at me.

"Shit car." he said.

I pointed back.

"Shit life mate."
biggrin Fantastic rofl

Paracetamol

4,267 posts

275 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
Boxster (I've had a 2.5 and a 2.7) are amongst the best driving cars I have ever had. I love that they retain the nice meaty steering, brakes, pedals etc but feel so lithe on their feet. Contrast this to stuff like the Z4, SLK etc that just feel like 2 seater saloons.

Its jealousy and nothing else...that "cheap Porsche" is actually £40K which is double what most people who would make such a comment earn in a year.

My only gripe with them is residuals and this has always made me buy used (usually £40k to £23k trade in 3 years). Its great when they are down to early 20's however as they dont then drop a great deal more.

MaxAndRuby

6,792 posts

263 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
kayc said:
MaxAndRuby said:
kayc said:
car.chic said:
What is it with people really hating Boxsters?

If I had a £1 for everytime someone tells me I don't drive a real Porsche, or I drive the poverty spec Porsche or even (stating the obvious) It's not a 911 though, is it?!

One thing I have noticed the people who say this stuff are the ones driving about in shopping carts or family hacks. I wonder how many have actually driven a Boxster?

I've found my Boxster S to be a great all round sports car, which loves to be driven hard and has extremely good capabilities, no it's not a 911 neither does it pretend to be, they're two different ball games entirely, when will others get it into their heads?
Its because the Boxster represents the start of the demise of Porsche being a premium brand.
And the beginning of them making a profit in the 90s. If they hadn't built the Boxster you would've never experienced your 996TT. Boxsters sell so well because they're fantastic cars. Like 3 series BMWs, for some reason some people feel the need to abuse them. As the OP said, usually from behind the wheel of utter sheds.
They could have done what other manafacturers have done..make a relatively small amount of top quality cars and put prices up..they chose to produce shitloads of mass produced cars,keep the price nearly the same,dilute the brand name and make previous low depreciating cars into cars that lose money as quickly as BMW/audi/aston etc.I think this started around Boxster/996 time and its no surprise that air cooled's are bid and boxster launch cars onwards are offered..all imo of course..
Surely you can't be questioning the Porsche business plan since the Boxster? Do you really expect the Porsche board to sit around saying "Well this massive pile of cash we've generated is all well and good, but what about those tools with beards who don't want their engines coolled with water? Let's go back to the financial tightrope and release a sideline in horse brass and zovirax."

Porsche could never have gone down the route you're suggesting because they've always had 'cheap' cars. The 968 was still current when they commissioned the Boxster. They produced 'shitloads of mass produced cars' because the market wanted them. This would've happened in the 80s with the 924 if demand had been there.

Going further, they HAVE done what you suggested aswell. They produce the GT2/3/3RS, and the Carrera GT, non of which have suffered a bad reputation from the cheaper models. The win all round.

Pheedbak

704 posts

248 months

Tuesday 9th October 2007
quotequote all
I think its got something to do with it being a soft top they tend to get more abuse than a hard top equivalent....