964 or something newer?
964 or something newer?
Author
Discussion

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

6,336 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Some silly questions about prices I'm afraid.

Am I right in thinking £15K will get me a decent 964? And that they're reasonable cars to keep on the road with servicing etc from an indy?

I've driven a 964 cabrio, I found the car tramlined quite badly on the poorly surfaced roads we were using. It may just been that paticluar car but it didin't really feel planted, is the C4 much different?
Were options like air con and cruise rare on these, or just unlikely to work properly after 17 years?

Also the 993..... would mid 20's get a good one? And are they far superior to the 964 or just newer and prettier?

Then the 996, I like the looks of these less than the 993, but I've seen them going for around £20K which puts them into the "save a bit longer than the 964 league". I know they're all different but I'd like a realistic target before obsessing any further!

Whatever I get has to be manual, in a sane colour (basically not yellow or pink), and reliable.
I'm not really fussed about C2 or C4 as long as it feels good to drive.
And I'd like air con and criuse control (saves me speeding on long runs). It's just the pricing is a little hard to work out....

wildoliver

9,324 posts

247 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Yes.

Tramlining to a degree is a point made about all 911's, personally I never really found it an issue, but the car has a lot of grip so will grab a bit on rough roads, just get used to it.

C4 as a nice daily driver, c2 if you like to have fun.

993 is nice, and the better car imo but not worth the extra cash for the improvements unless you love the look, personally I prefer the 964 look so can't justify the extra cash.

Lots of dogs, but also lots of nice cars, Shouldn't have a problem with your colour choices either.

LeoSayer

7,863 posts

275 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
£15k should get you something nice.

You need to allow a fairly large maintenance budget should things go wrong, perhaps £2,000 per year. Some years you may only use £500, others you may use a lot more!

Tyres are £500 a set, a clutch change is £1000 from an indy, air con can be troublesome and cost well into 4 figures to fix if it doesn't work. I would say around half have it fitted (was an option). Top-end rebuilds cost upwards of £5,000 so be sure that doesn't need doing. Renewed suspension bits can cost £2000.

Classic insurance is cheap if you garage the car.

Convertible is quite wobbly compared to the coupe, so be sure this is what you want.


1231

122 posts

240 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
There's a couple of good threads on this start here

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Oh and buy the 964 - keep the 10K you'd spend on a 993 as your engine rebuild / high class tart fund.





Edited by 1231 on Thursday 11th October 13:39

robmug

1,047 posts

294 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
My 964 doesn't tramline; decent tyres & geometry should help.

Make sure any 964 you look at has the same tyres front and back, as they are very sensitive to tyres.

I've done 70,000 miles in mine and 30,000 in other 964s so I'm pretty used to them by now!

Drive a few and you'll quickly get the feel for a good one.

robmug

1,047 posts

294 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
I'd agree with LeoSayer above.

Also add brakes - new discs and pads all round plus a fluid change will be upwards of £500.

In short, you won;t pay much more for a car that has had new brakes, shocks, tyres, geometry, clutch etc, but it'll cost you a fortune ofyou have to do it all.

Best to buy a car that's been with the same owner for over a year. 964s are easy to run for nothing for a year...but the things that should have had money spent will all be saved up for the next buyer....

rich 36

13,739 posts

297 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Classifieds here are a good starting point and save a bit of legwork,

I saw a handful in flesh recently buying myself a 964.

Would suggest a thorough once over by almost anyone in the back of the monthly mag if seriously attracted to a car,
Oh and beware the lurid interiors

(Unless of course you like lurid interior)

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

6,336 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
I prefer dark interiors, but as long as the dash is black (so it won't reflect in the windscreen) I can cope with white leather!

I meant to say it has to be the coupe, I'm ginger (it's a curse!) so have no use for anything that will let in sunlight. No daywalkers here.

What about the 996? it does seem to be pretty unloved and available from about £18K. £3K for a 10 year younger car is a big step. I don't like the looks as much, and understand the driving experience may be less, but it's still 10 years younger.

Also are there any good indys around Aberdeen? My BMW goes to Insch (a slack 20 miles away) for servicing so I'm not worried about traveling for better work.

Edited by Speed addicted on Thursday 11th October 14:49

rich 36

13,739 posts

297 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Its the ginger reffernce chap,

They simply weren't ready so soon.

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

6,336 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Thought it'd gone quiet....

rich 36

13,739 posts

297 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
You were doing fine SA right up to the G bit,

Anyway, have you had any more thoughts on model?

Aircooled/ water

Former would be 964 and 993, water cooled then 996

nervous

24,050 posts

261 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
rich 36 said:
Its the ginger reffernce chap,

They simply weren't ready so soon.
hes right. i at least like to be told im handsome first. an expensive dinners always nice too.

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all


993 much cheaper to run than 964

robmug

1,047 posts

294 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
POORCARDEALER said:
993 much cheaper to run than 964
why? surely the only difference is hydraulic tappets...all other consumables/issues are identical...

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all


have a look at menu servicing prices for 964 v 993 , 993 substantially cheaper

Speed addicted

Original Poster:

6,336 posts

258 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Damn it, I always seem to come out too early!

For looks and noise I do prefer the air cooled cars, the 993 is realisticly going to be out of reach.
£15K ish is a reasonable amount for me to spend on a car, bearing in mind I tend to change about every year or so, and the fact I also have 3 motorbikes.
Buying a 911 is my current plan to find nirvana and stop buying cars, I've wanted one since I was 5.

The only thing that makes me think twice about the 964 is the 996. It's a lot younger and possibly more reliable due to less things being worn out. But as I've also noticed with my various BMWs the newer car's tend to get fatter and softer.

What I really need to do is get off this rig and go test drive a couple of each.



POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
Damn it, I always seem to come out too early!

For looks and noise I do prefer the air cooled cars, the 993 is realisticly going to be out of reach.
£15K ish is a reasonable amount for me to spend on a car, bearing in mind I tend to change about every year or so, and the fact I also have 3 motorbikes.
Buying a 911 is my current plan to find nirvana and stop buying cars, I've wanted one since I was 5.

The only thing that makes me think twice about the 964 is the 996. It's a lot younger and possibly more reliable due to less things being worn out. But as I've also noticed with my various BMWs the newer car's tend to get fatter and softer.

What I really need to do is get off this rig and go test drive a couple of each.


964 is a cracking car, just make sure it isnt leaking oil badly.........a good un you with fall in love with, a bad one will cost you a fortune

robmug

1,047 posts

294 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
POORCARDEALER said:
have a look at menu servicing prices for 964 v 993 , 993 substantially cheaper
OK, done that.

Regular servicing is more for 964, but clutch & brakes more expensive on 993.

Prices from Hartech: (964 vs 993)

Extended 12,000 mile service: £680 vs £640
Clutch £930 vs £1050
Front brake pads & discs £285 vs £340
Rear brake pads & discs £285 vs £330

(Admittedly the 'standard' 12k service is £560 vs £350, but the differential decreases if you go for the extended service)

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
Speed addicted said:
What I really need to do is get off this rig and go test drive a couple of each.


There ya go!

My first drive in a 996 reminded me very much of the 320i I had at the time .. Obviously loads more poke with the 996 , but the steering , pedals , 'box were comfortable to my beemer muscle memory.

The 996 turned out to be a far far better car , with much better reliability than the beemer though...

Imho , the 996 should have better reliability compared to the 964... But both work well with gravel drives wink

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Thursday 11th October 2007
quotequote all
robmug said:
POORCARDEALER said:
have a look at menu servicing prices for 964 v 993 , 993 substantially cheaper
OK, done that.

Regular servicing is more for 964, but clutch & brakes more expensive on 993.

Prices from Hartech: (964 vs 993)

Extended 12,000 mile service: £680 vs £640
Clutch £930 vs £1050
Front brake pads & discs £285 vs £340
Rear brake pads & discs £285 vs £330

(Admittedly the 'standard' 12k service is £560 vs £350, but the differential decreases if you go for the extended service)
Having owned quite a few of both Rob, I have found the 993 to be a cheaper car to run overall, maybe its partly down to the 993 been a year or two newer, but the 964s I have owned have seemed to need more running repairs than the 993s