Tiptronic question
Tiptronic question
Author
Discussion

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
So here's the thing. Leave the tip in auto mode, it changes up and down like an auto. Ok so far.
Push the stick over into manual mode. Now, I have full control over the gears with the steering wheel buttons, right? Well, no, it still bloody changes up when it gets to the redline. Or actually, a bit before.
Can the box be changed via plugging something in so that the up changes are manual as well? It's getting on my t1ts.

Cheers


Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
Tiptronic will always change at the limits to protect the engine.

IMO the auto mode is slightly unlike a regular auto, kickdown in particular I found quite different - you cannot just bury the throttle, you actually needed to give it a light kick.

I'm still waiting for DSG - anyone know why this is taking Porsche so long? - especially as they are related to audi and it's been available on those for simply ages and ages..

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
Globulator said:
Tiptronic will always change at the limits to protect the engine.

IMO the auto mode is slightly unlike a regular auto, kickdown in particular I found quite different - you cannot just bury the throttle, you actually needed to give it a light kick.

I'm still waiting for DSG - anyone know why this is taking Porsche so long? - especially as they are related to audi and it's been available on those for simply ages and ages..
Ok yep I can get that it changes at the limit, but then a manual doesn't, so why can't I have mine so I choose when to change up???
And what's DSG?


Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
DSG - Direct Shift Gearbox

http://www.vw-personal.de/www/en/wissen/entwicklun...

It is a dual clutch pre-selector auto I guess. As efficient as a manual with the convenience of an auto. The only down side is a little more weight as it uses an extra shaft.

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
I drove one of the tip 911's (996) at Jonathan Plamer day about a year go

I wa stold the car had a software reprog and there where extra paddles added. Their cars had no probs bouncing of the red line and holding gears - may be worth contacting them to see who did their onversions.

cheers

simes69

56 posts

239 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Globulator said:
Tiptronic will always change at the limits to protect the engine.

IMO the auto mode is slightly unlike a regular auto, kickdown in particular I found quite different - you cannot just bury the throttle, you actually needed to give it a light kick.
Yeah - gas pedal needs a sharp kick to get jiggy with it. If you squeeze the pedal down to the carpet nothing happens. Think it's the built-in Wife Driving Protection System.

Stealth997

388 posts

239 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Ray - Mine 997S does not change up in manual mode but it does flat-line. (if that's the correct terminology)I guess there's a limiter of some sort but it does not take back control from you.




KGB1

245 posts

262 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
On the 997 with the sport switch on, you can hold it in gear until the rods come out the side of the block!!

Kev

Ray Luxury-Yacht

Original Poster:

8,918 posts

247 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
confused

Well that's how I want mine to be, but it bloody changes up for me even in manual mode. Is annoying enough to have started dulling the relationship with my new car now, to the extent I'm toying with the idea of moving it on already mad

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
confused

Well that's how I want mine to be, but it bloody changes up for me even in manual mode. Is annoying enough to have started dulling the relationship with my new car now, to the extent I'm toying with the idea of moving it on already mad
One of the main things that annoyed me about the tip was the refusal of Porsche to put the up and down shift also on the gear stick.

Fiddly buttons are sometimes OK, but quite often I was feeling for the lever to nudge it up or down a gear, and then cursing them for not having done it. Given an Audi TT comes with a proper DSG and up/down via the stick, I felt rather short changed with the tiptronic, and could ony buy the manual.

Tiptronic gripes:
No DSG - why not when vw/audi have it? Porsche is _supposed_ to be better.
No change on the stick
Steering wheel buttons too fiddly
Non-standard kick-down
Drinks fuel
No DSG - does a slush-box really belong in a sports car?

kent993

385 posts

274 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Globulator said:
Tiptronic gripes:

No change on the stick
Steering wheel buttons too fiddly
I'm puzzled by the comment about no change on the stick. On my Tiptronic box I have a choice in manual between using the buttons on the steering wheel and using the stick, shoving it forward or back to change gear rather like a DSG box (though I know it's not the same). I agree that the steering wheel buttons are a bit fiddly and I imagine paddles would be better, but you can learn to live with them.

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
kent993 said:
Globulator said:
Tiptronic gripes:

No change on the stick
Steering wheel buttons too fiddly
I'm puzzled by the comment about no change on the stick. On my Tiptronic box I have a choice in manual between using the buttons on the steering wheel and using the stick, shoving it forward or back to change gear rather like a DSG box (though I know it's not the same). I agree that the steering wheel buttons are a bit fiddly and I imagine paddles would be better, but you can learn to live with them.
I was using a Boxster S (2005 - new shape), when you slid it to the RHS to select manual mode, that was it - you could only change with the buttons after that.

I could learn to live with the buttons if I did all my driving in a straight line, but my usual roads are fairly rural and generally involve moving the steering more than half a turn quite often. Even after a few hours I was still having to play 'hunt the button', instead of just changing gear which would have been easy with the stick (or a manual).

All I ended up doing was getting annoyed and sticking it back in auto - when I had to re-learn how to kick down an auto.

On audi/vw cars you can use the stick in manual mode (RHS) to nudge it back and forth to change up or down. It's just the steering-wheel buttons repeated on the RHS of the shift.


You can see the + and - printed on the audi, for up and down gears.

Erik997

1,289 posts

239 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Globulator said:
kent993 said:
Globulator said:
Tiptronic gripes:

No change on the stick
Steering wheel buttons too fiddly
I'm puzzled by the comment about no change on the stick. On my Tiptronic box I have a choice in manual between using the buttons on the steering wheel and using the stick, shoving it forward or back to change gear rather like a DSG box (though I know it's not the same). I agree that the steering wheel buttons are a bit fiddly and I imagine paddles would be better, but you can learn to live with them.
I was using a Boxster S (2005 - new shape), when you slid it to the RHS to select manual mode, that was it - you could only change with the buttons after that.

I could learn to live with the buttons if I did all my driving in a straight line, but my usual roads are fairly rural and generally involve moving the steering more than half a turn quite often. Even after a few hours I was still having to play 'hunt the button', instead of just changing gear which would have been easy with the stick (or a manual).

All I ended up doing was getting annoyed and sticking it back in auto - when I had to re-learn how to kick down an auto.

On audi/vw cars you can use the stick in manual mode (RHS) to nudge it back and forth to change up or down. It's just the steering-wheel buttons repeated on the RHS of the shift.


You can see the + and - printed on the audi, for up and down gears.


Its true. On Boxster/996/997 you cannot change gears in manual mode using the gearlever - only using the steering wheel buttons. On 993 Tips you can do both.

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Why do most manufacturers put the + - function on the stick back to front?

To my mind it's far more intuitive to pull for upshifts and push for downshifts but most are set up the other way 'round.

Pat Cash

312 posts

261 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
So here's the thing. Leave the tip in auto mode, it changes up and down like an auto. Ok so far.
Push the stick over into manual mode. Now, I have full control over the gears with the steering wheel buttons, right? Well, no, it still bloody changes up when it gets to the redline. Or actually, a bit before.
Can the box be changed via plugging something in so that the up changes are manual as well? It's getting on my t1ts.

Cheers
Turn off PSM - I think that'll cure it on a 9x7 (although can't remember if you have to have sport chrono woth sport mode on)

kent993

385 posts

274 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Globulator said:
Explained about Boxster version....
Thanks - I'm no longer puzzled! smile

tonikaram

324 posts

241 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
pdV6 said:
Why do most manufacturers put the + - function on the stick back to front?

To my mind it's far more intuitive to pull for upshifts and push for downshifts but most are set up the other way 'round.
Me and you are the only people (well a few friends too) who feel that way. In BMW's, at least, it was setup correctly.
In some Mercedes's it's setup sideways!!!! :S Why not just hang something from the ceiling to pull on while they're at it...

Kay

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Ray Luxury-Yacht said:
So here's the thing. Leave the tip in auto mode, it changes up and down like an auto. Ok so far.
Push the stick over into manual mode. Now, I have full control over the gears with the steering wheel buttons, right? Well, no, it still bloody changes up when it gets to the redline. Or actually, a bit before.
Can the box be changed via plugging something in so that the up changes are manual as well? It's getting on my t1ts.

Cheers
You're driving like a pussy.... When you start to press on it only changes up at the red line wink

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
tonikaram said:
pdV6 said:
Why do most manufacturers put the + - function on the stick back to front?

To my mind it's far more intuitive to pull for upshifts and push for downshifts but most are set up the other way 'round.
Me and you are the only people (well a few friends too) who feel that way. In BMW's, at least, it was setup correctly.
In some Mercedes's it's setup sideways!!!! :S Why not just hang something from the ceiling to pull on while they're at it...

Kay
Actually BMW have done it both ways round!! When the old E36 M3 SMG came out, it was forward for down. Simultaneously the Tiptronic auto was released in other models which was forward for up. This then changed to the other way round in late 2002 (I think) so at last the range was consistent. You can only imagine how confusing it can be when you're getting in and out of different cars all day, demonstrating them on test drives and so on, and forgetting which way round the particular you're in is configured!!

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
tonikaram said:
pdV6 said:
Why do most manufacturers put the + - function on the stick back to front?

To my mind it's far more intuitive to pull for upshifts and push for downshifts but most are set up the other way 'round.
Me and you are the only people (well a few friends too) who feel that way.
It just feels better that way round; when you're accelerating (and therefore going up the box and your weight is to the rear) it's easier to pull the gearchange and vice versa for braking.