968 CS, or 944 turbo ??
968 CS, or 944 turbo ??
Author
Discussion

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi, am thinking of either of these for mainly weekend use and very occasional track day/driving trips. Does anyone have a view/experience as to which is "best" in terms of reliability, handling, "fun" etc etc.

thanks in advance.


johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
I've heard 968's are far better than GT3s, so that would be my suggestion.....

mollytherocker

14,472 posts

240 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi

I would personally go for the 968CS. They are a great track car and easy (relatively!) to handle around the limit. The 944 Turbo is a little trickier in terms of throttle control on the limit due to the turbo spooling in. However, if you want to tune the engine, the turbo is the one to go for. A reliable 300bhp is possible from a good car.

Good luck!

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
hi, many thanks. Yes, i'm told its difficult to increase the output on the 968, and obviously quite easy on the 944t. Personally, i much prefer driving non turbo cars, but must admit like the appeal of boosting the output. THe 968 has a more contemporary look, and am inclined to go for the CS as its was designed for the track, but am trying to find out if they are as robust as the 944.

cheers

Riverside

319 posts

249 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
nickb55 said:
THe 968 has a more contemporary look, and am inclined to go for the CS as its was designed for the track, but am trying to find out if they are as robust as the 944.
Not alot to separate them in terms of robustness, the turbo has a few things that can be expensive if they go wrong but then the variocam & cam chain on a 968 is expensive too if it's in poor repair.

Get the best you can find of either, the CS has a lot going for it but so does the turbo. You can do pretty well the same suspension & brake mods to either.

diver944

1,855 posts

307 months

Saturday 13th October 2007
quotequote all
Reliability wise they are much of a muchness, both being built in the late 80's early 90's when Porsches were hewn out of solid granite. Both have their weaknesses though, and both will be over 15 years old so things will obviously wear out and need replacing.

The Turbo will probably have a weak wastegate and be much laggier than it should be if it is still standard. The 968 needs to have it's cam chain and tensioner inspected fairly regularly as failure will be expensive. Both of them need to have the cam belts and balance shaft belts replaced regularly. On track they are both fantastic cars and if the suspension and brakes have recently been refreshed they can easily embarress many modern exotica.

It really comes down to your preference in body styling or whichever one you can find in the better condition for your budget. Obviously 968's are newer and in general are in better condition , but they are much rarer. 944's are much more plentiful and should be easier to find, but likewise there are a hell of a lot of tired old dogs that could be money pits of you do not buy wisely

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
thanks v much. think i'm going to focus on the CS, and as you say not that many around, but am happy to pay low teens, so hopefully will find a decent one.

thanks again
Nick

Pheedbak

704 posts

248 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
good choice .. take a look at http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/261874.htm

no affiliation or anything seems like a good car with less miles and cheaper than what i paid for mine!! And i know the guy from the 968 forums..

Anyhow good source of info @ http://www.968uk.com/

happy shopping smile

Phil

Edited by Pheedbak on Sunday 14th October 10:41

ash7764

35 posts

230 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi nik, The lads have dished out some sound advice to you and this forum is great help for tricky decision makings. I think you could have some great fun with a nice 944 se turbo, they are superb cars and as you know they come standard 250bhp and with a bit of promax upgrade they top 300 no probs and with a bit more spent u can really start flying. I think 968 model is ok'ish but personally couldnt eat a whole one. Its a cross breed between a 944 and 928. At least witha 944 it has its own distinctive shape and commands a lot of respect.

i own a 944 se turbo, last of the 1991 models, each time i drive it and the turbo kiks in it takes your breath away, its alive and breathes with you. The lads are perfectly right when they say thers a few tired old dogs out there when it comes too the 944 turbo but just look carefully and find a well maintained one. you will see when u go to any porsche shows how much these beasts are loved..theres always a flock of people round them...the 968's are usualy down the bottom by the tree's. (poor things)... "not that i got anything against them"..honest! good luck nik.

ph123

1,841 posts

249 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
The 968 in Clubsport form, won 'sports car of the year'/Autocar's 'Best Handling' in 1993 and it's handling is truely wonderful. 6-speed box and reasonably light and modern compared to the 944 Turbo which was heavier and better equipped.
A good example of either are budget supercar bargins I think.
Clubsport will remain a 'classic' for ever.

chfs911

694 posts

257 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
Just back from Knockhill Supercar day. I kept getting asked what was under the bonnet of my CS. It is standard bar a chip. They could not believe it!

I could stick wth most things including 600bhp F40. No not on the staights but lap for lap I was having to brake early to let him get around the hairpin corners.

You can't go wrong with the CS. Lovely balanced car.

Smiffack993

177 posts

244 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
I had a lovely black with red decals 968 cs. It gains the utmost respect on road trips such as Le Mans, GP etc. The car creates much attention and is a fantastic drive. Do the 968 CS!

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the very encouraging replies. Can't wait to find one now. Just one (probably stupid) Q on the CS, is it reasonably "comfortable" to drive on eneven country roads? ie. tolerable. I ask because most of the time, it's blasting round country lanes that i would be doing, rather than the odd day on a nice (relatively) smooth track. I used to have a porsche with PASM, and in sport mode u were out of your seat sometimes on bumpy country lanes (or maybe i just didnt drive very well!)

cheers
Nick

Edited by nickb55 on Monday 15th October 14:48

willdew

2,138 posts

295 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
nickb55 said:
...is it reasonably "comfortable" to drive on eneven country roads? ie. tolerable. I ask because most of the time, it's blasting round country lanes that i would be doing, rather than the odd day on a nice (relatively) smooth track...
Depends what you're used to. The MO30 option included uprated suspension, that's firmer than std. Also, if a car's still on it's original suspension, it'll be a minimum of 12 year old by now, so probably need uprating. KW Variant 3 is the most popular choice. I'd suggest it's worth keeping an eye out for one that's had it done already.

Also, the "Sport" was a UK only model which was a Club Sport with a few options ticked, so don't discount them. They don't weight much more at all (20 - 30kgs tops), and electric windows and boot release aren't bad things to have. They were made on the same production line, with the same sequence of chassis numbers.

ph123

1,841 posts

249 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
NickB - there are 4 showing for sale right now on Pistonheads Classifieds.

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
yes, thanks, have called about a couple. There's a nice looking white one (red wheels mmm!), at a garage in suffolk. Selling for someone who has a bunch of porsches. Had a big rebuild recently (5k), but 10 owners. Had more work done on brakes etc. Never sure if a lot of work is a good thing (ie. it's done and wont need doing again), or a bad thing in that it indicates constant problems/abuse. I'm going to speak to the chap who's advertising the red CS this evening. I also called Peter Morgan with a view to checking over whatever car i end up getting. When i said i was looking for a 968cs, he said "Excellent choice!".

Mikeoupe

303 posts

252 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
If the 'big rebuild recently' included replacement cams / chains that's possibly a good thing as they are prone to wear, if the work to the brakes was to cure plate lift then again, that would also be a good thing. Let us know what you find out.